Pizza This Pizza That Baxter

I've ordered from Pizza This Pizza That multiple times over the years and I think they're a great pizza place.
The lasagna is always nice and I like that they have bechemel sauce included in theirs.
I got a BBQ chicken pizza. I did not really enjoy this, but this is just personal taste and not any fault of the restaurant. The pizza looked great and had a perfect, generous amount of toppings. The base is definitely one of the best I've ever had, it's not too thick, not too thin and was cooked perfectly! Next time I will get my normal flavour! The pizzas I personally love are Aussie and Supreme (none of those prawns/anchovies/olive things added though because I am boring and basic).
I ordered through UberEats and you cannot see delivery as the restaurant delivers their own food. Expected arrival was 8:15-8:35pm and the delivery guy arrived at exactly 8:15pm. When I have ordered delivery they have always been punctual. I ordered a drink as well which was creamy soda. They had none in stock but the delivery driver came out with a bag of choices, which I think is great customer service and a really thoughtful gesture that I've never come across before, so thanks! That was definitely noticed!

What a great pizza place ! Worth the drive from Carrum Downs. Service was great too.

We love this place! Lucky to live just around the corner and come to pick up pizzas or even just the amazing garlic bread at least a few times a week! Their Aussie pizza is the best, even without the meat like I normally get on one half. So much flavor and many options! They accommodate all our pizza requests, and even treat us with a drink or dessert every now and again. Always craving this pizza, always will :) give them a try, you won’t be disappointed!!

I think this is the best pizza I’ve ever had in Australia. The garlic cheese and mexicana pizzas are incredible. Can feed a family for under 40 bucks. Incredible

Ever since my favourite childhood pizza place shut down my family has been on the hunt for a new favourite. We found Pizza This Pizza That about a year ago and have been ordering from there ever since.

Tonight I tried the Spicey Special pizza and it was the perfect amount of heat, couldn't fault it at all. My wife, being a creature of habit, got a Caesar Salad and she says it's the best Caesaer when compared to other pizza restaurants in the area.

Beautiful fresh and piping hot pizzas with generous but not too many toppings. Best hot chips in town, great salads, pastas and chocolate mousse. We've ordered many different items from their menu and never had any complaints.

Delivery is usually on time, give or take 10 minutes. Good with order notes, delivery staff are always friendly and pricing is good value for the great quality you get.

My favourite "go to" pizza is Hawaiian and I tried about 10 different pizza restaurants in the area trying to find a good Hawaiian (seems to be a saturation of pizza restaurants in my area but difficult to find a good one) and Pizza This Pizza That destroys the competition. Perfect bases, great ratio of ingredients 10/10.

Best in VIC? Pizza This Pizza That has my vote.

Live in Somerville and use to swear by Pepe’s but honestly they have gone down hill and this is the place to go if your local. Amazing pizza. Meals are nice too

Beautiful service and wonderful fresh pizza... the owner was so nice and even gave us a complimentary dessert... we will be back for sure

Good pizza. The pizza here is of a high quality, and I personally enjoyed it a lot. So did my family. I'm glad I chose this pizza shop out of all the other ones I could have chosen.

Thank you for making such good Pizza, Pizza This Pizza That Baxter. :) I hope your business continues to thrive as covid happens.

My usual here is the Spicey Special (consistently good), but last night I tried the Souvlaki pizza. It was very tasty, and I was most impressed with the really generous amount of lamb. They could improve their communication when deliveries are running late, but overall a great pizza place.

Positive reviews lead me to this place...so impressed! From the outside it doesn’t look much. If you could see inside you would see what a well run place this is! Best Pizzas I’ve ever had... looking forward to trying more on the menu!

10/10 every time. Been ordering from here for 7+ years and the quality is always great. They deliver the food very quickly and I've never had a bad pizza from here. I highly recommend it.

If you ask very nicely, and order a family dozed pepperoni with extra pepperoni, and you tell them that you really, really, like pepperoni, it will cost a little extra, and you will get the greatest pepperoni pizza experience of your life. Huzzah!

First time here bought 2 large pizzas capricosa and supreme and omg absolute perfection. Very generous toppings and light base and crispy cheesy edges. Not oily and salty. Back to loving pizzas again!

This place is hand down one of the best pizza places I have ever had the privilege of ordering from, the tandoori and the suvlaki pizza 🍕 were just amazing and great customer service when delivering in the heavy rain! Thanks guys I will be ordering again

Absolutely Love Pizzas here, especially the Gluten Free Marinara pizza.The best.

Very good service, the pizzas are amazing top quality, will be back for more yumyy pizza

Awesome Pizza and amazing customer service! Zac the owner is always friendly! I would give them 6 out of 5 stars if I could.

By far the best service we have ever received! Unfortunately the staff was having a hard time tonight as they were absolutely flat out! Our food took longer than expected and there were a few issues but a 5 minute phone and our meal was replaced and delivered free of charge. The staff we dealt with were very apologetic and the food was delicious! Thanks guys!

Honestly the best pizza place I've found, with wonderful service and delicious ribs and pastas!!! Will definitely be eating from here again :))

Absolutely delicious!
Our family enjoyed the supreme pizza and the Seafood Risotto 😘😘😘😘
If we could give more than 5 stars we would.
Clarke Family