Rustlers Steak House

Onion rings, Philly cheese steak sandwich were great. Had to order & pay for dinner rolls. Fish & chips were good but fish cut & fried to small. Service was superior. There were 3 of us & we're definitely going back. Like the new location! Thanks!

We were greeted happily, added to the wait list, seated promptly when it was our turn (less than a 30 min wait). Our waitress took our entire order and the tables next to us without writing it down, and it came out perfect & in a timely manner.
This is an impeccable steak house and I will be back.

Went last weekend, service was friendly and accommodating. we had the ribs, steak tips and baked scallops all of which were delicious. have never had a bad meal or experience here.

Terrific food got the cowboy burger, plenty of blue cheese. Waitress was attentive and we lacked nothing. First time but not the last time I’ll be there.

Everything was excellent! Ask for Jenna to be your waitress she knows all about rustlers Steakhouse! The onion rings are to die for and the nachos with their chili the very best. The ribs were awesome

Really cute local spot with a rustic feel. Loved the decor. Our waitress was at least seven decades old and in addition to taking our order, mentioned that she had baked several pies that morning. So that meant we had to leave room for dessert! I ordered the haddock Reuben and it was divine. The fish perfectly breaded and cooked. The right amount of sauce and cheese. Accompanied by a pile of sweet potato fries, the plate was filled to the brim. My friend ordered the Monte cristo and said it was really good. A delicious lunch. We ordered a slice of chocolate cream pie to share and it was well worth leaving room for. The chocolate pudding was perfectly silky and smooth and generously topped with whipped cream. A lovely lunch all around.

I was craving a turkey dinner and I heard that Rustler's served a homemade turkey dinner every Sunday. It really hit the spot! A heaping mound of white meat turkey covered in gravy, homemade mashed potatoes. Stuffing and squash mounded up on a plate. Cranberry sauce on the side. It was just like my homemade Thanksgiving dinner. I recommend it to anyone. Craving a nice homemade meal.

Food was good, fast friendly service and they was pretty busy. The chili is so good and quite filling

Great food quick service had zero complaints. We were seated in the outside patio area and was nice

We were seated immediately and the chairs and tables are very comfortable! I was there celebrating my birthday with my son, the waitress was soooo attentive and very prompt, also checked on us throughout our meal the perfect amount of times (usually I have to sit and wonder where my waitress is at other places!). All the staff was friendly and especially our waitress. The food was soooo delicious zero complaint! My son was obsessed as well and he’s typically picky! We had been to Rustler’s at its old location (basically across the street lol) but there new building is much nicer! I definitely love it; the whole atmosphere was comfortable and kind of modern rustic AND THE FOOD is even better since they moved! I will be choosing there to eat anytime I want go out to eat from now on, definitely best seafood/steakhouse food around! I don’t know why some say they are expensive, I actually think they’re cheaper than the chain restaurants with better quality food and larger portions!!! Also I was very pleased at the amount of choices on the menu, having a gluten intolerance it can be difficult eating out but there was soo many delicious options that were not fried or breaded for eating gluten free! My son tried Tiramisu for the first time and loved it!! -our order- my son got the chicken finger platter, we got scallops as an appetizer (the dipping sauce with it was amazing!!) then I got the “chicken” stir fry but substituted for steak tips! It was delicious! Amazing time thank you so much, happy to have celebrated my 30th here ♥

We've been a handful of times, and the food and service is always great, and we really like the new space. The wait has a bit long, which is ok, but it seems to be bc the tables aren't turning due to the kitchen being a bit slower. But that could just be a staffing issue. We will return!

Good food, good service, and fun times with friends at Rustlers Steak House.

Excellent location for any event! Food, staff, atmosphere all top notch! My 50th Birthday Suprise party was held here and I could not have imagined anything better! Thank to all that worked on this event! You are wonderful! Kitchen Staff Drinks Food clean up bussing! Every. Single. Aspect!!!!! Such a great place!!!!!!! THANK YOU! Recommend to everyone!💯

Kickass food and customer service!!

if you like french onion soup, you have got to go here. my husband and i always just look at each other in wonderment when we get it, and spend several minutes just brainstorming about what's in it. in a way, i don't want to know, because it would ruin the magic, but at the same time i do want to know. it's incredible. also, i get the chicken tenders and fries tossed in their cajun seasoning, which is also dynomite. oh, and the honey sriracha dipping sauce is also just perfect. big fan of this place!

The service was awesome. The french dip sandwich is one of the best that I have ever had. Fresh bread, the prime rib was to perfection and the au jus was the crown jewel. Well done Rustlers!

Some of the best French onion soup I've had. Restaurant was very busy, but our family had a really nice meal here.

Been here several times and it has never disappointed - food is excellent so is the service and a great atmosphere - I highly recommend it!!

Great spot for some great food and almost any kind of drink to pair it with!

We love it here and definitely our go to place when we’re in north windham!! Always an amazing experience l! The food is fantastic and the service is always friendly and efficient! Their prime rib ravioli is our favorite when they have it! Masons green beans are our go-to appetizer, the chili has just the perfect amount of spice, and they always cook our steak perfect! Make sure you check out their specials board.