True Believers Gaming & Collectibles

Love this place … it’s my son’s favorite store at the mall! We aren’t allowed to leave before coming in and seeing what they have. Every time we come we always walk out with a funko or a new wrestler or some kind of toy! All the employees are so nice and friendly! This is our go to for bday gifts & Xmas gifts

Coming in a little late with this review, sorry. I live in Arizona, and I just happened to see a vlog on this shop and they had something that caught my eye. Called them, no one picked up, so I sent an e-mail. Surprisingly, they answered back pretty fast. They treated me better, via e-mail, then some of my local stores even. Sent me more pictures of the item that I could ever ask for. 100% transparency. Could not have asked for better service. Thank you again.

The owner Jesse and his team are absolutely great and knowledgeable. They are extremely helpful and every time I go to the store I have an awesome experience. Highly recommend this shop to any true toy lover.

Great store, clean and friendly. Lots of great items and very good pricing on MTG cards! Definitely recommend.

I have been here 4 times and the service, the staff, selection of numerous figures and collectibles, the reasonable price listings, everything about it is incredible. It's like this one of a kind store that brings warmth to me, especially as an avid Transformers enjoyer. I mean, the kind of Transformers in stock, vintage, sealed, old and new, it's quite unique. I highly recommend this place to anyone in the local area and it's worth revisiting too.

It's a super dope place that I've visited a multitude of times. If you enjoy nerdy or older videos game type stuff I definitely recommend coming here. As a whole they have a great assortment of things. Also Joe is a super cool dude.

Was very hyped to see this store with amazing variety of anime! Chris and Kevin we extremely helpful picking out valuable Pokémon cards to extend my collection! Highly recommend

Wide selection from Pokemon TCG, many other collectibles throughout the years as well, best store in Central Jersey to get what your looking for collection wise.

Love this place..service is very friendly and welcoming & Prices are great. All types of figures and collectibles. Recommend for sure Check this place out!!!

Great store with so many retro and current toys and collectibles. Staff was awesome and very helpful. Joe was very knowledgeable and answered any questions I had. Peter was great helping me find everything I was looking for. Definitely my new go to spot for all my collectibles.

I just got back from a visit to one of My Favorite Collectible Shoppes-True Believers in The Menlo Park Mall! I always make it a point to stop in there when I'm in that Mall! The selection is incredible and the staff is extremely knowledgeable about ALL of their products, not only the main-stream ones!

Not my first time here. Never my last. The selection and service are second to none. Always enjoy walking down memory lane with my 10 year old son to have him have the same experiences i did. Anthony and Joe are the best. Come see them!

Great collector store. I didn’t get a chance to thank the employee. But absolutely welcoming. Knew my kids were very young, showed them cool collectibles for their age. Hands down nice and rare items. Very welcoming for a family with lots of space! Not like the typical comic stores that discourages young ones. A true gem in this mall. A+++

What a fantastic experience! Chris was the best! Chris was honest and on point with everything on helping me sell my “vintage” game systems and accessories. I will ensure that I only deal with True Believers and Chris!

Staff was wonderful, knowledgeable and helpful! They found us multiple options of items to buy from their extensive merchandise. Will definitely be back!

This place brings back so many childhood memories. They have it all! From trading cards and action figures, to old school video games. This place is great. Plus, my brother and I can talk to the staff all day about everything we know and love. They are truly TrueBelievers!

Great place to buy pop animations and other anime stuff or just have a look around

The place is really awesome! I bought One Piece japanese cards and their selection is really great! Also Anthony was an amazing help! He read the description in japanese for me and he was super friendly and funny! My girlfriend bought a 3DS and a game! It works well!
The figure selection is insane and they bring some from Japan.

Huge selection! Great prices and friendly and knowledgeable staff.

Great store. We love coming in and looking at all the nostalgic toys and games.