Salerno's Pizzeria

Amazing pies here. Never fails to satisfy. Delicious sauce. Don’t ask me which is my favorite because I can never decide.

New York pizza, and the subs/heroes on real Italian bread, are unbelievable.
Great crew, thanks Tom for always taking care of me on deliveries
My go to place for the past 15 years

This place is honestly one of the best pizza places I have ever been too. Their buffalo chicken pizza is literally the best. Try to beat it u cant! I drive 45 mins from where I live now to get it. I just came in today and every slice is just delicious. I'm serious go here and try it. U will not be let done. Thanks salernos!!!

Love Salernos. The food is always good. They use a sweeter sauce, which is what I like. Pan pies are excellent. I like the buffalo chicken roll. Their wings are no nonsense fried wings. My wife loves their vodka pie. Im going to try the buffalo chicken pie next go around - it looked fantastic in the display.

My three year old grandson isn’t feeling well today and asked for a white pizza so I picked one up a few minutes ago from Salerno’s Pizzeria. I’m a new customer for Salerno’s Pizzeria and am very impressed by their friendly atmosphere, customer service and the high quality of their pizza. It is absolutely delicious. My wife just said I made our grandson very happy with the pizza. Actually it is the folks at Salerno’s Pizzeria that did so. My family will definitely be back, again and again, as a regular customer. Thank you!!!

Doug

I started coming here about a year ago after taking a job in the area. Salerno’s has been consistently awesome every single time I go which is at least once a week. I have had pizzas, salads, hot and cold sandwiches, their paninos, and everything I have had has been awesome! They greet me by name every time I come in. They are great people who truly care that you enjoy what they prepare for you. This is not you average restaurant. I can’t say enough good things about Salerno’s! Highly recommend!!

Tasty cheese pizza. Very crispy but not crazy. Worth the buy

Awesome pizza, flavorful cheesy, just great

Absolutely true Authentic Italian food, homemade perfection 🥰 The key to a great Italian restaurant is all in the marinara sauce, this hands down is the perfection. Finally we found our Italian restaurant. Took a few years but very very happy, is my Italian family. Thank you SALERNO'S

Came down from upstate New York on vacation with my wife and she and I absolutely loved the food!!! Haven't had pizza like that in a long time. And the rations for all the sides...you definitely get your money's worth.

Fantastic pizza and a surprisingly great drink selection.

I think this is the best pizzeria around. One reason is that they use better quality ingredients than some other pizzerias I have tried. It’s there in the crust and cheese. The crust has a flavor, so there is effort put into developing that taste. The crust is thin to medium and usually very crusty. It’s not doughy. It’s cooked just right. The sauce lends flavor to the pizza without overwhelming it like some sauces can. There is a balanced proportion of cheese to sauce to toppings. It just taste great. You’ll definitely come back from more. Aside from the pizza they also have some very tasty entrees.

Get lunch from here regularly and everything I order is always AMAZING. Their vodka sauce and their buffalo chicken are one of the best, you won't go wrong ordering anything that includes one or the other. 10000000/10

This is our go to pizzeria, we literally drive 25 minutes each way from Tinton Falls to come here. Their Sicilian is better than L&B Spumoni Gardens and margarita pie is incredible too. Also the eggplant rollatini is the best I’ve ever had.
Note to the owner: There is new retail being built on Ft. Monmouth where we live (by Netflix and the new RWJ hospital), I highly suggest you open a second location there, we have terrible pizza in Tinton Falls and you guys would kill it!

This review is a bit overdue but I’ve been meaning to compliment the delicious pizza at Salerno’s. A friend was in town from Ca who was on a mission to have awesome pizza. I took her to Salerno’s knowing she’d be very satisfied. We tried 2 slices; a spinach artichoke and a margarita. They were both outstanding! I must say that I eat here often and have never tried these 2 types of pizzas. I now look for them when I’m there! I’m a fan!

Creme de la creme.... top notch delicious food. We enjoy nearly everyday. Safe-com team

I drive here weekly which is a 25 minute drive for their quality and taste of their food! The staff down to the cooks are very welcoming and pleasant to communicate with. Their penne vodka with the vodka sauce and option grilled chicken is a must along with their Margherita Sicilian pizza ! You’ll thank me later

They have the best eggplant parmigiana. Everything about it is excellent. And their sauce is magnificent!

Since originally posting this review I tried their grilled vegetable sub and I now have a new favorite item there. It is one of the best I've ever had. The veggies are grilled just right, their balsamic glaze is delicious, the fresh mozzarella is plentiful, and whatever bakery supplies their sub rolls.... a bad roll can ruin a sub, this is the opposite and makes an already tasty sandwich transcendent.

Plenty of pizza places around me in Laurence harbor but I go here. Great pizza and pasta dishes and the place is busy for good reason. Prices are reasonable but not sacrificing quality.

Delicious! I’ve had it two times since moving to Hazlet, the first time it was amazing but it was during the winter and we were out and about and it got left at our doorstep and by the time we got back we had to heat it up in the oven and it was still spectacular. We ordered the personal pan pizzas, one pepperoni, and one egg plant Parm 🙂on our second visit we order the exact same thing and again a hit!

This will definitely be our go to spot in our new neighborhood 🥰 thanks guys keep up the good work! Also they are always super nice when we call 💛