Montalbano's

Boutique Italian deli, great prices for authentic Italian food and products. Try the pizza rustica around Easter. And try prosciutto bread anytime.

Love the food…love the family! It’s my go to place on Sundays!! Ty Cosmo 😉

These guys are the best !!! Always have the best food on the island and have such great service. Just picked up my holiday turkey which is always perfect every year. Hands down the best homemade roast beef I've ever had. Always greeted at the door like I'm part of the family.

First visited Cosmo, Pat and co after I was stuck with yet another bad chicken from my usual store. Been a loyal customer ever since. Bell&Evans chicken and top quality meat and cold cuts. I've also catered many parties with them. Always receive compliments from my guests. Everyone in the store greets you with a smile and warm hello every time you go in, giving it that nice neighborhood feeling.

Cosmo and his crew are awesome. His food is always fresh and there's always a nice selection and variety of prepared foods. You could also bring your pot and get Sunday Sauce homemade if you get lazy! I always call ahead for my meat order and he makes and packages everything before we get there. Great neighborhood pork store!!

This is Joe Dogwood one of Montalbanos best customers 👏 .... this place is GREAT - I discovered this spot over 5yrs ago when I stumbled in starving & ordered a Veal Parm hero 😀 & met Cosmo !!! I have ordered lunch 3 times/week ever since AND 😋 have had these gentlemen cook every holiday meal for me also!!! They are the BEST !!! On many occasions Cosmo & brother Fabio have offered to bring me food personally on their way home from work if delivery person left early or didn't make it in ...... the people are as GREAT as the food , you will NEVER be disappointed thank you guys for the food & friendships 😊

Your typical italian market with tons of fresh cooked dishes,great variety of meats and veggies and most of all your typical grocery chain items,.
The prices are a little bit higher then Shoprite or other popular grocery chains but for the most part you are getting fresh quality foods...

Can’t ask for a better neighborhood butcher. They do it all. I’ve orders Filet Mignon from them for holiday parties that was top quality to everyday cold cuts for lunch sandwiches. They have also come through with fantastic catering for our parties. Pat and Cosmo and the crew offer great service and know their customers by name.

Great place, Cosmo and everyone that works there are great, I dont go all the time but Cosmo knows me by name and knows what I like. Great quality meats the best chicken cutlets never disappointed. Will recommend them to anyone. P.S... there hot food is amazing as well... must try

Excellent sandwich and fresh mozzarella cheese was amazing. Salad 🥗 was also fresh and crisp. Rice balls were delicious too. I'll be back again soon.

If you are looking for quality food at a reasonable price, Montalbano's is the place to have cater it. I don't write many reviews but I was motivated to write this review by the number of adults at my daughters pre-prom that approached me to find out who had catered the food. I myself enjoyed the food, but knowing my guests were thrilled by it makes me want to go back for more and makes me a loyal customer. It was an EXTREMELY crazy traffic day, yet they made it on time which , to me speaks volumes. As someone who worked for a caterer in my younger years, I highly highly recommend Montalbano's to anyone planning a party or get together!!!!! Five out of five stars!!!

I order Montalbano's basically everyday for lunch. I get their lunch special. SUPER FAST. SUPER NICE. SUPER AFFORDABLE. DELICIOUS! I usually get sick of ordering from the same place everyday but Montalbano's is the one exception. Thank you guys!

First time I went on Tuesday 8/3 I ordered 2 salads which was outstanding staff was fantastic any questions I had they answered and helped me i told them they have a new customer and I highly recommend Montalbano's

What a treasure not only accommodating but had hard to find cuts of meat. The veal Osso Bucco was so tender you did not need a knife to cut it. Amazing service!

Amazing customer service, quality, and food. Cosimo and Fabio always go above and beyond in any way they can.

Great food and if they run out of something for example grilled chicken or eggplant rollatini cosmo will have it made while u wait

Great prepared and catered foods, fresh meats and salads, shelves always packed with domestic and imported specialities👍

Best Butcher on the island , amazing staff Cosmo always treats his customers with the upmost kindness and respect , and the food is the best

The store is immaculate. Service is top notch meat and food is fresh and good.

Great food and they were there when we needed them the most!