The Cider Press

We had an excellent evening of dining at The Cider Press! The atmosphere was great, the food was amazing, and our waiter (guy with a pony tail) was so fun and affable. We enjoyed it all! Thanks for a delicious dinner out!

Everything from the customer service to the food was amazing. Had a craving for fish and chips and they did not disappoint. Can't wait to come back and try all the other goodies on the menu.

The chicken strips should be called “Canes My A**”. Sauces are hand crafted and it shows. Loved the homemade chips. They were perfectly fried. Clearly a lot of care taken in preparing in the food.
Service was friendly and knowledgeable.
Highly recommend The Cider Press

Tonight we had a dinner at a new place downtown Millersburg called
The Cider Press.

Food was great, place is quaint and cute,
wait staff and manager are friendly attentive and even went above and beyond for us when we had a problem with one of the meals.

We even sat around talking and ordering drinks to close the place down. 🍻

2-7-2024
Fantastic Restaurant. Highly recommend!
Thank You for another Spectacular Dinner.
We had the Italian Sausage Pasta & BBQ Mac n Cheese. So Delicious!
Compliments to the Chef!
The Server is always Fabulous & does a Great Job! Thank You!

1st Visit -
Great experience. Lobster Mac n Cheese and hand breaded chicken tenders with homemade chips were delicious. Dressings are all made in house.
Nice selection of hard ciders.
Service was fantastic! Thank You!

Located in the heart of Millersburg, near Amish Country. The space was filled with character and thoughtful detail. The staff was friendly + the food was great. Excited to come back again soon!

What a wonderful evening I had at The Cider Press. The staff was warm and inviting, and the food was innovative and bursting with flavor. A new gem to the Millersburg culinary scene, I look forward to visiting again and tasting their crisp selection of ciders. Thank you for the excellent visit.

We had the esteemed pleasure of dining at The Cider Press for Valentine’s Day. My wife and I brought our 15 month old baby. Pookie, who was our server, greeted us at the door and already had the high chair set up and ready to go at our table! The eloquent ambiance of the restaurant felt very intimate, romantic, and inviting, but it wasn’t at all stuffy, pretentious, or over the top. It was the perfect vibes for what we were looking for on this day of love.

Pookie was courteous, well knowledgeable of the menu (especially with the drinks on tap), and respectful. She always came by our table to check on us with a smile. As it turns out, Pookie’s mom was the head chef in the kitchen. We were afforded a chance to meet her and she was delightful!

The food was delicious by the way! You could tell it was made with all the intentions of providing a comfortable, home cooked meal like most of us Midwesterns felt as kids growing up.

The Cider Press is a place for couples, singles, families, and any other dynamic of social interactions. We will be back, and I encourage anyone reading this review to just go down and check it out for yourself!

Thank you again, Pookie, for everything! And please tell your mom hello and she is doing a wonderful job at the restaurant.

The menu was unbelievable and the food was fantastic! Xandra our servor was a lot of fun with a great personality. Everything from the apps to the main meal was very tasty. We thoroughly enjoyed the wonderful customer service. We will eat here again when we are back in town and highly recommend you give it a shot!
Thanks gang!

You can tell the owners and managers put their heart and soul into this place! The service and food were excellent, and I loved the recommendation for a speciality cocktail. Both my mom and I agreed we’d come back!

I was visiting from Florida & decided to give it a try.. April 5, 2024
I had the fish and chips
The food was amazing , and so was the service..
very nice & inviting atmosphere.
Highly recommended

Love love the place! Blacken chicken salad and their own dressing was delicious! The waiter recommended the cider flight we enjoy tasting the different flavors. Great service will definitely return .

A great place for delicious, artful, rustic meals locally sourced and creatively crafted. Absolutely loved my time there. Can't wait to go back!

Wonderful Valentines dinner, albeit a bit too spicy on the jambalaya, even for my taste. Loved the entertainment by our poneytailed waiter!

5 Stars! Love this place and the people!
Food is Amazing! Casandra and her team go all out to make your experience memorable! So Go Eat, Laugh, and Enjoy yourself. You will not be disappointed!

The valentine dinner was a great experience. Everything was better expected. Staff was very friendly and sociable. We will definitely be back when we're in the area.

Everything about this place was amazing. The staff knew all about the Ciders and what was in it. The food was absolutely delicious. Our waitress could not of been more helpful and efficient and the cook/ manager even came out to speak with us and share a recipe.. I would highly recommend it.

I enjoyed dinner at this incredible restaurant this evening with my friends!
We all had a delicious meal (chicken alfredo)and one of the best parts of dining there…I have a soy allergy and they were actually so accommodating by making my meal soy free!!
The first time I’ve been able to dine out and actually order something off the menu besides oatmeal and not having to worry about a negative reaction to something I ate.
What a wonderful find! Service was incredible,our waitress Pookie E was amazing and she took care of our table
as though we were her only table and it was a full room of guests.
Thank you so very much!!
We’re going back to Kansas soon,but when we return next summer…this will be one of our first stops!!

This is the yummiest, friendliest little secret in Millersburg! The menu is varied and not too big. New items added and everything designed and well-thought out. Results are mouth-watering happiness. Watch out for the homemade desserts and cupcakes. I only need one and I take home 4 because they are that good. Italian sausage with bow tie pasta, brisket, pierogies many more! Lots of ciders to choose from if you please. This is a must try and will enjoy!! Our new favorite restaurant family! ❤ Stephanie and Steve

Our service is always impeccable. The staff is authentic and kind and the food is delicious. The only thing that would make it better is more of a drink selection.