Polito’s Pizza

I've ate here 3 times now and it's been fantastic every time. Nice workers, foods done in a timely manner, it's delicious, and its fairly priced. Would highly recommend.

I grew up with Politos, always eating it when I was little, and my brother and sister worked there and talked about it, so there's a little bit of nostalgia whenever i go there. The pizza slices are very big, and are really cheap despite how delicious they are. You can get 2 slices of pizza and a t-shirt for $10 which is a pretty good deal. They have arcade games and claw machines for a little entertainment while you wait for your pizza to be made. One complaint that i have (and I'm really nitpicking here) is that the atmosphere is just a little bit empty and boring, but other than that just about every aspect is good. I would definitely recommend this restaurant, and would rate it a 9/10.

The pizza mimics a favorite back home in Pennsylvania. Staff are east to talk with. My family had a restaurant there, so we exchanged good memories. We will be back!

Really good pizza and garlic knots to die for. The place could use a cleaning but will overlook it for good pizza.

Hands down the best pizza we've had in Oshkosh!!

Very good pizza. NY style so they’ll heat up anything by the slice or make a whole pizza fresh if you’re feeding a group. Very willing to customize for the customer. Excellent and chill couple of guys working there.

Awesome people to serve amazing pizza. Thank you

The pizza reminds me of Aniello's Pizzeria in Corning, NY without the ambiance of Anniello cussing out his staff in Italian. Sure miss Aniello’s! Glad I found Polito’s.

My favorite pizza place in Wisconsin. Garlic bread is on point!

Everybody only wants to come here when they’re drunk, however it is good midday as well. Just like a solid pizza by the slice option. Also the cannoli is my favorite I’ve ever had.

Awesome pizza and garlic knots. $20 goes a long way

Big slices and a huge 20inch pizza should you choose. College friendly and busy during bar time. Price are reasonable.

We went for a weekend with the grandsons for a weekend getaway to Wisconsin Rapids. We decided to order a pizza on our first night there. We could have ordered from any of the standards like Rockys, Papa Murphys and many others, but decided to try a local place and something unfamiliar to us. We ordered from Politos and were thrilled! The pizza was fantastic! It was a hit with all of us. Cheesy, great sausage and pepperoni and great flavor. Also, it was the biggest pizza I’ve ever seen, 20”. Just delicious, I highly recommend.

My boyfriend and I were trying to go to Toppers, as we are not from the area and obviously recognized the name. We waited for almost 10 minutes without anyone noticing that we were even there.

We decided to leave and walk across the parking lot to this establishment and was immediately greeted by a nice man behind the counter. Pizza was good! Reminded me of Sals Pizzeria. Great customer service.

Ordered through doordash and the experience wasn't great. Their pizza is easily the best in town, the staff was amazing and helped insured my order was correct. I'd recommend them to anyone, maybe just don't order through apps.

Best pizza. Love it.

This New Yorker was lost without her traditional New York style Pizza when I moved here. Politos is the only place in town that has nailed it. Love the food. Love the service. Fridays has not changed in our home even though our location has changed.

Personally, I haven't been inside but this is the only place I order pizza. When you do order, go big. That XL pizza is amazing! You definitely will be satisfied. I feel the large pizza doesn't give the Polito's pizza the same justice, but that XL pizza has the cheesy topping goodness I expect from Wisconsin. Like I said, the only pizza I order from.

The BEST New York style pizza in town.

Great pizza and knots... We got spinach and feta 20" added bacon... It was delicious...😋💕😁
✌🏼❤😁🌎