Mafia Pizza / now known as Papa & Nonna’s Pizzeria

Hadn't been back for a long while, tried again and the gluten free Bianco was pretty good tonight. Will go back for that.

Mafia is a great blend of small town feel and big city flavor! They have good pizza and pretty good wings. Big fan of their Buffalo chicken pizza and the godfather! I don’t think you’ll be disappointed with anything you get at Mafia!

This was the best pizza I've had and there isn't a close 2nd. I tried it today for the 1st time and it was amazing. The husband and wife owners are super friendly and down to earth. I'll be a frequent visitor

Hands down the best pizza, chicken wings and people! We drive from Valdosta just to get their food and the hospitality is amazing they make you feel like family ❤ thank you for doing what you do!!

Calzones are delicious. I had mine stuffed with pepperoni, sausage and bacon. The Mrs. had sausage; while the youngin had cheese pizza.

Great family focused restaurant! Service was excellent; wide variety of food choices. A hidden gem in Monticello!!

Friendly staff, fast food AND a FRESH salad bar. Nice cozy atmosphere this is the BEST pizza in north Florida!

Food was great! I got the Strom-Zone and will get just a Stromboli next time as it was amazing. Loud inside when we first arrived but as a few families left and others came it got quieter to where we can hear each others conversations. Waitress was very attentive and “on the ball”. Small place but very busy. Lots of people picking up food. My mom said the Greek salad is not worth the price ($9 I believe). No real substance to the salad as it was all iceberg lettuce that overflowed the place and very little other ingredients. My dad loves his salad and everyone loved their pizza from what I could tell.

FYI for the owner...y’all had an issue with Clover while we were there. Take it from someone who lost a ton using them...switch to a different company! Square would even be better but there are ones made specifically for restaurants. Dump Clover before it becomes an expensive paperweight for y’all too. After loosing a $15,000 sale because of their glitch (payment was taken and said to have gone through. It even printed a receipt but it never actually processed.) and zero support from them in the matter it wasn’t worth all the other issues too.

We love this place, food is the best, staff professional and friendly. Good prices

Enjoying the best Bloody Mary and excellent service on this rainy Sunday morning! Highly recommend Mafia for any time of day. They never disappoint with the best food and wonderful friendly service!

My daughter and I split the difference in distance to have lunch and visit together. Having cooked made from scratch home cooked meals for over 50 years I've never been a huge fan of restaurants BUT we found Mafia Pizza to be ABSOLUTELY OUTSTANDING‼ I would give it 10 stars if I could. I had the shrimp po boy with homemade onion rings and my daughter a chicken wrap and salad bar. Everything was so fresh and the flavor excellent; seasoned to perfection. It's a small quaint place and clean; very clean. That reflects on the commitment of the owner (he's cute as a button). I can't wait to make the hour drive to go back and eat here again. Absolutely delicious!!!!!

This is by far the best pizza I have had
Salad bar is phenomenal. We will be back.

I loved there food so much that I came back twice in one day. The service was outstanding, the food was just awesome, and the prices was great. If you want real Italian food, this place is the best ever. Please folks come check them out, you won't be disappointed.

Absolutely amazing! Love their grilled chicken caesar salad. Stromboli's are also delish as well!

Had Baked Ziti. Some of the best ever. Others had hand tossed pizza. The loved them. Beautiful salad bar. Smiling faces all around from staff. Definitely will be a repeat customer

We had a good time playing. Courtney was the Best. We enjoyed entertaining everyone. The godfather pizza was crazy good. Thanks for have us.

Try it once and you will be back every weekend- just like us 🍕🍺🍹
Excellent service and atmosphere! Highly recommend!

Excellent pizza - had their Supreme. We are from New Haven, CT - home of Pepe's and Sally's apizza. Mafia pizza is in the same league - Highly Recommended. Sorry we couldn't try your Drunken Mussels - they sound delicious. Perhaps next time when we are in the area.

OMG... astoundingly great pizza!
Go there!! Just do it!!

Amanda my new favorite bartender, was amazing down to earth served up great drinks and made my experience amazing! Ralf the Owener, gave me some good information on the menu and cooked us some amazing Cod and Salmon! The food was out of this world good!! Courtney was also a pleasure! The staff here was amazing, the food was amazing, the people just everything!! Come here you won't be disappointed! Shelby also was awesome because she let us know about the side of the restaurant we almost missed and truly made sure we had a great experience.

I dipped my broccoli in the butter in the bottom of my cod plate and I almost went to heaven!