Colarusso's Cafe

Always delicious! After not visiting this treasure for a few years I was in the neighborhood and couldn’t pass up the opportunity. Colarusso’s did not disappoint. The pizza with the special cheese was as good as always, the vodka shrimp pasta special was just that, so special it was insanely delicious! Service efficient and personalized. thank you for not changing what I have missed!!! Until next time!!!!

Love the tomato pizza that my fav 😊

Been many times over the years and have never been disappointed. My wife went last weekend; she said had great service and raved (as always) about the pizza. I made a great life choice and married the right woman; she brought a white pizza back to VA and it was GREAT. Thank you!

Ate dinner here with my folks last night. Very friendly staff, very generous serving, very affordable, and the food was damnit good. All three of us had not a single thing to complain about. If I lived locally, this would be my go to spot!

Great food and great service!

Excellent pizza and large variety of dinners and snacks

Love their fresh tomato and garlic pizza, as well as the traditional plain square. They also have an excellent side salad. One of my favorite pizza stops throughout the valley.

Dining in is always my preferred option at this restaurant. Whenever I call ahead for pickup I usually end up waiting past the time that they say to be there by. That process could be improved.

I can't wait to go here again. Whole slice of tomato on top of the pizza (no sauce under cheese). This was so good, I literally want to come back and get it again.
Had a good time with family and enjoyed the food.
Waiter/waitress seemed a little stiff but overall satisfactory service.

Visited here for a nice lunch date with my wife. The old Forge Pizza was amazing! My wife likes the white pizza but I prefer the red with pepperoni. You never have a disappointing meal here.

Great pizza, white to die for, creamy, delicious, hot and gooooeyyy

It's a little dated but the food is outstanding!

Food and service were excellent. We had a grilled chicken salad and Italian sub. No cutting corners here. Pizzas were all around us and looked delicious. Definitely will be back.

If this place ever closes, my heart will break! Can't go wrong with anything on the menu
It's a family favorite and a (very important) tradition to eat here when I visit home

The food will blow you away! It is delicious! Greatest meatballs ever! The sauce is epic. Great menu and excellent service. A must visit!

Been there quite a bit. They catered on premise for Christmas. Wonderful people. Wife of owner delivered. It was a great meal. Everybody raved about the food
Never been disappointed. I love the Polenta. They make it Saturday night and it's leftover on Sunday. It's even better. I'm so strolled They opened on Main Street, Old Forge.

amazing food and great atmosphere

Driving in the snow and started getting hungry. Based on past reviews, we decided to pull off. As we opened the door....6 people in a row walked out with pizza boxes! The place was packed. Parking was an adventure (must park on busy small street) but the food was worth it! We enjoyed the flavor, and the cost. We have family in New York, and this is on the way. We will for sure be back. You should stop and give it a try. I know we will.
Small town feel. Friendly Service. Good Eats.

Pizza was amazing!!! Extremely friendly service. Family run atmosphere. A+

Great Italian restaurant located in a neighborhood. Reminded me of being back in South Philly. Excellent food and service. Finally found a place that made tripe and had great dipping bread. We started off with calamari, fried to perfection. This is our third time back.

My favorite place for Old forge pizza and the waitress is ALWAYS an angel 💜