Gaetano's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Amazing. I get something different every time I come and it's always the best thing I've ever had. The owner Sherin is from Manhattan and the pizza tastes just like in NYC. I recommend the Buffalo chicken pizza or anything that comes with the homemade meatballs.

We love Tommy. He is so personable. If you don't like it.. he'll make it right.
Wonderful pizza. So tasty we ordered a full one to go home. This may be NY style pizza.. i'm sold.! The store is sadly hidden to the back of a small plaza that can't be seen from the road. I'd like to see it either have more visibility or maybe move. Great job. Never very busy when we're there. But great pizza.

We had many reviews, both negative and positive. This was a PHENOMENAL experience!!!! The meatball sub was EXCELLENT and the antipasti salad was beyond DELICIOUS and the garlic knots....OMG!!!!! We could have eaten them all night!!!
ALL of the Staff were kind, helpful, and very attentive. As my Partner says, this is DEFINITELY a do over!!!

My wife and I have visited this facility in the past when it was owned by past owners a while ago. The food was okay then, but nothing to write home about. I was told a year or so later to try it again, as it came under new management, new chefs, etc. It was a night and day difference. The folks were nice, the place was spotless, and of course, the food was awesome. My recommendations is the Chicken Parmesan, while my wife's recommendation is the pizza, add feta.

I see a below review that didn't have a good experience. I must have been a one off day, as we have been back and things are still really good over there. Especially the garlic knots.

This restaurant now has new management. The pizza is really on point: NY style thin crust, with terrific sauce and fresh ingredients. My wife loves their baked ziti, and their portions are huge. I think this pizza restaurant is one of the best around in the area. Recommend highly!

We ordered this early afternoon through Grubhub. About 25ish minutes later, I received an email stating the restaurant had cancelled our order. Then I received a call from the restaurant asking why we had cancelled as grubhub emailed him that I had cancelled the order though he had just made the food. I was right around the corner and stopped to grab the food and pay directly. I’m so glad he called because the food was excellent and reasonably priced. My mom LOVED her gyro!! We’ll be back!!

Really good pizza joint. Friendly owners and staff. We like thincrust and they do it just right. Wings are meaty and just the right amount of sauce. They're getting busier so plan on 30 minutes for pickup most nights.

Delicious, authentic New York style pizza. Fresh, savory ingredients, homemade taste and housemade sauce! Owned and operated by a wonderful family from New Jersey. I love the service and the food! This is the only place I'll be buying pizza since I first tried theirs!

Luigi's Pizzeria and Cafe is the best! They have a great lunch special (2 slices and a drink for 5$). The pizza and garlic knots are absolutely delicious, the best I've had in Florida!

It's also right off I-95 so if your passing through Port Orange, you got to stop and try it out (Don't confuse this one with the other Luigi's, make sure you go to this one on Taylor Rd. because they are different)

Like their sign says out front "Come in and you will not regret it!"

Thanks for the great Pizza!

Just ordered pizza here for the first time and I have got to say... best pizza I’ve had in town so far! It’s been pretty difficult to find a good pizza but they did it very well. The crust was perfect, not greasy at all and the cheese doesn’t fall off th pizza when you pick it up! New favorite pizza joint:)

I don't see how this place can get bad reviews lol. I had a regular pizza and wings and it was freaking delicious. I'm from chicago and we take our pizza very serious. Great taste and everything, this is definitely one of my top places now. I'm happy I'll be working in Florida a couple months. I'd come here again.

Out of the blue, took a chance and ordered pizza, stromboli, and cheesecake for delivery. I was not only surprised by the prompt delivery but after my first taste of pizza I felt like I was sitting at Angelos in New York City across from the Le Parker Meridien Hotel eating pizza. Thumbs up for finally port orange florida having authentic italian pizza.

This place is amazing! They are unbelievably nice and very flexible. This place is literally the definition of authentic, delicious Italian food! They make everything to order and the sause homemade. Everything taste so amazing and I love everything I've ever tried here. Everything has absolutely fonominal taste! (From garlic knots to the pasta and HOMEMADE marinara sause!)

I've been craving cicilian pizza for about a week now.
Most places.didnt even know.what it was.
You guys delivered and the pizza was to die for.
I'll definitely be storing this number you earned a new customee

This was the best pizza i ever had. I never been inside before but the pizza tastes really great. Im totally getting one more today!

Our family had dinner here tonight there was 12 of us they were very accommodating and friendly. Food was great, place was clean we will definitely go back. Keep up the good work guys!

New owners, very nice guys. Had fettuccini Alfredo, Greek salad, and four cheese pizza. All very good. We will be eating here again.

Just ordered the Hawaiian pan pizza and it is the best pizza I've ever had! The deliverer was such s lovely and kind person also! 11 out of 10 would recommend!

This pizza is very good. I had a very tasty white pizza. The crust is so good it reminds of my grandmother’s homemade bread.

I will be back again and again.

New owners are great!!! And they know how to make a pizza!! Just had today and plan on going back for more
They have alot to choose from !! I highly recommend this place!!!