Alfonso's Pizza

Fresh, generous toppings without going overboard; just the right amount of cheese; crisp, fragrant base (obviously house made with love & not mass produced); cooked and ready exactly when promised; friendly service; the extra large is HUGE! I recommend you give our new local a try!

What a wonderful place, Pizza was amazing, fresh and authentic - not fabricated. Quality for the price. Gentleman that served me were nice.

Just moved to the bay, stumbled across this place and wow!! Pizzas are absolutely delicious. My husband and I had the margarita and it tasted as great as it looked!
Had a nice chat to the lovely owner who really puts his heart and soul into making the pizzas which reflects in the taste! Can’t wait to go back 🤤

Delicious pizza! Large slices that fill your appetite! The owner was really friendly and welcoming. Will definitely be back again! 🍕

Picked up a slice of Hot Chik as part of my second lunch and I’m very glad I did. First time trying a pizza slice shop in Australia and I hope they’re all as good. Good crispy base and loved the cream sauce drizzled over the top. Good gelato too.

Phenomenal pizza. Really friendly owner.
Seemed very expensive, but pieces are huge.
2 slices and a drink for $15 was enough for a delicious lunch.
If I was local, I'd be here weekly.

Just got a lamb bryani calzone (always great), and a slice of margarita pizza for my 8 year old daughter. Half way through the slice, I was made to go back to the shop so she could tell the owner she rates this place 30 out of 10! 10 points for the happy friendly service; and 20 points for how good the pizza was! Can't get much better than that.
We'll be back again!

Great pizza, will definitely be back again.

This is the first google review I have left, and it’s absolutely deserving. We purchased 1 of every slice yesterday & 2 calzones - each as delicious as the last and marvelled over how excited we are to have discovered this place and to return over and over. The owner was incredibly hospitable! 10/10 ⭐ 🍕 Thank you!

The most amazing - huge pizzas. We ordered two and the were ready on time, hot and delicious. Will be back again for sure!

Have been getting this pizza at least once or twice a week for the last few months and have to say absolutely delicious, it is the best pizza I’ve come across!! Personal fave is the angry Hawaiian but you can’t go wrong with any selection. Shout out to the bay scaff boys AKA the pizza deleters we are still chasing that garlic prawn special!

My husband shared his slice of pepperoni with me on the weekend. I had maybe 3 bites of it & I can honestly say it was SERIOUSLY DELICIOUS and I can’t stop thinking about it. So so good!! I wish I lived closer 🤩🤩🤩

This is the best Pizza I have ever eaten. Im hooked. So fresh, tasting and an amazing base. Excellent choices to pick from. The service is 5 star. Husband now also a fan. He wants the pizza base recipe lol. Such a friendly place to visit. Great work Brad. Cheers Charlie

Each time we visit Nelson Bay we head here for some lunch. Fantastic pizza and calzone . Owner is friendly and very accomadating.

Great pizza so good to have a good pizza in the bay

Best pizza in all of Port Stephens. The owner is really friendly too. 10/10

Always amazing to come in, being local it’s nice to have some fresh authentic pizza after a long day, best customer service and amazing atmosphere

Omg! Best pizza I’ve ever had! The tradies lunch special is a bargain!

2nd time here,Incredible pizza, we made a special side trip to come back
Going to be pizza for lunch and pizza for dinner.

Owner is awesome, great Pizza quick and easy if you want to grab something on the go