Two Brothers Bakery Cafe

We needed a huge order of cookies for a wedding - - and we are so glad we chose this bakery! They were amazing to work with throughout the entire process, and went above and beyond to make sure that we were happy with the order. They even developed a gluten-free version of the cookies that we wanted, so that we had a gluten-free option for guests. The order was done on time, delicious, and the cookies were beautiful! We had so many complements from the guests. Highly recommend this bakery !!

I was here in September 23 and forgot to write a review. I love checking out small bakeries in random towns and had never been here before as they just opened. I stopped in early morning looking for bakery items. They had a small selection, and I got a pumpkin cinnamon roll. I would have chosen plain, but they were out. Anyway it was amazing, and of course at the time fall festive. Several people were in just to get coffee and they were quite busy. I will definitely be back when I'm in Port Jervis!

It's one of the best bakeries I have been to. From the food to the service, everything was terrific. It was one of the best chocolate chip cookies I have ever had! The hot chocolate is made in-house, which is incredible! If you’re passing through, stop by. You won’t be disappointed. Everyone was very friendly as well!

Fantastic place run by two great people. They have breakfast sandwich specials on Saturdays - DELICIOUS. Would recommend to anyone!

Best bagel in Port Jervis and in the surrounding area period. A nice bubbly exterior with a light chew on the interior. Plenty of variety. Great bakery, desserts. And weekly additions to the menu. The guys running it are very very nice. I hope they can stay fixtures in our town for a long time. Prices are extremely reasonable. Somebody else wrote a negative review stating that a bagel was almost $10. That is a flat out lie.

Have been here twice now. Both times, the service has been exemplary, and the quality of their products is excellent.

Specifically, for fans of cookies or creme brulee, I can personally attest to the quality. If you can catch them with a fresh batch of chocolate chip cookies I highly recommend grabbing one. As to the creme brulee, they will torch it and caramelize the top right in front of you.

Finally, the bagels and cream cheese selections are varied. I tried a poppy seed bagel with a garlic chive cream cheese and enjoyed every bite. Not too much cream cheese, but plenty to enjoy.

I will definitely be going back!

I had the pleasure of meeting one of the owners Mike and he was so pleasant and the vibe there is dope. The treats are delicious & we can't forget the amazing bread pudding. I'm freaking obsessed!!!!! Definitely going back...

Best breakfast sandwich in the Port Jervis region hands down. All the baked goods are absolutely top-notch and the service always comes with a smile! Don't miss this place if you are in the area.

So many yummy pastries, bagels etc. My go to place!!!
Update: 01/2024
Bagels, cronuts, chewy Brownies, & pies (only at holiday time) breakfast sandwiches at any time of day. There's no menu because they want you, the patron to have lots of options. If you want something, give them a call and see what they can do. I've never had anything I didn't LOVE!!!!

Awesome bagel sandwich. Coffee cake was really good too. I will definitely be back the next time I am in the area.

Stopped by a quick coffee. Their bacon, cheddar, scallion scone is so good. The service was amazing too.

Big fan of this new bakery. Bagels are unique and delicious. The scones are banging. Cronuts are a nice addition. Looking forward to see what else they add to their arsenal! Great friendly service. Next door to a smoke shop doesn’t hurt.

David(which means beloved)and Michael( which in short means Angel of God) are true to their names...they are sent from heaven in their amazing new "TWO BROTHERS" BAKERY. I went to check it out and bought wonderful little chocolate mousse cups. The cups are edible cruncy dark chocolate...the mousse filling is so rich n thick n creamy...better than in ones i enjoyed by the finest places in France and Brussels. I knew from the first spoonful...i was addicted to this place! Then today i picked up a dutch chocolate cake for a 91 year old man...his birthday...and his favorite childhood memory...he said it was perfect like his Mom made for him as child. I was so happy ...he was so happy...the bakery brothers too very happy...that cake was a masterpiece. These guys Michael and David want to please....you tell them a memory...and they will go out of their way to find a way to recreate it for you. I love them and wish them great success at the plaza at 84 front street...parking a bit bothersome at times as there are so many folks wanting the bakery or other small shops in Port Jervis....but other than that everything so worth the trip...prices too are reasonable...service fast and with friendly attention...place is clean and.....happy in atmosphere.
LOVE IT! LOVE IT! AND LOVE IT! TOO GOOD FOR ANY TO MISS!
Fantastico!

..cup...the mousse best i ever had...ever

One of the most amazing bakeries I have ever been at! Not only are the two owners the sweetest, kindest, most generous people I have ever met, but the Brazilian lemonade will change your life! The crème brûlée like none other, and the most amazing bagels I have ever tasted! and being from New Jersey thats a bold statement! Please support this talent and make sure they are around serving us for years to come !

Great neighborhood bakery with delicious, quality treats and coffee! Friendly service and comfortable atmosphere.

This place is new in town, incredible quality, delicious food. Go go go before I eat it all 😍😍

1st time stopping in. Stopped in for Snowballs Chance, smelled so good, and the people were great. Will be going back! Thank you

Two Brothers is an adorable little cafe with a nice little selection of goodies. I tried a cinnamon roll on the spot and it was so yummy with a generous amount of icing. I took home a raspberry/cheese danish and a crumb cake cookie. Both were delicious. I can't wait to try everything!

Great coffee and pastries. Super friendly. Just wish they had a regular available menu.

Ordered sfogliatella last minute from them for a friend who is obsessed — he loved them! Everything else was delicious, too!