Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes

All I can say is, "Wow"!!! Guilty Pleasures Cheesecake is my new favorite place for bread and cheesecake. We were having dinner with friends and picked up two loaves of crusty Italian bread to accompany a hearty bean soup. Amazing!!! Crunchy on the outside and soft and chewy inside. And the cheesecake was out of this world. The antique decor is so charming. We'll be going back regularly!!!

Went in today and had the absolute best experience and a to die for Boston Cream cheesecake. The owners , Justine and Patrick, are so welcoming and fun, I wanted to hang out with them all afternoon! I think i just made some new BFF's! Definitely worth taking a ride over to Washingtonville. I can't wait to go back and try all the other delicious flavors.

The Mecca of Cheesecake, Pastries & Vintage Candies! Order ahead, or pop in. You WILL find something you Love. Owners are fabulous!

Adorable store with friendly, hard-working owners. Very fun and unique atmosphere when you walk in. Lots of vintage goods -candies, sodas, etc. Homemade desserts are seriously amazing!!! Tried it today and will be back.

This place is one of those places you get lost in the decor... Unique and so well put together I didn't want to leave !!! Oh and the desserts are amazing!!!!

Guilty Pleasures Cheesecakes is a quaint little spot that offers some of the most delightful treats. “Guilty Pleasures” if you will. The desserts are excellent but what gives this my 5 stars is not just the cozy atmosphere and cute setup but the uniqueness of each cheesecake from the savory, Cheese Burger, Jalapeño Popper, Buffalo Chicken, to the sweet 7-Layer, Pumpkin, and Cinnamon Toast Crunch (for Cereal week) the creativity knows no bounds. Cheesecake not your fancy that’s okay, there are some amazing scones, cookies and other treats to satisfy those little “Guilty Pleasures” that we all have. Let me finish off the the review by also saying, all those cheesecakes, baked on site to add to that extra delight.

Patrick and Justine- I just had (inhaled) your tuna sandwich special. It was incredible- it tasted just like nana used to make! I highly recommend it. You guys made my day!

Love this place the atmosphere is always welcoming, the smell of the candy and desserts once you walk in omg.

1st time customer. The store was clean and the staff/owner were kind.
The tiramisu and the hazelnut lattes were delicious! Pumpkin canoli bar and rainbow cheesecake were even better!
Small business Saturday people!!!

Amazing treats! Super friendly staff. Variety of desserts and candy to pick from plus coffee. Highly recommend!!

So cute, great food. & Try their harvest tea!! Love the place, will definitely come back again !

She made me a turtle cheese cake . It was absolutely Delicious . Could not ask for a better cheesecake . Love it , thank you so much . Will definitely be back for more !!!

The owners are extremely welcoming and offer a variety of pastries including vegan croissants. Love coming here😊

#1 Cheesecake in town..and a variety of candy, treats, even soup & sandwiches and many more. Just a fun place all the way around. You feel like a kid again. The coolest owners & atmosphere. See u soon! For my Going Coconuts B. Day cheese cake 😋

I don't usually like cheesecakes, but these were absolutely amazing. The rainbow cookie cheesecake was better than any rainbow cookie I ever had. The store atmosphere was really cool and the owners were extremely nice. I will be going back here for sure.

What a sweet little bakery. Love all the different candies and gift ideas. The smell when you walk in the door is amazing. So many different flavors of cheese cake to choose from. Came home with cheese cakes and pastries. They were absolutely delicious! Will definitely be back for more.

Lovely shop, great desserts, friendly and fair prices will definitely be going back!!

Most delicious cheesecakes… couldn’t decide which is my favorite so I will continue to take the mini four pack great deal

Excellent. The Soup 🍲 and Sandwich were Delicious. We tried a little bit of their Cereal Cheesecakes, they were Awesome. We bought a loaf of Olive 🫒 Bread 🍞, Excellent. We had a great experience. The Owners and Staff went above and beyond. Everything was Amazing. Thank You 😘

My new favorite place! Came here for coffee and ended up getting the pecan pie bar and a sandwich as well. Split the sandwich with my husband, who is VERY picky, (especially on sandwiches, he’s an Italian from Brooklyn) and he couldn’t stop talking about how good it was. The ingredients, the bread, everything was delicious and FRESH! The pecan bar and iced coffee equally delicious. The atmosphere is adorable and the people who work there are very friendly. Can’t wait to go back :)