Otter Creek Sports Bar & Grill

The food here is good and the service is always so friendly! It's really cozy and inviting, which is a welcome change of pace as many other restaurants around town tend to be very "divey". This place has a little bit of everything to suit your needs. They have root beer on draft, which is always a win in my book.

Went there on a Friday night for fish fry and it was AMAZING! Service was great, atmosphere was great, fish was great and the prices were great! Regular order of haddock was 3 very large fillets which was more than enough! Definitely will be back!

Super friendly service and great food. We had some pretty awesome cheese curds as an app and I had the Club sandwich and my husband had the Philly. Both were amazing. Was our first time eating here and will definitely be back :)

The cheesy potato soup here is like crack in a bowl! It's absolutely amazing! It's worth coming here just for the soup alone. The staff is also really cool.

I love this place and all the people. I love that I can go in and be sarcastic and joke around. The bartenders get my humor and the food and atmosphere are even better. You walk in and get a hello how are you doing! You leave with a smile and a few laughs! I have almost had everything on the menu and I have to say they have found a great niche in life! The homemade soups are always so good! Make a point to try this place!! Bartender with a friendly smile!!

First time we visited, and it won't be the last. Wonderful waitress and delicious food with large portions.

I meet the sweetest people tonight, I travel to Wis to say goodbye to my dad, a vet that is in hospice, the waitress was the best, the food was fantastic, the bartender made a fine
Long island. Their kindness made a horrible time for me , so much better I can't express my gratitude, please give this restaurant a try. This is true Wis. Finest, I will be forever grateful for the way they showed love to me. Thank you.
Anita and Michael I will never forget this. Thanks again..

Awesome sweet potato fries! I get them whenever they're available at other restaurants and none beat Otter Creek.

We're from Greenville but we often come to Hortonville just to visit this bar. Incredible people, hometown atmosphere, makes the food even better 😊

I returned here after moving away and used to visit often. I was not disappointed on my return! My boyfriend and I got the chicken and shrimp alfredo and both were delicious. I was happy that the dishes hadn't changed a bit and the prices are unbeatable. We also got tater tots which I LOVE here. Our waitress was very nice and our food came out quickly which was a plus. Can't wait to come back!

I love going to this place. The people are always friendly and engaging and the food is delicious and the menu has quite the variety to it. I recommend Otter Creek.

Lively atmosphere, and the bartenders and waitstaff are always friendly. Like many other foodservice joints, they seem to be struggling with adequate workforce, but at no fault of their own. If visiting during peak hours, expect a little wait, but the fish on Fridays is worth it.

We have come here several times. Good food and service!

The cheesy potato soup here is off the chain!! Best soup I've ever had!

I had the tenderloin steak sandwich which was excellent. I added French fries they looked like I got the end of the bag little broken pieces. Other than that we will definitely be back.

First time there. Food was delicious!! I had the ribeye sandwich cooked medium rare. Was SO good. Very juicy. Cooked perfectly. Had onion rings with ranch dressing on the side. Very good!! My husband had the walleye dinner with fries. He thoroughly enjoyed it as well. Service was good and staff was friendly. Would highly recommend!! Will go again when we are in the area!!

Just moved to the area and stopped in for dinner. Place was busy being one of the only places open on Mondays. Food was good and service was awesome. Faith was right on top of greeting us and so friendly to chat with. We agreed to make it our Monday night spot if Faith promised to serve us! We'll be back!

Enjoyed a delicious lunch at Otter Creek today. I had the haddock and my husband had a Reuben. We were pleased with each of our choices. In fact, my husband said it was one of the best Reubens he has ever had! Kudo's our waitress also!

Best prime rib sandwich I have had in a long time. They are doing everything right. Great bartender, service, comfortable atmosphere! I will definitely drive back from Stevens Point to hang out here. Secret surprise for us, someone very generous local person, came in bought our lunch. The person apparently does this randomly. True act of giving back 👏👏 👏! The world needs more people like you. I hope our paths will cross again someday. Left a thank you at the bar for your kindness, appreciate what you are doing! We will continue to learn from you and pay it forward always remembering the kindness you always share!

Great atmosphere with plenty of room to dine and socialize. Good food with a large, varied menu served by friendly staff.