Pultneyville Deli

The lady who took the orders was wonderful, polite, and friendly. Enjoy the Portabello sandwich. The husband had a buttery lobster roll sandwich, which was s special for the day. It was very clean, and the bathroom was pristine. Well, it's worth a visit to the Pultneyville Deli.

Delicious homemade food everytime, beautiful scenery and great service.

Our favorite local place to dine in or take out. Food is good but depending on selection is a little pricey for what you get. For the lobster roll dinners, we wish they were a little more generous with the serving of French fries you get with the lobster roll. It’s a piddly amount compared to the price paid. Service is good and the staff are friendly and nice. You order at the counter and we usually take it to go and eat at the nearby park. But there are tables both inside and outside. They have a shade tent outside as well. All in all, good place to go for lunch.

Rode my bicycle along with my adult daughter from Webster. 18+ miles each way. Food was great. Cookies very good. Good selection of beverages including beer. Pretty town to wander around and see Lake Ontario and Pultneyville ha hour. Nice people who run the deli.

This little gem is fantastic! I've eaten something different each time I've visited and has yet to disappoint my taste buds. The price is on par with normal restaurants. Clean and friendly.

Good food, big portion, nice service, friendly staffs and a clean place

Had a group of 9 of us come into the deli yesterday and have lunch. Only one girl was working and she did a great job doing everything she could. Service was a little slow but she was the only one working so I'm not gonna knock it. Food was excellent! Have a nice selection of canned alcohol & ~6 taps I think of beer but use a beer card or something.. pretty neat, my wife and I will be back again & try the drinks this time!

Easy online ordering and pickup. The cookies on the counter were too tempting to ignore. So far I've enjoyed every sandwich I've ordered and am looking forward to trying their breakfast options.

Nicest little deli in the entire region! If you're in Pultneyville, this is the place to stop. Everything is fresh, homemade and delicious. The owner and staff are friendly, the place is clean and bright, and the cookies are to die for.

Other than the table being very sticky it is a great place! (Stickiness was because of adhesive from some kind of table cover). The Tattooed lady is awesome! Breakfast sandwich was very good! I plan on going back to check out the bar upstairs! The wine and beer dispensers are a great idea!

Great food, friendly service! Tops.

Fun little place to stop for ice cream, beer, or a burger. Ice cream selection wasn't huge but it was reasonable. Beer selection was local which is nice.

We went for just a burger and fries. Overall it was a good meal in a beautiful location. Seems like there was a lot to choose from on their menu that I'd be interested in trying but I could only pick one thing. Will try to stop by next time we're in the area. Hopefully it's soon since we have family that live around the corner.

It's a nice historical spot as well if you're into it. I enjoyed the photo timeline of how the place has evolved since the 1940s.

Very cool place. Awesome food.

They were still doing quite a bit of business at almost 9 on a holiday evening. Nice selection of ice cream. Plenty of outdoor seating. It appears now they have some sort of small restaurant or Cafe on the upper level. I didn't really have time to check out the menu but I've been there a few times for ice cream and it's always been nice. Perfect for a summer ride.

We were upstairs @ The Up Pub for my birthday. There were 6 people in my party & the place was packed. There was only 1 waitress/bartender & she was awesome!!! She provided exceptional service & was very friendly. She deserves a raise!!!
P. S. The food was delicious!!!

I was disappointed when the original eatery, The Pultneyville Pickle, closed, but the Deli has taken the reins and is doing a great job! Great variety on the menu, simple but comfortable indoor dining, and more recently, expanded outdoor dining. There is a pub upstairs as well, which adds to the appeal.

Beautiful location, friendly staff, delicious food! Will definitely be back!

Nice little find with outdoor seating. Staff was super nice and friendly. Our dog was given a bowl of ice water to help with the heat. Lots to choose from on the menu from salads, sandwiches and pizza. I ordered a large salad which was larger than I expected.

We love this place.I had the chicken pesto wrap - delicious! My wife had the Calypso Salad: delicious and fresh. The owner and the waitress were friendly and the service was excellent. Oh, and the prices are reasonable. We'll be back...

Always good and by far the best place in Wayne County. Breakfast sandwiches very good. Root beer on tap. Excellent Mac and cheese and pizza. The people are always very friendly too. Consider this Mecca in what is otherwise a food desert.