Michaelangelo's Pizza & Subs

Our first day in NC, and we found an amazing pizzeria. The crust was perfectly crispy. The, sause, and cheese were perfectly balanced. We also ordered a calzone, and you guys hit that out of the park. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Faith, you made our first visit very pleasant and appreciated. Thank you, and we will call this our go-to.

Very good New York style pizza. Crust is fresh and they are very liberal with the toppings. I have never been put on hold when I call for pickup and I always get service with a smile.

Placed a takeout order online. Said it would be ready at a time, I got there 1 min before and it was being packed up. Perfect timing.

Everything stayed warm for the 20 min ride home.

Calzone was one of the best I've had and my fries was crispy. My wife's cheese sticks were perfect according to her and the salad was fresh.

Great pizza... Stromboli my daughters loves it .. no one makes it I like Michaelangelos

I ordered delivery tonight, had to feed my volunteer plumber! I called and the girl who answered the phone was very polite and answered all my questions patiently. My pizza arrived during the times I expected, which I always request well done so I don’t mind waiting. Making the experience perfect was the delivery driver. He was such a kind, respectful, nice young man. I asked his name so I could leave a good review, it was Matthew. I am so thankful I can order a good pizza with a kind delivery person. Thank you Michelangelo’s!

Great food! The prices are fair for the fresh and quality food I got. Staff was friendly and fast on getting fresh food made. Anytime in town this will be a place worth visiting.

Can only get REAL NY pizza here and one other place in the area. All the rest is a joke.

I enjoy a few slices of their pizza nearly weekly, typically when I dropping off items a the PO a few doors down. I know that I will be able to come in and get 2 slices, plus a drink for a great price. The staff is wonderful. The place is cozy and clean each time I am in. Great lunch spot for me. I would recommend this spot for locals and visitors.

Yummy stuff and so glad I stumbled across it.

We always get the steak and cheese sub and a slice of pepperoni and mushroom and it is spectacular every time, they have an all you can eat pizza for a cheap price if you can eat that much lol love their canolis too

They are very nice there and the food is excellent

Great pizza, please start delivery to Stella, Cape Carteret sucks. Update 4/13/22 just had the best steak and cheese sub ever, glad I got it here. Seriously, you will not be disappointed eating here.

Wife and I really like this pizzeria. My wife is from south Hersey and this place has the closest pizza she remembers from growing up. The pizza we had tonight was perfect, crust was soft and chewy. Toppings were just the right amount without overwhelming the rest of the pizza. Thanks Michaelangelos's for another great dinner.

Placed a pick up order and it was hot and ready to go in 15 minutes. Pizza was awesome! I don't know where these 1 star reviews are coming from. Staff was friendly and smiling when i was there. I found my new pizza joint!

Super friendly... the young man that served us yesterday actually brought our food to us! I am in love with their spaghetti and garlic knots. As we left a young girl smiled brightly telling us to have a great day.

Best pizza in town, with the kindest and most friendly staff

Best pizza I have eaten in a long time! Lots of cheese, toppings and crust was perfect.

We had a great pizza! Lived the sausage!

Destiny makes an amazing NY Sicilian pie! Tastes just like it!! Her pies have just the right combo of ingredients and whenever I'm homesick, I order a pie! Michelangelo's Swansboro rocks! Great staff as well!

Just wanted to give kudos. You guys are awesome. Food was delicious and hot tonight. Jaden our delivery young man was so nice! Merry Christmas! And Happy New Year!