Magic Mugs

My favorite coffee shop is probably in all of Ohio. Great lighting, plenty of seating, and they even have an arcade machine and an old Nintendo (the one before N64). My favorite drink to order is roasted marshmallow latte for cold days and a Red Bull Italian Ice on hot days. I highly recommend it. You'll love it.

Always a great spot! Perfect for Saturday morning coffee dates and ending procrastination (starting a 7 page paper that's due tomorrow 🙃).
Love the atmosphere, food, and coffee.

When I moved to Dover a few months ago I was worried I might not be able to find the quality of coffee drink or welcoming atmosphere that I was used to in a bigger city. Not to mention, I come from working at a small locally owned coffee startup myself for 3 years— I have high standards for my coffee experience.

Then I found Magic Mugs & knew it was my spot. Chloe, Derek & Sophie are the absolute dream team. They make high quality drinks and make you feel like you are coming home when you walk in the door. They remember you, they start conversations with you & they are always seeking to make the community a better place. The decor, original art and collection of books & games is just icing on the cake.

I’m honored to call this *my* local coffee shop, and I take all my friends who come to visit here!

Cute little coffee shop located in the beautiful town of Dover! This was my first time visiting and felt so welcomed. Staff was kind and helpful and recommended their Mystical Carmel Macchiato which was fabulous. Highly recommend checking this place out when in Dover.

Such a cute, cozy, welcoming place in Dover. There are lots of fun things to do and excellent coffee. The new owners, Derek and Chloe, are wonderful people and the flex seating offers a comfortable space for everyone. I cannot recommend coming here enough. I’ll certainly be back every time I’m in town.

Also, get a cinnamon muffin or brownie. You won’t be disappointed!

TL/DR: Magic Mugs in Dover is arguably the best cafe I've experienced, with great vibes, perfect music, and fun features like a retro arcade and Nintendo Switch games. Ideal for socializing, studying, or working.

I've lived in coffee mecca (Portland & Seattle) and traveled to many major cities around the world (Tokyo, Paris, NYC, LA) and I have to admit, Magic Mugs in Dover is probably the best cafe I have been too.

The vibes are perfect for either hanging out with friends, studying, or working. And the music selection is perfect; not too crazy nor too slow. I never have to listen to my own music while I'm at Magic Mugs.

For fun, they have board games, a retro arcade with all the classic games, such as Pac Man, and have a Nintendo Switch where you can play games like Mario Party, Super Smash, and Fall Guys.

I stopped here during a brief trip to Amish Country area and I was pleasantly surprised when I walked in. The workers (Owners?) were very friendly, made me a good coffee (I had no food, but next time I will), and I enjoyed the acoustic guitar hanging on the wall. The Mini NES area was really cool too and there are plenty of comfortable places to sit. I have been to many countries and most of the states, but rarely found such a neat little introvert-heaven coffee shop as this. Surprise to find it in Dover, OH... When I return to this area, in a few months, I will definitely stop by again!

Barista was very nice. Atmosphere was clean and cozy. Way bigger inside than you would think. There was a kid playing video games on a tv they have in the lounge area. Pretty awesome that they make that available. The pour on my latte was a beautiful presentation. It is the little things when you are consuming premium coffee products. Prices weren't much different than other coffe shops. Expect to pay at least 5 bucks. Their presentation sets them apart, so I hope they don't lose that over time.

They are a great staff and they make a great coffee. I go there several times a week, and everything I order is well done. The employees all have great personalities.

We were here from Michigan and stopped in for a coffee and conversation with an old friend. It was warm and welcoming. Great coffee in a really cute mug! It was very enjoyable ☕🥰

Five stars for service, coffee & ambiance. Have not tried food yet, but if you are a coffee lover you will love their dark roast sumatra, which has been there the last two mornings.

I absolutely love this place. I’m always calm and relaxed here. Their food and drinks are the best. A super homey chill vibe with lots of seating options, they have books, coloring pages, games and more. By far my favorite coffee shop

Great coffee!!! Staff was fast and friendly

They are the absolute best! Unfortunately since we cannot visit in person due to distance, I was able to order coffee to get delivered to me in Maryland! They even ground up the coffee for us. It arrived in like 2 days fresh and even better it was absolutely delicious. We also got some stickers and a punch card for when we can make it in. Amazing people that we adore from a far! Can’t wait to visit soon! ♥

Super cozy coffee shop with phenomenal vibes. Very aesthetic place for pictures as well. Highly recommend the "cozy sweater latte" from them.

I stop here almost every morning before work. The coffee is fantastic. The owners are some of the most genuine people and make everyone feel so welcomed in their shop!

Absolutely brilliant coffee shop! The staff is knowledgeable and welcoming. Great place to spend time with friends!

I am so very much enjoying my Saturday visits to Magic Mugs. It blends the vibe of a traditional coffee shop with the soul of a diverse community. All are welcome here.

When we walked in, we immediately loved the vibe of this place. Everyone was friendly, and it was a great place to do work. Oh! I should also mention that their coffee is excellent!

This is a nice spot for coffee or tea and a snack. They make an interesting iced chai. Fresh ginger is the predominant flavor, enough to develop a mildly hot sensation for a nicely balanced cold and hot beverage. The coffee is also delicious. They offer a range of available types and preparations of coffee and tea. You see the entire age range of the community from about 5 to 75 enjoying this fun establishment!