More Ice Cream

It was my first time coming to the shop, friendly employees, good ice-cream licking flavors, and a very true sign of “you’ll want more” blew me away. Its cheaper than Baskin Robins for sure and my family and I really couldn’t leave without one more cone. 10/10 I recommend.

My wife and Daughter stopped for ice cream not knowing they were closed, a man let them in and my daughter got her ice cream, thank you for making my kids day!!! Your kindness didn't go unnoticed!!!

I'm surprised I have not rated this place earlier, I've been here on dozens of occasions. This is the place where I would recommend any ice cream enjoyer come, since the prices are amazing for what you get. At most times of the year, when it's open, they actually sell the ice cream cheaper than South Mountain Creamery's Storefront (which is where More's gets their ice cream from), and it's still just as fresh with many more options. The place is mainly staffed by the students of the high school, but they do a great job and are very kind to meet and greet every customer. This will always be a place I would come back to even if I moved away from Maryland.

Delicious ice cream with a great selection of offers! Can be pretty busy so be prepared to wait a little to be served if visiting during summer hours. Tons of seating options though parking is a bit limited.

Amazing staff and super friendly. 10 out of 10. We live around the corner and truly the best ice cream and experience me and my family have had!!

Ice cream was delicious, especially the Reese’s parfait. Mr. Jim was incredibly kind and stayed open another ten minutes so we could make it for a sweet treat enjoyed on the lovely front porch.

Perfect spot to enjoy a delicious ice cream cone. We sat on the porch after a nice walk around town.

*****UPDATE******
I found out there are multiple places that advertise Moore’s Ice Cream. If you go to the actual website it does say closed until April. Best ice cream hands down!! We drive an hour round trip to get their ice cream. The owner and staff are very pleasant and eager to help!!

HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!!

We come to More Ice Cream quite often. We rely on your website for ACCURATE information. We do not live locally, so it is a planned trip. Your website states for winter hours you are only closed Monday. Made a trip over only to find out you are only open Friday, Saturday, Sunday. Made a trip over on a Sunday around 3pm and you were closed. However, your website said you were open. Today, we once again checked your website. OPEN. We get there, and we find a small piece of paper taped to the window, “closed today”. You are our favorite ice cream place. Yet your business and website is proving to be unreliable.

This place is amazing! I was so shocked to see we were the only ones here on a Friday night! Service is amazing, the place very clean, and had great luxury seating upstairs. I also love how the napkin holders have little quotes on them, and how music was constantly playing on the porch. I recommend coming here if your looking for a sweet treat!

Excellent ice cream!! We are repeat customers with two thumbs up each visit. Several fantastic flavors or sundaes to choose from, you can't go wrong!

Super kind and friendly staff. They even let me sample it because it was my first time! Delicious ice cream! Portion sizes are huge and totally worth the money! Definitely will be back!!

Great ice cream shop in a historic building.. clean, welcoming, nice young adults working there, and of course the ice cream was fantastic. A destination we take our kids to in Middletown.. can't say enough great things about More's.. beyond offering a nice selection of ice cream, it's the cleanest ice cream shop I've ever been around. Tables were all wiped down, not a smear on them, place was so well put together, plenty of seating inside, out, and upstairs. Historic building, rose bushes and grounds tastefully done. Classic ice cream shop. Save yourself the drive to the creamery/farm outside of town, stick to More's Ice Cream. I'd give it "More" stars of I could!

Stopped here after visiting Crystal Grotto Caverns for an ice cream treat. Staff was friendly and portions were great for the price. Highly recommend banana peanut butter fudge ice cream.

Awesome homemade ice cream!!! Be sure to bring only cash to this destination but totally worth it. The selection is stupendous! Very comfortable and relaxing atmosphere. Has luxury seating upstairs. Recommended for sweet tooths.

Love the small town business. They value the local community as seen by the photos throughout of the local high school athletes. By the way, the ice cream was also delicious..

This charming old-fashioned ice cream shop is in the middle of Myersville. It serves a great selection of Garber's ice cream flavors, and their fresh baked goods are amazing a la mode! Open all winter 11 am - 6 pm

A wonderful throw back to an earlier time. Relatively intimate service, walls lined with photos of local high school "heroes". Lovely wide porch with seating on two sides and ice cream. What could be better?

Amazing ice cream, great service, and the prices make the kids happy. A must-visit on our list for great ice cream fun.

They employees are so nice we didn’t have enough money for the ice cream so they gave it to us for what we had and the ice cream is soo delicious! totally recommend!!

What a sweet please to visit. We enjoyed having ice cream on the front porch. We will be back. Not expensive, compared to other ice cream shops in the area.