Papa Farm Pizza

Pizza most importantly requires two things: quality ingredients, and proper balance. Papa Farm Pizza seriously nailed both. Ingredients are farm fresh where they can be, and it shows up in the flavor. Fresh cheese tastes worlds different than bagged cheese with starches to keep it in shreds. Fresh tomatoes and herbs all bring so much more depth of flavor to the food. The Margherita pizza was, I think, the best I've had. The balance of the fresh sweet basil and sauce was spot on: enough acidity to bring out the tomato, but enough basil and olive oil to bring out the sweet herb and earthy flavors. Done temp on the pizza was exactly to my liking: a bit of brown for some bold flavor, but not to the point of eating sauce and cheese on a burnt cracker. It had just the right "chew" for my preference. We have 5 young kids and finding something, anything, they all enjoy is a challenge, but they went through the cheese pizza like piranha. Staff was very attentive and kind. Ambience was nice with screens to peek at occasionally. Can't wait to go back for more.

Wherever we have lived we always like to find a local pizza joint. This is, by far, one of the best ones we have found.
We normally get a 16 inch pepperoni & sausage but tonight we wanted to try their breakfast pizza.
It was pretty delicious! It was almost like a breakfast casserole, honestly. I'd the say the only thing that could make it better, would be putting more sawmill gravy on top... Because, who doesn't like more gravy? 🤣
I always look forward to our pizza nights from Papa Farm! 😋

I met the owner briefly at the Garden center. Nice person. I am from Chicago and seen the pizza truck and I had to try the pizza, being that my family is in the pizza business. I had the Margarita pizza. Excellent 👍. I wish him all the success he deserves!

Great food. A lot of food. Great value. You just can't complain abt prices. We had sandwiches they were very good.
Cheese cake was good, side salad was nice. No iceberg lettuce no 4 pieces of tomato. It was a very nice side salad.
I was really impressed coffee. I ordered a cup she brought it filled also a small thermal pitcher with coffee so I could just refill my own it's been years since that has happened Ata restaurant and i LIKE IT
REALLY SURPRISED Weren't expecting much but what a nice little place eat.
If it continues this way we will be back often and happily refer.

Love the wood-fired pizza that Lenny and family provide at various events throughout the year. Great wings at the restaurant, too -- but I still prefer mine breaded. :)

Really nice home town, sit down, pizza parlor. Food was very good! Very friendly people there & had fun with the trivia TVs with other customers 😁 Looking forward to going back ❣

The flavor-fully made wood fired oven in the mobile truck absolutely delivered on taste and quality. Recommended!

We walked in and were immediately seated and had our drinks! The server was probably the most caring and informative that has ever served me anywhere! She was genuinely interested in our opinion on everything and I think that’s super important! We order a large pizza ten garlicparm wings and a order of the baked breadsticks! And I’m going to tell you every part of it was the best we’ve ever had anywhere hands down! The wings were not breaded which is perfectly ok with me but perfectly crisp with a garlic parm sauce and they are to die for! The pizza was absolute perfection I can’t find a single thing to be negative about here! The breadsticks blow every other pizza or sandwhich shop out of the water with a crisp crust and a seasoning that is beyond perfection! Holy hell why did we ever wait to try this place! I recomend not only the restraunt but the entire staff to! They are the greatest friendliest and most informative group of people to ever run a pizza place! They were regularly passionate about our opinion on each item and just passionate about thier buisness all together! Thank you all for having us and this will be our permanent date night pizza from now on!

Absolutely incredible pizza! I ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch and it was the best of its kind I have ever had! I'm not a big crust eater but I could not let a bite of this pizza go to waste. The ingredients overall were perfectly balanced and you really can't beat the farm fresh taste! Can't wait to come back!!!

Most excellent..

Totally loved the loaded macaroni with chicken n sausage with Alfredo!

You can actually customize it!!!

Pizza was awesome too!

Moved into the area in December of 2022. We ordered their 16” large pizza yesterday, with veggies and sausage! It was loaded with toppings, sauce and cheese! It lasted us for two days! One of the best pizzas we’ve ever had!! Plus, they have a rewards program! Happy customers!

Our family had a taste testing duel on NYE with a local pizza place and Papa Farm Pizza. Papa Farm Pizza won hands down! The crust is handmade and amazing! The sauce is a perfect addition to the crust. It's flavorful and delicious. The sausage isn't large and off-putting. It's chopped fine and tastes great. Additionally, the pizza wasn't greasy and the competitor's pizza was filled with grease. We also purchased a chef salad and the greens were gourmet, no iceberg lettuce there! They didn't skimp on the salad toppings. The chef salad is truly a must have.

The competitor's pizza's sauce had no flavor and the crust was mediocre. Their sausage was in large balls and disguised the flavor of the sauce.

Papa Farm Pizza is a hidden gem. Our family is sold!

Very nice place to eat delicious pizza. I feel like they are developing their specific take on the classic pizza experience. The cost was within reason and the quality was excellent. I would recommend the owners expand the salad bar as it lacked variety of flavors that you normally find with a salad bar.

WOW WOW WOW! What a gem to find in this area. We live in Plymouth but will be making plenty of trips to knox for this spot. Best pizza around hands down. You can tell they use quality ingredients. Wings were fantastic too. Can't wait to try more items on the menu!

Just got take away but the staff seemed very friendly and helpful. The stuffed pizza is good. The inside looked clean and with plenty of patrons which is usually a good sign for business. I'd return for sure.

This is the best pizza place, by far, in Starke County!! We are so happy that Knox has a real delicious pizza now. How can people leave good comments but only give 2 stars?? A business grows and thrives on its referrals people!! My neighbor said the beef sandwich is magnificent! I'd give this place 100 stars if I could, hands down the best food!!!

Great Food, clean restaurant, friendly atmosphere and professional service. Best Italian Beef sandwich in town. The salad was just fantastic. It wasn't just lettuce and a piece of tomato. It had so many different ingredients. The salad was an adventure to enjoy We had a great time. Next visit we are going to try the pizza.

One of the best pizza places I've been to in the area as a top reviewer of such places I give my approval it's a really good family owned business which I like to see. The food is top notch and the service is excellent

Best pizza in North West Indiana. The margarita pizza is an absolute must try! Just got my 2nd pizza from there, and its just as great as the first. The staff are friendly and they have my favorite ale on tap, Angry Orchard.

Ordered pizza online. Picked up 45 minutes later.
Delicious !
This will be our new favorite place to buy pizza! Better than PH AND GM pizza in town!