Slyce Pizzeria - Voted Best Pizza

Incredible meal. The pinwheels are HUGE and a meal unto themselves. I'll never again make the mistake of ordering them AND a pizza! The garlic and herb wings were most tasty, but next time, the garlic knots WILL be ordered - they looked divine.

What an amazing little place. I went there with some friends of mine and we had ordered both the buffet and off of the regular menu. The staff so kind and helpful they have mentioned if there was something that we wanted specially made that they would make it for us and put it on the buffet. For sale for super accommodating and very attentive to all of our needs. A wonderful little gem hidden away. A must go to place

It was amazing! Loaded w cheese, and fresh ingredients...loved it! Best pizza I've ever eaten!

Words don’t explain how good this pizza is. We’re from the Chicago land area and it’s extremely tough to find really good pizza in FL. And it exists here in New Smyrna Beach. And the staff is super friendly and desserts are home made. Best cheesecakes I’ve ever had. We’re going again tonight. Unbeatable beer prices too!

Great pizza. Everything fresh. My family got the Chicago 18 inch deep dish. And we could only eat half. We definitely came hungry and are leaving full and satisfied. We will be back again. I could see my dough being made my cheese freshly grated and our pie made fresh to order. Prices are awesome too

Eat there on July 30th great service right of the bat! Ordered a Chicago style pan pizza and some wings. The pizza was the best by far I have ever had. The wings were awesome as well. Over all a wonderful experience and would recommend it to anyone! The only bad thing is we are on vacation and can't go every day.

This place is AMAZING! They made a fantastic buffet style spread with several different kinds of pizza. It’s all authentic and homemade! My favorite was the meat lovers. We’re all the way from Ohio and wish they were closer to us! The staff is friendly and attentive.

We couldn’t be more pleased with our experience and we will definitely be back on our next vacation!

In the mood for a good Greek salad and Slyce came up in my Google search. They had a great Greek salad, good size, good dressing and it had meat! Tried their deep dish personal pizza (not on the menu yet) and it was just the right size. Alma (the very friendly owner) explained up front the deep dish takes a bit longer but it was worth the wait. Will definitely go back. I'd recommend the Slyce to family and friends.

Great food! We ordered a pizza, Greek salad, lemon pepper wings for 4 of us, plus Cheesecake for dessert and everything was delicious. We shared and were full, happy, and satisfied. Would recommend it to anyone. They make a lot of their own products, and use unbromated, unbleached flour for their pizza crust. Next time I plan on trying one of the pasta dishes. 5 Yummy stars!

Best Italian food in Florida. Best pizza and lasagna. The service is great and the food is just amazing. We had 2 large pizzas. The calabrese and the Brooklyn. The sausage is made in store and so is the fresh mozzarella. The owner is very friendly. We went while they were very busy and I can see why. It's worth the wait

Great food and the prices are amazing. Best pizza in town. Just like new York. The portions are huge. We had 2 14 inch pizzas a lasagna an eggplant parm dinner and a Sicilian pizza to share. 2 soft drinks. 4 bees and 2 glasses of wine. And I almost forgot. 2 orders of sausage and peppers. All for less then $80. They make their own mozzarella and sausage from scratch.

Great little place! A group of us went there last night for dinner and were very pleasantly surprised. The food was really good, the staff could not do enough for us and made us really feel at home. We had about a even split between the pizza buffet and menu items and everything met all expectations. If they didn't have the pizza we wanted they made it for us on the spot! Give these guys a try the next time you want something Italian. You won't be disappointed.

Best pizza ever for a really good price. I got a 14 in pizza and and order of wings and drinks for 3 people. Everyone was satisfied and I recommend anyone in the area to come here. I would definitely come here again. Owners are very friendly and we're very hospitable. Slyce pizza is a must!!!

I love some of the comments below stating they do their own reviews. How absurd although I know some others that do. I have not only been to this place with guests 5 times, I send my hotel guests there as well as anyone I talk to. As not only a hotelier, I am a certified F&B professional. This place uses not only fresh ingredients but make their own sauces and cheeses. It's the real deal and why I send people there. Hats off to a local restaurant that cares about quality product, not price. All restaurants will have their ups and downs with staffing, it's hazard of the business. If you catch them on a busy night or short staffed, give them another try. they are worth the wait.

This place is DELICIOUS! The 2slice special is enough food for two people but, it taste so good you won't want to share lol. The prices are great too. This is my second time here and I'll definitely be back again. I brought my daughter, who calls herself the pizza pro, she approved as well. Great place for lunch and dinner.

The Chicago style stuffed pizza is the best pizza around...period! I order it for my family a few times a month...the kids love it too! You'd have to travel to the 'windy city' to find any comparison. Simply delicious!

this is 100% the best pizza place you can find in Florida. My father owns a pizza shop in New Your City and it is just as good sometimes you have to wait a little on Fridays but it shows how good he is by how busy he is.
Sam is the pizza king. If you want high quality food i 100% recommend go there.

Best in town, best around.
We have been eating at Slyce regularly for several months now, since the day after they opened. In this time we have gotten to know the owners and staff quite well. They'll make you feel like family. Service is always friendly and attentive. The wait to get food can be on the longer side, but once you get it you'll see why! Everything is homemade from the sausage to the dough to even the cheese! Good food takes time and it's done with a smile!
What impresses me the most though is the consistency. In all these months I have had exactly zero bad meals. The quality is above and beyond every time. You won't find a better meal in town and you can't beat the price! Slyce is the pride of Port Orange.
My favorites: spinach pinwheels, meatballs, calzones, and you've GOT to try the canollis!

On vacation from Virginia and decided to bring grandma in! It was a delicious Chicago style pizza! Literally amazing! D was our waitress and Sam was the cook! Super friendly! Definitely recommend and definitely will be back!

This place is out of this world. We ordered an 14 inch stuffed pizza and a 24 inch cheese. Both for delivery. Everything arrived nice and hot. 45 minutes it was at my door. Don’t listen to these hostile reviews. It’s 1 customer who has it in for them. I seen these posts last week on Facebook. Seems like they are having fun.