Mystic Lobster Roll Co Juno Beach

Great little spot tucked in a plaza. The roll was perfectly toasted, lobster was plentiful what more do you need from a lobster roll. Also the locally sourced key lime pie was great to finish off the meal. Will be coming back when I'm in the area.

Great selection of lobster rolls! They have traditional CT (butter), ME (mayo), and NE (lettuce)…but a lot of unique rolls too, such as a BLT (bacon), one with avocado, one with prosciutto, one with cheese!

We just ate here and were very happy with our 2 rolls. Owner was nice, it’s a one-man show (at least it was on a Monday in July). Expect to pay $20-24 per rolls, which is pretty standard.

All they need are whoopie pies to complete the experience! It’s towards the back of the strip mall, next to the fabric place…behind the turtle sculpture.

For context, I work and travel all over the eastern seaboard, especially the Northeast. I've had my share of lobster rolls. This place has the BEST that I have ever tasted! And the Clam Chowder is phenomenal! People were super nice and helpful, cannot express enough how amazing this place is!

My wife and I stopped by and had lunch. For starters we had the Lobster Bisque and New England Clam Chowder. The Bisque was the best we ever had anywhere! They make the Bisque and then add fresh chunks of lobster. Yes, chunks. Yummiest, so good! The Clam Chowder was very good, it just needed a few more clams.
We both ordered the over stuffed Maine lobster roll. It was also the best we have had! Made with just lobster, we could taste the chunks of lobster and the tasty bun. It over flowed onto the plate. And even the Cole slaw was good. We will be back soon!
It is located in the Loggerhead Plaza across from the Loggerhead Marinelife Center in Juno Beach just north of Donald Ross Road.

This is a hidden gem!!!! The brioche rolls are incredible with a slight crisp. My fav is just the regular roll with butter and I add garlic salt. Great place for lunch, since it’s tucked away it’s not overly crowded so you can get in and out and not worry about waiting if you’re in a rush.

We went here for lunch and we ordered one hot and one cold lobster roll. They were both delicious and seemed to be very high quality lobster. The price was a little surprising as it cost us over $40 for 2 rolls and we were still pretty hungry afterwards but this is not a frequent splurge for us so it was ok.

We are in town for work! Found this little gem! Evan was amazing and welcoming! Great customer service! The Lobster Rolls were amazing ! My husband had classic I had the southern one with candied jalapeños! My mouth did somersaults! Don't walk ...run!

REAL lobster rolls , fresh and delicious. They had awesome candied jalapeños for me to put on mine. Great selection of food and sauces, The restaurant is super clean but the person running the place really topped it off and made it the perfect experience. The Key Line pie was also outstanding!!

My wife and I just had the Maine and Connecticut Lobster roll with slaw and a pickle. Outstanding. Owners are top notch, thanks!

Best lobster rolls in town hands down. If you haven’t yet tried this place, you need to.

This place serves the best lobster rolls, corn chowder and keylime pie 🥧 🍰. We will be going back!!!

Delicious full lobster roll. Friendly and fast service. Easy to get to after leaving the loggerhead reserve.

I was hoping to visit a restaurant in the same area, but it was only available for dinner, but to my surprise there was a lovely quaint take out spot that looked amazing! I am from Cape Cod in MA, so I know my lobsters. Let me tell you, the lobster here is sooo fresh and incredibly tasty. They have 3 styles: Connecticut (warm lobster with butter), MAINE (Fresh lobster and mayo), and New England (lobster, mayo, greens and lemon). Not only was the lobster fresh and cooked perfectly, but the rolls were buttery, crisp and slightly toasted! The coleslaw was so good it didn’t last 3 seconds... it was sweet, savory, bitter, all at the same time, with chopped pickle and carrot. The mixed salad was fresh and high quality.

The owner was so nice and we chatted the whole time and the personal feel to the service and care, was unlike anywhere I have eaten since moving here! Please show some support and check out the location in Juno Beach, owned by Sean, and get yourself an amazing lobster roll!

We tend to be something of *ahem* connoisseurs of lobster roll. We've tried all the ones that win "Best Lobster Roll." This place beats them all. The proprietor is friendly and enthusiastic, a true believer in his product, and with good reason. WOW! The flavor, the texture, the amount of meat, the amount of butter, all perfect. This guy knows from lobster roll. Go here. Eat.
My husband, upon returning home, said he wished he had ordered another one but didn't want to be piggy. Life is short. Get two. At least. Yum. Sorry we didn't have the phone to take a photo. Guess we'll have to go back. Darn. HAHAHAHA!

Excellent lobster roll and filet mignon Mac and cheese!!! We have been taste testing key lime pie this season and this one by Key Lime to Happiness was the best we have ever had. Kudos to Mystic Lobster for supporting a small business for their pies instead of a mad producer. The owners were friendly and personable. We will definitely be back!

New to the area. We stopped in after work for a late lunch. Didn’t want to eat too hearty before dinner. I got Lobster Bisque, he got Lobster Mac & Cheese and we split a roll. It was hearty though! Nice big fresh chunks of lobster. Coleslaw on the side was tasty. Honestly can’t wait to go back & try the other rolls.

Cute bistro type place. Quick friendly service and great tasting lobster rolls!

We tried the Connecticut and main lobster rolls and they where amazing. Best in Palm Beach County.

Great place with great service and food. Notably very clean as well. Key lime pie was a surprising must try. Thank you!

Searching and yearning for an authentic New England style lobster roll in South Florida, we heard about this place (open only for a month) and decided to try it. We had the classic Maine style lobster roll. No frills -- just a warm, toasted, buttered (and delicious) roll heaped high with very fresh lobster meat (only claws and knuckles) and minimal mayo or other fillers, served with a nice pickle and really good cole slaw. Sean (at the counter) and Joey (in the kitchen) are pleasant and welcoming and the place, while small, will become a hit quite soon. As New Englanders ourselves, we have not had a better lobster roll anywhere!!! We recommend this place highly.