Cindy’s Café

Cindy’s Cafe is hands down the best breakfast I have ever had at a restaurant!! The atmosphere is AMAZING & so was the food! Cindy, herself was our waitress & she went above and beyond making our time there very enjoyable. I was wanting a Rueben but in a skillet & She made that happen (delicious corned beef, Swiss cheese & of course sauerkraut , ohh yes & to top it off a side of 1000 Island including scrabbled eggs on the top & hash browns on the bottom) It was the best skillet I have ever had, thanks to Cindy’s directions (it was not on the menu) & her husband cooking, it was truly delicious!!
Our experience was truly over the top & we will defiantly be making this our 1st Saturday of the month stop. (I was with my Mom & Cousin we all felt the same about the food & atmosphere)
Cindy along with her daughter & husband all work together to make this a wonderful place to dine. You will have to stop in & hear Cindy’s journey of how she got to Milton to open her cafe, it is very impressive!!
Thank You Cindy, you truly are a blessing🩷

Such a great place. The atmosphere is like being with your family. The staff are all so wonderful, they treat you like you are part of the family. The food is wonderful and you are full when you leave! It's just the way a small town Cafe should be like!

An absolute gem! Cindy's Cafe exudes warmth and charm, serving up delicious meals with a side of genuine hospitality. The cozy atmosphere feels like home, and the menu offers something for everyone. From hearty breakfasts to flavorful lunches, each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail. The staff treats you like family, making every visit a delightful experience. Don't miss out on this local treasure!

Generous portions. We had the Country and Meat Skillets. The place was hopping on a Saturday morning but service was friendly and efficient. Will definitely be back.

Our first visit was this morning, the food was exceptionally tasty, and the staff is phenomenal. I'm very particular about cleanliness, and this restaurant gets a huge thumbs up for that and everything else from me!!! My new favorite place to eat!

This cafe has everything you'd want- super friendly service, bright and clean atmosphere and the best food! I've gone for breakfast and lunch and am always so pleased with my choice. Shout out to the chicken noodle soup...soo good!

This lady knows how to run a great restaurant, superb food, real ingredients, whipped butter, what a delight! And then, if you wish to customize such as the meat livers skillet to add gravy on top - no problem! Five stars, the atmosphere is clean.

Lovely small town Café with the dishes and atmosphere you'd expect. Friendly staff. Good service

What a gem! We had brunch here and the food was so flavorful and fresh. The staff was so friendly (even gave my granddaughter Easter candy) . We have a new favorite spot for breakfast!

I got one word for this place AMAZING!!, the service here is unmatched! They are truly the most amazing people, the food is out of this world! I would drive across the country to eat at this place! Thank you for always making breakfast amazing!

Cozy diner with amazing staff. Huge portions of delicious comfort food. Do not sleep on this place.

I ordered the special, avo blt omelet. It is AMAZING!! Very busy this morning, but service is great, so attentive and kind! Love this place. Great first time here!!

Cindy and her waitress were awesome!! The restaurant was full only a few seats available. A real home town vibe. I highly recommend this restaurant. I live in Burlington/Lake Geneva area and they made me feel like a local. Thank you for a great breakfast and hospitality!

Love the Lemon theme. Our server was so nice and funny. Everyone was welcoming. The food was big portions and great tasting. The business seems to be doing great as a new name and new owners. Definitely recommend this cute, friendly, and home atmosphere café
10/10

Happy small town Cafe with good food, perfect portions and friendly, fast service! I'd bring guests here anytime.

It's the first time my husband and I tried this restaurant. The food was Amazing, the service was Amazing! Cindy the owner and her sister are super friendly and Blake the waitress is super funny and super sweet too! Very clean as well!!

We ordered to go for lunch at work and the food was wonderful! The café is so clean and cute, I love the lemons. Cindy and the rest of her staff were so cheerful and happy. Thank you for a great first experience, we will be back.

We have eaten at every restaurant in Milton and Janesville this is the best place hand's down! Hot, flavorful food. We will be back every weekend!

Amazing food, and amazing people the people there were so friendly. Went hiking near by and wanted to grab lunch and saw the cafe, it’s a cute little place. Delicious gravy and other foods and lemonade. Will be back!!

The food is amazing and the hospitality is beyond! You won’t be disappointed!!