Port Sandy Bay

We had a very nice meal here. It was quite busy, so we had a bit of a wait, but the food was well worth it.

Priced very well, comfortable bar atmosphere (we ate on the bar side), friendly staff, and delicious food.

Shout out to Village Inn on the Lake for recommending this place!

Also has a game room with tickets that can be traded for prizes, for the young and the young at heart.

We recommend this restaurant, and would return here again.

I’ve been going here since high school when my friend’s uncle owned it then. Nothing changed under the new ownership years ago and has continued to be a local favorite. My family has had many birthday party’s over the years. Everything always went off without a hitch. Lots of games for the kids to play and plenty of room for a big party. It’s a cute place with good friendly service.

Huge place. Wonderful service. The pizza was super thin crust. Pretty good. I also had the spicy pickle fries. They were pretty yummy as well. Great location near the point state park.

This place is such a historic landmark . Its been around forever and the owner is so nice . There pizzas are the best around and they also have AMAZING FISH . There bar makes real mulled Old Fashions . Nice place take a drive through the beautiful school forest on a warm summer day .

This is a great up north atmosphere bar/restaurant which serves great food and pizza. Pricing is very reasonable. Also has a very nice game room for kids.

Not our first time to stop here when we are on a day trip. Great service. Fantastic Pizza.

Update Feb 2022: I just waited 57min to get a 1/2 cup crispy rice, burnt broccoli with Panda Express orange chicken sauce on dry steak at a restaurant in Manitowoc. Their brick oven pizza was ok. Their $8 (8oz) coffee cup sized Old Fashioned was not. If you have to change your menu every week to pull in customers that's your thing. Definitely not a family restaurant. I won't be back. Don't fall for the gimmick.

****Thank goodness there's consistency, a great family atmosphere, great food, drinks at a rational price at Port Sandy Bay. Nothing bad to say about a Two Rivers go to.🍕🎉🎉

The best pizza place in our area. Just a great place. Love just hanging out here.

Delicious food, amazing staff (so sweet, helpful with the kids!), and fun place for the kids. We even went back for a 2nd night in a row. Had pizza, cheeseburger and both were delic! Fish also looked awesome. Next time.. we will be back!

Excellent fish. Great place for a large group to gather.

Delicious pizza, awesome servers, and a really friendly atmosphere

Our snow coaster pizza was so good! Great place to visit when we have friends and family in town. They can always accommodate our group, large or small!

Had a great time in a very comforting atmosphere. Food, drinks, and friendly personnel. Definitely Travis made us all feel at home, very positive vibes.

Been a staple in the community forever. Great food and great spirits.

Great pizza and drinks. We are from Ohio and visit family in Two Rivers. We make it a point to get Port pizza at least once while we are there.

The restaurant doesn't take reservations that I'm aware of. It has a large, informal dining room w/ lots of tables moved & arranged as needed, plus a few booths. Most recently we were a family group- 8 adults, 2 kids, & 1 infant needing high chair- arriving during the busy period of their popular Friday fish fry & were seated within 15 min. Either stand, play games in the coinless arcade area (uses tickets purchased from a vending machine) or go to the adjoining bar to wait.
Menus are at the tables, customers order & pay at a kitchen counter, food is brought to tables by wait staff. Our diverse order- pizzas (thin-crust & award-winning- deservedly so!), juicy cheeseburgers & fantastic fish frys w/ side choices, a kid's meal- were delivered in 10-15 min. Drinks are self-serve & pay from the usually crowded bar.
When I realized I'd forgotten to order 1 of our meals (my wife's, no less!) several min. after our initial order, the kitchen counter person (who was also the super friendly, efficient, & accommodating owner) had the meal to our table within 10 min. It warranted a generous tip!
Not from the area, this wasn't our 1st visit & definitely isn't our last.

Some of the best pizza in the area!! !

Love the pizza, beer, atmosphere, and price!

This is a family favorite and a must have for all trips back to see family for over 40 years. The variety is great and it’s always a hard choice between fish fry and pizza, so we get both and share! Can’t wait for our next trip.
Sandy from Colorado

Quite a gem on the lakeshore. The service was prompt and friendly and the food was delicious and prepared very fast. The drinks from the bar were also very speedy.

There are multiple dining rooms, some can even accommodate groups at least up to 12 without crowding any other families. Right as you enter there is a game room with a few games for the kids to play. Plenty to keep the kids occupied for a bit.

The food was delicious but the pizza was the best part. There are plenty of options and toppings to keep everyone happy. Their signature size of a "snow coaster" pizza can likely feed more than the 5-7 listed on their menu.

Certainly worth the visit when in town.