Gargiulo's Tinton Falls

Fabulously romantic restaurant. White table clothes. Romantic music. Small cozy restaurant. Food is fabulous. Valet parking. I can't say enough wonderful things about the place. So glad we discovered it. This is truly a hidden gem. My husband was thrilled they carry Blanton's bourbon. Very classy. Very elegant. The halibut covered in cream and lump crab was amazing. The drinks were fabulous. The wine was our favorite. The Italian cheesecake was light and fluffy. The decaf cappuccino was the best we have ever had and it was wonderfully super hot. Just the best!

Delicious! Had dinner last night, food and service were spot on. We had the pork chop, halibut and seafood fra diavolo (a special) for dinner. Perfect! My 13yr old loves the rice balls. Their bread is scrumptious and the graham cracker gelato is a must! Cozy, tasteful interior, comfortable seating, relaxing atmosphere. Our server was Rachel and she was excellent. Valet parking. Highly recommend!

My niece had her small intimate wedding here and it was lovely. I would recommend this restaurant for a special dinner with your significant other or for a small party. It's elegant. The staff, especially Theresa and Christopher, were very attentive. The food was good especially the fried zucchini and egg plant. The fire pit was a nice outside place to gather even in December.

Dylan, our waiter was amazing, pleasant, attentive and responsive. The calamari racanati was incredible. I had the sole franchese and it was very tasty with the brussel sprouts. My boyfriend 's special lasagna boulognese left a bit to be desired because the pasta seemed dried and hard. Other than that, I would recommend this place for a fine dining experience.

Went for first time last night with two good friends. The atmosphere is very friendly and cozy, love the decor. We sat upstairs .Our waitress Sierra was beyond excellent. We all had fish dishes and we all enjoyed. Mine could have been hotter but it really wasn’t a big deal. Loved the brussel sprouts. Wished they had Malbec wine but Sierra gave me a wonderful suggestion and it was very close to Malbec. The young man also who was assisting Sierra was very personable and attentive. Sorry can’t remember his name:( Even the gentleman doing Valet was personable and friendly. We will be back:)ps the italian cheese cake was wonderful.

Great family owned and operated business. Staff is friendly and attentive. Awesome Italian dishes as well as meats and seafood.

We ate here for the second time tonight. Really enjoyed the meal. The restaurant was very busy as it should be on a Saturday night. We had stuffed clams which were delicious. My wife had the Filet cooked medium. It had a stuffed veal special they had. It was also excellent. We will definitely go back again. Prices are reasonable and the service is great.

The food, atmosphere, and service are top notch. Outside was gorgeously decorated and welcoming. There was a fire pit to keep you warm while waiting for the valet (who took great care of the car). Inside was beautifully decorated for Christmas. The service team was knowledgeable, friendly, and helpful. Our glasses were never empty. The meal was delicious and plentiful. I had the veal special and it was amazing. The Gelato is Devine. All members of our party were very satisfied.

We’re really like the place. First time we were on the second floor, which was very cozy. Food was great.

Great staff, tasty food and live music with outdoor seating, what more can you ask for? We will definitely be back.

Charming family restaurant, staff very friendly.. we had their special lobster with seafood in white wine sauce over linguine, which was phenomenal.

Amazing authentic Italian restaurant. Valet parking, priced very reasonable, great service.

We came here for the first time recently with two other couples for a grown ups night out and we were so pleased with everything. The restaurant downstairs is cozy, romantic and homey, the staff was friendly. The waiter was awesome .. never rushing our group, always attentive and pleasant. The food was excellent. The menu is large enough that there are plenty of options without being too much to chose from. Wine list was very nice. This is a great place for a romantic dinner. We will definitely be back!

Hands down one of my favorite places. They take great care of their customers. From the start of the valet to the finish while wiring by the fire for your vehicle.

My wife and I have eaten at Gargiulo's a number of times over the past couple of years and we are always impressed with the quality of the food and service. If you are looking for great place for an intimate date night Gargiulo's is a great option.

The food was fantastic. The eggplant rollatini was by far the best I've ever eaten. My bfs veal special delicious. The service excellent and the setting warm and intimate. Can't wait to return. Thank you Gargulio's for a lovely evening!

Gargiulo’s has a beautiful, warm atmosphere inside. Their staff are attentive and courteous. Most of all their food is well-displayed and is exceptionally tasteful.

Delicious food and excellent service from hostess & servers. Great selection of drinks and entrees.

I had the Shrimp Scampi with a glass of the Il Vecchio.

A true family run restaurant with outstanding food and Drinks. Cozy, intimate & delicious.

We had a Valentine's dinner at Gargiluo's and it was fantastic. The atmosphere is very romantic and they had a wonderful live jazz singer that wasn't too loud. I had the lamb chops and my husband had the veal. Both dishes were cooked/seasoned to perfection. The wine was reasonably priced. Even on a notoriously busy night, the service was excellent. We will definitely be back.

We were there Saturday night and was delicious from the appetizers to the dinners and desserts!
There was four is us all loved it!
My son and his girlfriend was there before and took us in so glad they did!
The food was very good and hot.
The server was very helpful and attentive.
We will definitely go back!!