Finders Keepers

The store is filled with all kinds of unique and fun items and is my go to for present’s. I love supporting this hometown shop!

Finders Keepers by Peggy Rima in Palmer Lake, is a giftshop that is now owned by the lovely Sherina O'neil. Featuring (and supporting) local artists you will find unique gifts that you really can’t purchase anywhere else.

Hand thrown locally made pottery, handcrafted birdhouses made from 100% recycled materials, hand decorated journals, watercolor paintings, jewelry made from old watches, local honey, hand made candles and cards.

Paperweights made from decorated rocks, scarves, bags, gloves and the ever popular Palmer Lake hoodies and tees.

This little store has something for everyone, along with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The ‘Finders Keepers’ name says it all, you may buy the gift for someone else, but will end up wanting to keep it for yourself!

Be sure to pay this store a visit next time you’re in Palmer Lake, you’ll be so happy you did!

The store is organized so nicely and Sherina was so kind and helpful I can't wait to tell all my friends to check out this great shop. Finders Keepers is a great place to shop and Sherina is fabulous ✌🧡just love the treasures I found especially my kitty rock painted by a local artist

I stopped in this cute little shop on a weekday. I was in the area eating lunch with my husband and going on a little walk around the lake. My husband had to head out and I found this little gem of a place. They had the cutest stuff! I bought these adorable green earrings that were geometric shaped with green beads. I plan on wearing them on St. Patrick's Day. Everything is made by local artists. Truly unique gifts. The store owner was so friendly and helpful. I enjoyed chatting with her. You can tell she takes a lot of pride in her place. It's been in her family for years. I plan on visiting next time I go to Palmer lake.

Love this store! It has the most unique items and features a lot of local artists, and the artists are very good. Some stores like hers are not as discerning as she is and it makes a difference. We discovered it when we were roaming around looking for Autumn splendor. The owner Sherina could not be more pleasant. I enjoyed shopping for some unique handcrafted items for Christmas.

I absolutely love this store! Finders Keepers is my go to store when I’m looking for something really special. It is full of items from local artisans and always has great holiday gifts. Everyone working there is so friendly and will help you find the perfect gift.

I moved away from the area within the last year and had always loved shopping at Finders Keepers for unique gifts for friends and family.(local art work, honey, pottery and jewelry along my favorites) I am missing Palmer Lake and reached out to Sherina to get some help finding some Palmer Lake T’s/hoodies and she went above and beyond to help me find perfect items. I received my package today and everything is just perfect. She even included a little extra couple of goodies that brought tears to my eyes remembering fondly all of my ears in Palmer Lake. Highly highly recommend this shop and Sherina is wonderful to offer help and suggestions

We loved renting a Kayak here! Family oriented. You won’t be disappointed. We’ll be back with family and friends.

I go here so often! Sherena always has something new, and I never walk out empty handed. She is such a sweetheart, and her items are priced well and good quality. Stop by when you can!

Looking for a present for a family member or friend or even yourself? Look no farther than Finders Keepers! I am not a family member of Sherina’s but I am local to Palmer Lake since 2003. I knew Peggy Rimas who started this lovely gift shop. My husband has gotten great advice from Peggy and Sherina!
There are many items made by local artists that you can wear(jewelry) or hang on your walls.
Christmas is coming up and they say to send your presents as soon as you can!
Don’t miss this store and support local😀

I love this store and the wonderful people who run it! Best place to shop in Palmer Lake! Lots of really unique gifts (jewelry, clothing, home decor) from local artisans.

Just when your out for a Fall Saturday afternoon bite to eat and some photos of the beautiful Fall leaves, if you're lucky you'll venture into a Fantastic lil shop in Palmer Lakes, Colorado.
The narrow winding streets of this small community are lined with quaint shops, bars, wine bistros, hair salons & places you didn't know you needed, like "Finders Keepers" a small and well organized jewel box filled with the works of some 53+ locally artisans hand selected and curated by the Owner, Sheridan O'Neil. The perfect place to find "Made with Love" jewelry from 16 different artists, Local honey products, candles, stunning pottery, simply Devine handmade & unique" one of a kind" Birdhouses and those treasured little special "Gifts" you know will forever be remembered like the Original Photography prints cards and beautiful handmade frames by local Artist, Eileen Skahill.
I was told the "Elves" a.k.a. Sherina is working round the clock readying hundreds of Christmas Goodies for her "Black Friday" Sale where she will proudly share her Boutique and "Special Pricing" to kick off the Holidays. But Do Not wait, the shop is filled with Specialty items that will be long gone before we've enjoyed our Thanksgiving Birds this year!

This unique shop is THE BEST for finding one of a kind gifts for friends and family, as well as decor for my own home!!! The owner/staff are super friendly and knowledgeable and willing to go above and beyond to make sure I leave happy!

Sherina is personable and goes above and beyond. Not to mention that this is the perfect store to find any perfect gifts!

Love this little shop! Both the owner and manager are great people, not to mention their fantastic customer service! The variety of of gifts etc. are unmatched!

What a great shop! Lots of unique gifts and a great number of them are by local artists! Very friendly staff to boot! ⭐

Great little local shop. Stuffed with lots of locally made things as well a other lovely stuff. Great jewelry. Good prices.

This place is a super cute shop with amazing local gifts! The staff is always extremely helpful and nice everytime I go there!!!

One of my favorite places to find unique local items. The owner, management and staff are incredibly nice and a pleasure to talk to. Thank you!!

Absolutely a hidden gem we loved this little gift shop. Wonderful lady with tons of info and lovely gifts.