Wicked Good Bakery

Wicked Good Bakery did an amazing job providing desserts for my wedding in October 2023. Sarah was so easy to work with and everything came out beautiful and delicious. We did a small cake and then mini cupcakes and mini apple cider donut whoopie pies. Everything was a hit! I would highly recommend them for any bakery needs!

Cake was absolutely delicious! I had emailed her my dream wedding cake and she made it on with my budget! Simply elegant! Cookies were yummy! Perfect size for our wedding!

Sarah, Jean, and everyone at WGB are so friendly, welcoming, talented, and helpful! The only thing better than the owners and staff are the goodies, treats, pies, and cakes they prepare. We have used them over and over again during the last couple of years, and it's always a 5 star experience! LOVE having them right in Plymouth, but they're certainly worth the trip if you aren't as lucky to be so close!

I was desperate to find a small cake for my intimate wedding, as there was no one available to accommodate me for our day.

I found Sarah and trusted to purchase her cake and cookies site unseen by photos and google reviews.

She is located right off the highway so it was easy to pickup on our way more north to Bretton Woods!

She had great communication the whole 6+ months we were planning and I only got to try the caramel latte cake we ordered on the day of our wedding and it was PHENOMENAL! The dogs loved their pup cake as well.

Thank you for adding a piece of love to our day Sarah!!!!

(Cakes are gone but here’s the best snickerdoodle cookies I’ve ever had!)

My husband ordered a cake for my 50th birthday and it was SO YUMMY!!!!! Everyone raved about it. 25 people devoured a cake that fed 40 people. That's how good it was. She nailed the design too. I highly recommend the cakes here.

This past week the Wicked Good Bakery provided the most beautiful wedding cake and fresh assortment of delicious pies for our wedding. They were so good that everbody gorged about all of it, and we had to hide some in order to have a bit later on. Thank you, Wicked Good. We love everything about you!

Oh my goodness! We were looking for a cake for my son's birthday while visiting the area. We come every year and have been disappointed in the past by highly rated places. We took a chance on wicked good bakery and OMG! The cake (chocolate with Oreo filling and vanilla icing) was truly exceptional. My second chocolate hater child gobbled it up and asked for seconds. The birthday boy's eyes lit up with the first bite. Even the adults were thrilled and we are all looking forward to the leftovers (which I'm told also freeze very well). You can stop looking. This is the place you want!

Their goodies always taste amazing and we order from them for all our children's birthday cakes! Always been given exactly what we asked for on flavor and decoration. We really love their eclairs as well, definitely recommend.

We used Wicked Good Bakery for our wedding desserts and they were absolutely amazing! From the very first email, Sarah was so communicative and helpful. She made the process so fun and stress free. We had a variety of mini desserts and a small wedding cake for us to cut and everything was delicious! Our guests couldn’t stop raving about them! Thank you so much to everyone at Wicked Good Bakery who helped us have exactly what we wanted for our wedding day!

We have used Wicked Good several times, the owner is super nice and the cakes are always delicious with an outstanding appearance! Highly recommend for any baking needs!

Working with Sarah for our wedding order was a dream. Communication was excellent, pricing was better than anywhere else we looked, and her creations are not only beautiful, but delicious (I highly recommend the mocha latte cake flavor in particular). Sarah designed our stunning wedding cake based on a picture I sent her for inspiration, and I could not have been happier with the result. It looks like something out of a magazine! THANK YOU, Wicked Good Bakery for your fantastic service and for making our wedding day even more special. We will certainly be back for more.

For our wedding we opted for cupcakes vs cake. Omg to die for! All the guests loved them! My husband has a very picky sweet tooth and loved the cupcakes! They looked beautiful! We got vanilla, chocolate, strawberry and a mocha one, definitely recommend. Sarah was so nice and made everything so easy!

My husband and I ordered a 6" red velvet cake with textured cream cheese frosting as our "tasting cake" for our wedding and it was DELICIOUS! It was simple, but it was gorgeous! Sarah was very quick to respond and executed our every request. Thank you Wicked Good Bakery! 5 Stars!

Randomly decided to stop by with my sister during a road trip from Ohio. Order in advance if you want something specific because the selection is small and limited... bought out all of the available cupcakes and Samoa cookies and they are AMAZING!!! We will definitely be calling in advance to place an order the next time we are planning a trip here so we can sample more of the delicious treats!

This place is simply the best place to be on a Saturday morning! The doughnuts have become ritual for my family. My daughter loved her unicorn cupcakes for her "covid party" birthday, they brightened up what could have been a grey birthday.

It's all in the name, wicked good! All of our guests, and us, loved the cupcakes at our wedding. The flavor selection was as perfect as the cupcakes. Beautiful and delicious. Highly recommend!!

I picked up a dozen muffins and pie. These are my favorite muffins. Their muffins are moist and dense. The pie is great too. The owner has won several baking competitions, and it's obvious why. I can't recommend them any more strongly than that, they're wicked good...

SHer talent is incredible and I couldn't be more happy with what she is doing for my wedding... The chocolate cover Strawberries are amazing ,cupcakes and cookies , cinnamon buns and donuts and sticky bun are AMAZING AND HOMEMADE ..IF YOU ARE IN THE LINCOLN NEW HAMPSHIRE AREA YOU MUST GO SEE to Plymouth

This bakery lives up to its name and wow are the floral decorations on the cupcakes just stunning! And the crew is absolutely lovely!

A nice glass display case with a lot of sweet treats to pick from.