Magro's - Greene

We stopped here on a whim and we were glad we did. They were hard at work making pizzas from scratch and really working the dough. I don't usually like buffalo chicken pizza but this one was worth having. The pepperoni was very solid. I wanted to try the garlic knots that were swimming in butter on the counter but will do that next time.

We love their pizza, that's what we normally get. The antipasto salads are awesome too!

I just moved up here from Long Island yesterday. This place made THE BEST meatball parm hero and garlic knots I have ever had. Back on the island, we have some of the best pizzarias, but this place blew them out of the water.

This calzone is phenomenal, the service exceeded my expectations and they went out their way to come a little out of the distance. Very happy and will definitely be ordering again!! Tysm 😊

Garlic knots were fantastic as well as the sauce! The pizza was delicious as well! Definitely ordering again for sure!

Very open and welcoming front area to order at. Very nice service and fast.
Pizza tasted pretty good. Garlic knots are very well made, not too chewy and just the right amount of crisp on the outside

Nice quiet place in downtown Greene. Mainly hand made pizza and subs. Wide selection of both. All made on premise. Pizza is thin crust with lots of gooey cheese. Tasty! Have very nice priced lunch specials. Eat In or Take Out. I will be back.

NEVER BUY FROM THIS PLACE!!! Cheaper to go out to eat. I ordered a pizza with 3 toppings it came out to 28 dollars I also ordered 5 wings they came out to 10 dollars for 5 wings is outrages you might as well go to a high class restaurant sit down and eat instead of getting pizza to go extremely disappointed

The place is nice inside and the girl at the counter is very pleasant, attentive and helpful. The menu has a nice variety of items. My wife had the Mixed Meat Italian Sub, no mayo but with Italian dressing. She really enjoyed it. All the ingredients were very fresh and there was a nice balance of everything. The half sub was more than enough. I had the Chicken Parm Sub and it was equally delicious. That one came as a full size only and I took half home for a second lunch. It was our first time there but it's worth the 25 minute drive through some nice country and we will definitely be going back on somewhat of a regular basis.

I love this pizza place. My boyfriend and I eat from here at least once a week. We love the chicken bacon ranch pizza, never a disappointment. The garlic knots are good to. I absolutely love the honey bbq wings, the sauce is delicious and the wings are always perfectly crispy.

Great service. Wonderful food. Great delivery service. 3rd time we ate in. Everything was great again. Grew up on Tony's in Endicott and Margo's food is better. Ordered pizza for delivery and it was again excellent.

Great pizza! And I am a pizzaman by trade so I KNOW! people are so friendly!
The antipasto salad was great too!

Good garlic knots and pizza! They deliver to my address! Makes me super happy!

Ordered a slice of pepperoni. Excellent.

This place is our new favorite place for Italian food! We love the calzones and they are huge-big enough for a couple of our kids to share. Service during COVID has been great and friendly. Prices are very reasonable.

Great food, Great service, Great people and at a Great price!... Magro's mM 'Mazing!

I have been a regular customer since they opened. Always friendly service, great food.. Quality ingredients on pizza, and in the entree selections.. Don't miss an opportunity to try a great local Pizzeria...

Stopped here on my dinner break, and wasn't disappointed. Good pizza, and nice staff

Always fresh food with good flave my significant other loves the pizza there but I would prefer a thicker crust.

The best real steak sub I’ve ever had. Pizza is very good too!