Turtle Cove Resort & Marina

Elizabeth was our server. We were out this way traveling roads an making memories with my dad. An this place honestly made one to remember. Had a live band that we didn't know was playing. Paid 100 including tip for 3 people, so the prices definitely definitely affordable to what I would u say me lower class, affordable. Hole in the wall place of the main path. I will be back again. Thank you turtle cove for food an great service

They have great food and friendly staff. Go whenever I get the chance.

We went to the restraunt and enjoyed a simple meal...turkey club sandwich that was very good and big enough for my wife and I to share. It was Open Mic night (Wednesday's starting at 6 pm. Seven or so local singers shared their music. Was a fun night.

We traveled over 500 miles and ended up in the small town of Fair Haven on a camping trip. Locals unnamiously suggested Turtle Cove for dinner and we are so glad they did! The service made us feel at home because they mastered true southern hospitality in upstate NY. The food is perfectly made, looks so delicious and taste even better! Beautiful location, especially on a nice day!

Absolutely outstanding service and top notch people. We rented a boat slip and on the day of our arrival managed to drop a wallet into the water at the docks that evening. We did not have long enough gear to try to find/ fish it out, couldn't see or reach the bottom, and Brian & Colleen from Turtle cove generously
brought us a net, a ladder and even got into the water to help us look for it. Far and above expectations and truly kind people. Thank you!

My husband and I had a fish dinner last month. He had fried and I had broiled. The fish was out of this world. I have never had a fish that tasted so good!!! The service was great too, very friendly and the view was perfect.

Excellent food and service at reasonable prices, 10 wings was only $9.99, which is unheard of these days. Highly recommend. Pic is of the Philly cheese I ordered.

Always a great go to with good food, attentive service and mellow atmosphere. Just had our 51st anniversary meal on the deck and it was great.

Good time watching open mike night. Food was great, cold draft beers, wings were hot, and as requested. Super service by Ethan.

We rented a cabin for two nights. Cabin was vintage but was very clean and seems well maintained. We also had dinner one night in the restaurant as we watched a great show put on by a "local to the area" professional musician piano player and vocalist JustJoe, who was absolutely fabulous. Our dinners were very good, and the homemade peanut butter cheesecake for dessert was out of this world. Our server was attentive all night without being overbearing. Brian and his wife, (sorry I didn't get her name) was very welcoming. Definitely enjoyed everything about the Turtle Cove & Marina.

Not much to look at on the outside, inside it's nice and clean. Our server Caren was wonderful, it took a while for the food to come out but it was worth the wait. They had live music and it wasn't too loud.

We didn't stay here, but we did eat here one day while roaming the small village of Fair Haven. Don't let the lack of AC and the mismatched deck furniture fool you! The food was incredible. The burger I ordered was cooked to medium rare perfection, no small feat in restaurants these days, and fries were crispy, hot, and crinkle cut! My mom's cheesesteak was also delicious. The service was friendly and the breeze off the water helped with the warm day.

Love turtle cove. The food and drinks are amazing. The view is beautiful. We always have a good time everytime we are here.
A bigger parking lot is definitely a must. We always go on a Thursday-saturday when it's pretty busy but no complaints. The service is very good.

Best place in town to get food! The staff and atmosphere are wonderful. Sitting outside looking out at the water is so relaxing. This place is a must.

Nice little spot with great food and drink selection. Bartenders and servers were very nice. They also have a pool table, dart board and huge outside patio.

We went to Turtle Cove for dinner while on vacation in Fair Haven. We completely enjoyed the dining on the dock. The food was great, the service was awesome especially for a Monday evening. Can't wait to return!

We just want you to know that last night we ate dinner and I got the beer batter fish dinner - that has to be the best Haddock meal I have ever had. It was cooked to perfection and the mac and cheese was excellent. We could tell you made it from scratch not box. The service was excellent too. GREAT FOOD!! & SERVICE,

First time at Turtle Cove... and it won't be my last. Food was great and the waitress was super. Many, many lunch options.

The owners are absolutely wonderful. Staying in the apartment above the marina/bar was a delight, and so convenient. The food was great, food service covers all three meals, all day. We were there to go to the Sterling Renaissance Faire, which is less than ten minutes from the marina. The inlet from lake Ontario is such a beautiful space and provided a relaxing weekend.

Wonderful food and great service on a huge patio overlooking the bay. Everything I've ever eaten there is delicious. We can also take our dog, and they bring him a bowl of water.