Marty's Place

Went on weeknight. They were busy. Sat at the bar waiting for a table. The second drink the bartender bought us. He said I apologize for your long wait, this one is on me. Food was excellent. Love the variety of seafood. Steak was cooked to perfection. Love this spot! Only spot I know that has escargot.

Great place! I went there about 10 yrs ago and wasn't impressed but tonight was really good. Atmosphere was good and had remodeled since I've been there. I had an old fashioned and the T-bone and they were both fantastic! I didn't like the baby reds were deep fried and crispy, other than that I'd definitely go back.

Great service. We went late so they were out of some things but it didn't matter because our food was delicious! Soup and salad bar was great! 2 soups to pick from including French onion..my personal favorite. Theirs is fantastic even with out it baked with cheese. Broth was very good. They made me tenderloin Oscar style. Husband wanted the prime rib but they were out so he had the new york strip. No fresh baked bread as they were out as well. Amazing prices as well. Get the twice baked potato also...totally worth the upcharge....its huge!

I had the porterhouse medium rare it melted in your mouth my wife had the ribeye which was very good California veggies were good. Drinks were made well Bar staff was very friendly waitresses were very helpful. Would go back easily

In town visiting friends for the weekend. We all went to Marty's by suggestion. I can't say enough about the food, it was amazing. Service was 5 star, sorry I don't recall her name. We will be looking for her on our next experience. We all had something different and shared around the table. Was overall one of the best dinners we've had in some time. Highly recommend for all to go and enjoy. They won't disappoint

Amazing WI supper club experience!! The food is always great, and Brian makes a great old-fashioned. Steaks, fish, and sunday chicken are at the top of the list for food, but the other dishes will surprise you as well. The chicken marsala is amazing and enough for two meals. Top 1 or 2 supper clubs in the appleton area.

If you want the full supper club experience Marty's is the real deal!! Sit at the bar and have great old-fashions garnished with homemade olives or mushrooms. I highly recommend the ribeye!!! So full of flavor!! Salad bar isn't huge but has all my favorites!! Great place, great food, great service!

Excellent experience. Food was amazing, service wonderful. We enjoyed Old Fashioneds, Cordon Blue Bites, and Prime Rib with the soup and salad bar.

Great food and great service! Traditional, nostalgic supper club. Service has been wonderful. The surf and turf options are fantastic! We've tried the following: salmon, haddock, shrimp and scallops. All were very well seasoned. The soup and salad bar is great too!

Always great. Nice and simple salad bar. A classic supper club.

Just went to Marty’s tonight. The wife Had the Apple smoked prime rib and it was cooked to perfection and very tasty with very little fat. She loved it. I had the frog legs and they were tender and very flavorful. Soup and salad bar had two soups and everything was excellent. Our waitress was friendly and brought us two fresh baked loaves of warm bread -probably the best at a supper club I’ve ever had. Never a complaint and wife loves the old fashions! Will continue to come back!

Great salad bar & one of the best ribeyes I’ve ever had. We’ll definitely be back!!

My husband and I dine in at Marty’s every Wednesday evening. There food is excellent, drinks are good and service is excellent, also the price is very reasonable for two people. My daughters recently visited from Oregon and we took them out to eat at Marty’s and they were so impressed with the ribeye steaks, can’t get steaks like that out west! I would recommend Marty’s for anyone who wants good steaks or seafood.

From my initial call inquiring about reservations, all the way to the end of dinner .. our service was exceptional! Brian swiftly answered my call & was excellent in giving advice on how to still get a table on a Friday night without a reservation. Kevin was out bartender & while the old fashions weren't muddled, they were still served promptly & made to Wisconsin perfection. Robin was our waitress & she was very kind & courteous. She made our dining experience very pleasant! Overall our Wisconsin supper club experience was everything we expected.... traditional, warm & all that we always are looking for! Well done Marty's Place! We'll be back!

Stopped for dinner on a Friday with some friends. Typical wait at the bar for a supper club. After being seated, the waitress was super nice and answered any questions we had. My steak came out perfect, and I enjoyed every bit of it. I'll definitely come back again.

Have never had a bad experience here. Drinks and food are the best of the best.

I had an amazing time for my first time coming to Marty’s. My partner and I had the prime rib and New York strip and it slapped. 10/10 heather and Kevin were very fun and great!

The Applewood prime rib was awesome!

Unexpectedly amazing! I've lived here my whole life and have never gone to Marty's until recently. Heather, the waitress, was very friendly and made us laugh! She checked in with us multiple times to make sure everything was good and our drinks were full. The ribeye was great!

We had a large party, but server handled it well. On Wednesday and Thursday they have anything on the menu $28 or less for 2 for $42. I had a small tenderloin and frog legs. Soup and salad bar included. A great Wisconsin supper club and experience.