Bellvale Market

We found this amazing little market on google maps near the AirBnb that we rented while in NY for our son's graduation. We were staying in Greenwood Lakes which is kinda far from any decent grocery stores. When I found this market place I read the reviews on google & they were all pretty decent, so I sent my husband & daughter. When they came back, all they could do was talk about the place & all the fresh meats & seafood they had. My daughter was raving about how the wife who 'especially' went in the back & got her some Italian Crema for our fruit, and then made sure to show them where the Sicilian Virgian Olive Oil was. (My husband's family is Italian) So this made him VERY happy!!! My daughter was super happy because they make their Mozzarella daily. Their prices were also very decent!!

I would suggest this market to anyone especially if you are looking for fresh meat or seafood.

I have to say I was a little worried about ordering food from a place I was not familiar with, living two hours away. Dara was very reassuring and I knew by talking with her I was in great hands for my daughter’s wedding. The food was exceptional from start to finish and would highly recommend them for your catering occasion.

Local gem. Top quality deli, fresh meat, seafood, fresh delicious side dishes, fresh
in-house made motz, and Italian market goods. Recommend calling in your Deli sandwich orders. Market small and can get crowded. Not inexpensive but quality, especially so close, rarely is.

My second time there everything is perfect great customer service great food clean environment best spot in Warwick ny

So good! In addition to standard (and delicious) deli offerings, they have a huge variety of high quality fresh meat and fish, pre-made frozen sauces, soups, appetizers, and meals. And the sandwich I had was definitely made with Boars Head meat (I watched), anyone that says otherwise is mistaken. Overall, definitely worth the trip - I will definitely be back.

Outstanding fresh, high-quality meat, seafood..(best in the surrounding area), deli salads and fresh real italian bread all kinds of sweets too. The premade frozen take away meals are high end and the menu is extensive, and you can not go wrong. everyone is super nice and helpful. The place is SPOTLESS clean!

Friendliest small deli. Sandwiches are better than superb.

We took a chance on Bellvale Market to cater our local wedding of about 60 and the food was very good. Knowledgeable staff assisted with quantities and menu selection. The owner delivered the food and made sure everything was good before leaving. We went with:
- (2) large charcuterie boards, mini arancini, and assorted artisan breads for the cocktail hour. Breads were fresh baked and boards included good assortment of fresh mozzarella and deli meats
- caprese salad to start. Fresh summer salad to kick off the meal
- chicken picatta and sausage and peppers with brocolli rabe, green beans, and fingerling potatoes as the main. Everything was fresh and there was plenty of food
Would 100% recommend to others and use again in the future.

This deli has amazing food! We cater all of our family functions from here. We moved here from bergen county and have high standards! I highly recommend this place.

Oh gosh. My family loves this place. They keep us fed. Since moving to the area this deli has been a pleasure to be near. They have fresh seafood, meat, salads, and sides daily. The soups made there are so good. Menu seems to rotate daily or bi daily. They make things from scratch or source them from good importers. Even the frozen stuff is yummy!

Also, the consistent friendly faces from the workers is really heartwarming. They slowly start to remember you.

I heard they do big meals and catering but I have never tried any.

An outstanding deli for seafood, poultry, meat and amazing side dishes!

Quality food and quality service. I consider this a local salumeria, something I missed since moving from Staten Island. Meat is fresh, fish is fresh, mozzarella is fresh, and the staff is pleasant. This is the taste of Italy I’ve been desiring since moving here. Love it.

Ordered catering for Christmas and the food was amazing!

Absolutely delicious sandwiches and salads!

I just ate a chicken Parm sandwich that literally put tears in my eyes. Hands down the best heroes in the 845 no cap

Their food is delicious. Whether it be sandwiches from the deli counter, pre-packaged meals to go, fresh fish, etc... everything I've ordered has been great.

Would love to see some outdoor seating on the porch one day.

Also, would be a great coffee stop on the way to work in the AM if they could advertise it more and make it accessible :)

Absolutely incredible, quality food. Their subs/sandwiches are some of the best I've ever had. Really amazing place. Highly, highly recommend

Always a favorite, frequent flyers here! Best fresh fish around, excellent meat choices and plenty of made already meals, fresh or fozen, salads and deli counter!

I ordered three dinners just yesterday; it was my first time trying Bellvale Market and they did not disappoint! The food was delicious and the service great. I will definitely be returning very soon!

Bought their fresh burgers to grill at home, they were unbelievable. All my guests loved them!