Comley's Country Creamery

We were so thankful that the kind owner opened early for us as we didn't realize they didn't open until noon. We were greeted by two friendly pups and a cheerful hello from the owner. Our mouths were watering as we looked around the shop, and after several purchases, we enjoyed some tasty treats on our journey home. The chocolate milk was the creamiest and most flavorful I've ever tasted. And the coffee cake and cinnamon rolls are outstanding!! If you haven't been here yet, it is definitely worth the trip and ne sure to buy some extras because they won't last long, haha.

BEST MILK EVER !!!! Truly a small town family owned & run dairy. Free range beautiful happy, healthy cows !!! Their goodies are fabulous, cheesecake & cinnamon rolls are to die for !! The no bakes are delish !!! Jellies , fresh ground peanut butter and other great stuff too ... Fabulous farm fresh butter, plain & other flavors, local fresh eggs and so much more.. Stop in, you will be glad u made the trip !!!!

I have been drinking their milk for quite some time and it is phenomenal, best milk around, and the family is very friendly and sweet. Their products are fresh and delicious! I just bought there homemade coffee cake! I cannot wait to have it but I’m sure it’s delicious!

You just gotta go there, the coffee cake is the best I've ever had, the milk is delicious. Old school hospitality. Be sure to give Butch some head scratches.

Absolutely the best milk you could possibly get! Cream on the top is the best tasting milk I've ever had! They also have the best baked goods and desserts too! All kinds of canned products and homemade corn chips are a favorite as well! Always a friendly atmosphere also!

After years of making stops at the old truck stop off the Mexico exit to buy the best chocolate milk there is (well traveled and have tried a hundred of them) I find out that I can go straight to the cow (down the road,)which I will be doing from now on. Comleys cremery is about to know me well.

Great people. Great blackberry cheesecake. Excellent milk!

There milk is the best. They are also very nice people.

Best place! Need fresh milk.. they've got it.. heavy cream . Yessss. Chocolate milk yummy. Butter the best! Home baked treats too!!!!

Great products, bread was so good we ate the whole loaf on our car ride! The owner greeted us and explained the treatment of the cows- how they don’t use hormones and are grass fed. He gave our boys free chocolate milks for being first time customers. They said it was great. I just ate the peanut butter, it’s amazing.

If you happen to be in Mexico, NY I highly recommend stopping by this amazing family run store! Comley's Country Creamery has an amazing selection when It comes to baked goods as well as fresh tasty milk!
- Very friendly
- good prices
- Freshly baked

Absolutely wonderful. We have tried to get there for over a year. Finally did and was 100% worth the wait. Coffee cake, a gallon of milk, some chocolate milk for the kids. 3x sharp cheddar. Absolutely great. Prices were in line with what you would expect. They do accept credit cards as well. Will definitely be returning.

Awesome northern NY farm operation. Fantastic products, friendly service and the best chocolate milk!

Wonderful family run farm with excellent products. They're even open on Sundays. Much worth the trip into Mexico if you're from out of town.

Only place around to get milk if you want the real thing. So much better than the store bought stuff. Love this place.

Great service! Very nice people. The cashier was very polite and enjoyed the company. The milk is absolutely the best I've had. And the cinnamon rolls are home made and taste great!

Comleys milk sets the gold standard in dairy products. Their whole milk is rich and creamy and non homogenized! I ESPECIALLY LOVE their chocolate milk. The family are just as amazing as the products they provide!

We love this place. Great milk, butter, jam and baked goods. Everyone is so welcoming and friendly, you feel like part of the family. Thank you John and Will.

Great family owned farm store. Ultra fresh products.

There's no other places like this around! Farm fresh milk, home baked bread, nutty coffee cake, iced cinnamon buns, triple sharp cheddar cheese, and old fashioned birch beer soda are just a few of my favorite things. All made right on the farm or locally!