The Bagel Box

The Bagel Box is wonderful! From the pastries to the tea to their sandwiches, I've never had a bad thing from here. Staff is friendly and helpful and I will be coming frequently!

Edit:
The Bagel Box has been open for a few months now and is just getting better. The staff is more versed in the workflow and the food is top notch. Recently the ever-sought-after cinnamon rolls are difficult to get but it's because they are DELICIOUS. Bagel Box is NOT a bakery so they don't keep the display case stocked ALL the time which is understandable. It is a LOT of work to make all these pastries from scratch, especially the giant cinnamon rolls. If you haven't stopped by yet you are MISSING out!
I'd also like to point out (I've seen it in several reviews now) they are not a restaurant. They will not bring you water, utensils, or "serve" your table. Everything is set up near the front with drinks, utensils, and napkins. If you need something, get up and if it's not there, ask!

The food was amazing, the bagels were better than Safeways, and the chiles in the food are actually hot! If you choose it. Great small place for yummy bagels and more.
Edit: I keep going back, it is just so great!

We ate it too fast to take a photo before hand. But I went last week for the first time and loved it so much that I came back this week with my husband. Staff is so nice!!! Recommend the Cuban, the Italian, and the chive cream cheese!! Bagels are very fresh. Can’t wait to try the bagel and lox next!

It is so unbelievable that we got a chance to have this delicious sandwiches I this small town. All the stuff is super friendly.

I was looking for a new breakfast spot and was really excited to find that bagel box had a few gluten free options, I got a gf bagel for my daughter a bacon breakfast burrito in a gf tortilla for myself and we split a gf blueberry muffin. My husband got a regular breakfast burrito. Everything was delicious. My daughter said it was the best bagel she ever had. Our order took a little longer because the muffins were still being made and the bagel was made fresh to order. I didn’t mind waiting because have a fresh in house gluten free bagel is something you don’t often get. Definitely our new go to breakfast spot. I took a pic of the gf blueberry muffin to show how big it actually is and so good full of blueberries!

I was so happy with my experience at the Bagel Box. I am from out of town and picked a breakfast place that my mom recommended. The food was delicious and very well priced. I was amazed that I got so much for what I paid. But what blew me away was the service. Everyone was kind and helped take care of us. I don’t know if I’ve ever had the service I had today. Amazing. I highly recommend this small spot for a traditional breakfast.

Went for breakfast as a second choice this morning. Pleasantly surprised. Delicious biscuits and gravy with chorizo and chiles and Parmesan/rosemary bagel so flavorful. The young woman behind the register was so friendly and helpful. We will be back to check out many other options offered.

Fantastic bagels!
Best Club sandwich I have ever had..
Potato salad was out of this world.
Can't wait to try the other sandwiches.
I will definitely be a repeat customer for
this Mom and Pops restaurant.

Ok,. When I say support small businesses especially, I mean it. The Bagel Box was amazing, easy to get to, and it was pretty quick to get my food. There is sitting for people if you want to sit and eat in. I had the BLT sandwich on wheat, and guess what? It comes with real bacon. 🥰. This place is amazing, and I would highly check it out if visiting in Show Low or Pinetop or even if you are a permanent resident.

We love Bagels and were so excited to see this place in Show Low. We tried a bit of everything, and took home a bunch of yummy Bagels. (Sorry we cleaned you out) thank you....everything was delish. And the staff was awesome and super friendly!

Awesome food, great dining, fast service. Would highly recommend this place 👍.

First time eating here. The breakfast burritos are huge and very good. The biscuits and gravy are good as well. Massive portions. We will be back.

I love green chile and this place has fresh baked green chile and cheese bagels. Yummy
I had a smothered bagel ( green chile cheese of course), with the hot red sauce ( i mentioned my chicken allergy and she forwarned me that both of their green sauce mild and hot have chicken bouillon in its starter, wasn't going to risk it) with a scramled egg and my choice of meet. So good.

I'm in love! This is a Hiden Jem. They'll be a line out the door as soon as everyone funds out about it! FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED! PERFECTLY DONE! FRESH AS IT GETS!

First time there was just to grab a sandwich for the road...which was delicious. The bagel rancheros looked amazing and we will definitely sit down with that in the near future. Great find!

I went for the food, stayed for the chairs. Most comfortable chairs I’ve ever sat in. Pumpkin bread was amazing.

Awesome bagels and staff. Quiet and cozy atmosphere with some good old music playing in the background. We had to take a large selection of goodies back to Tucson, French Toast Muffin, Blueberry Muffin, Pumpkin Bread and of course a few of their fabulous Croissants. Yummy

Absolutely loved it! The bagels are amazing, I normally dont like blueberries however, I will eat their blueberry bagel anyday! Friendly faces when I walked in and everyone was sweet, theres even places to sit if you want to stay and eat! I tried the Tuna salad the other day and it was litteratly to die for😃. Found my new favorite place to eat up here.

We have been at least a dozen times. Each time it gets better and better. The food is incredible, staff is fun and very concerned that your visit is perfect. We will continue to come as much as possible.👍😁

I love this place! They make their own bagels. Bagel sandwiches are awesome and they offer a varied menu beyond bagels. Great service from appreciative staff. They welcome dogs too!