Nicky's Good Eats and Treats

Food was excellent along with the service! My husband chose Nicky's for his birthday lunch and we had a great meal to celebrate!!!

We ate here in September of 2023 on a trip to Two Rivers. The food was so good we've been considering the drive up from Illinois multiple times since!! No doubt it will be a regular stop on our way past on several future trips.

Very nice place to eat, felt like eating at home. Loved the food, Lott of veggie - salad options too. A very friendly touch of fresh cookies at the counter. Everything here spells fresh and just made - very few places serve food as good.

Delicious food and friendly service. I'm never disappointed! I always get take-out, but there are a few tables.

Nicky's Good Eats and Treats is a very small all-American eatery with a very large menu. More than just a burger joint, Nicky's also offers sandwiches, wraps, soups, salads desserts and more.

The prices are reasonable and the portions are solid. What stands out here is the taste. Food at Nicky's is fresh and they do not slack on their ingredients. The hand-cut fries taste like an actual potato and not something like a potato that's been overly processed. The burgers are juicy, yet the bun isn't soggy and there are many fish options to choose from (walleye, perch, cod). Burgers are ordered in a "build your burger" fashion. The three main burgers are hamburger, cheeseburger and bacon cheeseburger. After that, a list of toppings & extras is listed on the menu and you add on what you like at no extra cost.

My only wish for Nicky's would be a change of location. This place definitely deserves to be a stand-alone restaurant, especially in Two Rivers where the town isn't exactly exploding with dining options. There's about five tables inside of Nicky's and one or two outside, which is right on top of the gas station parking lot. Nicky's screams Americana and I when I taste their food, I picture a throwback diner.

Give their Facebook page a Like/Follow and you'll see they are very active and offer daily specials.

Highly recommended.

Popped in this little place during our family get away. Was super simple ans easy to order with decent options. Needless to say my husband said it was the best chicken bacon wrap he has ever had! 😋 Thanks for the great dinner!

Finally made it to Nicky's in Two Rivers, WI. Thanks for the fb posts... that's what brought us in today, your chicken spinach-artichoke sandwich deal.

Yummmmmm

The burgers and wraps were outstanding!
But - DO NOT USE EATSTREET TO ORDER ONLINE! The mark-up was 40-50% on most of our items. I have reached out to EatStreet directly with my issues. Call the restaurant to order carry out.

Really great on its own, especially great when compared to the other options in the area. Patty melt was great and on a nice salty rye. Sandwiches don't some with a side so try a cookie! Veggie burger patties are available.

I suggest the Monte Cristo! Had my first one from Nicky's and am now following them on FB just to see when they are ok special again! Hope to go back soon!

The food tasted great and the price was reasonable. I will definitely go back.

Nicky’s always has really good food! I love the Mushroom and Swiss Burgar, fries, and their soups. I recommend ordering ahead since they are usually really busy.

Best Hamburgers/Wraps/Soups/Specials/Treat in the universe(at least that I found). Most everything is made from stratch here. No prefrozen burgers or factory made soups. Fresh hand-made patties, home cut fries, and soups made daily here. The pricing is good, I don't know anywhere you can get a 1/2# burger for around $6 dollars; not just any burger, but possibly the best burger you will ever have in your life. Nicky has been in a kitchen for many-many years, and you will probably find her back there cooking your food tp perfection.
If you are in the area and looking for delicious food, you will find it here!!!

Small place with awesome real homestyle food. Great flavor always

Good service, quick food and delicious! Home made fries. Will order again.

Ordered “the Duke”. It did not disappoint. One of the best burgers in WI. It has to be. I usually go with a standard cheesebueger to gauge how good a place can make a burger. Just driving thru, so i wanted to change it up. Glad I did. I drove around a bit looking for this place. I did not know it was literally IN a gas station. Burger was so damn good, now i consider this a kickass burger joint with a gas station attached.

My husband got a burger earlier this year and he compares each and every burger he's had since to the burger from Nicky's. He hasn't found anything better yet.

Great fish specials on Fridays! The cheeseburger is also wonderful 😋

Very nice small but comfortable place and the food is exquisite

Such AMAZING fresh cut fries and burgers!! Definitely a gem of Burger joint. Just be careful, because it seems they've been short staffed lately (like many other businesses right now) so don't be surprised if they are closed even when they are supposed to be open.