McGillicuddy's

The food here is excellent. Wing sauce game is strong! They also make a great Spinach - chicken - cheese dip in a sourdough bread bowl. I will say their prices have gone up a bunch and dining in service is challenging to get served in a timely manner. But you have to let it go. Because yummy wings and spin dip are too good 😊

This is a classic place to go. The service is great and the food is good. The honey Buffalo wings either boneless or bone in are delicious. If it’s not busy the food comes out pretty quick. I don’t go here that often anymore but still like going every once in a while.

My buddy and I drove 90 mins to New Paltz from CT for the Pro Palestine rally. We stopped here for some food before heading home and we had Alyssa! She was amazing, patient and very efficient. The food was VERY good and came out quick. Prices are also very reasonable.

Would love to come back in the future!

A friend took me here for lunch, and it was delicious. Loved the atmosphere, and will definitely recommend/return.

Food here was hearty and delicious. I ordered a cowboy burger and chili on the side and they exceeded my expectations.

As for the dining environment, the only downside is that if you eat at the bar, the music is pretty loud. They could probably lower the volume a little bit. But otherwise, great food.

One of, if not my favorite, bar in the hudson valley. Really delicious food with reasonable pricing, fantastic drinks that don't drain your bank account, overall great aesthetic. Love this bar, so many great memories.

Very good place and party place. Street looks like an happening place during the weekends. We stoped here while on the way of our trip searching for diner place and we found and went thinking like a regular sports bar. But looking inside it is so good and we loved the inside architecture. If we get chance we will definitely stop by again.

French onion soup was very good
GARLIC SHRIMP over pasta tastless

Went to college in New Paltz over 10 years ago. McGillicuddy's back then has given me so many great memories. Wing Nights especially. I've gone back to visit a few times and Cuddy's is a must to go to. My favorite menu item is the spinach and cheese bread bowl. So delicious! Being there brings me back to some of my most favorite memories with some of my favorite friends.

Excellent service and great food. Very loud but a good loud. You could tell people were having a good time. College vibes for sure on a College town. Burger was juicy and tasty and the Guinness was poured perfectly.

Great food, great service perfect sports bar. We were in town and wanted to watch football. They renovated the place and it's much nicer than the pictures look. Everything I ate was delicious. Spacious interior seating covid friendly.

There for a birthday party, great time. Dry rub wings are the best!

Classic sports bar that serves sport bar food that is actually really good. If you got an American food craving and want some beer check it out. The shepherds pie is also surprisingly good I did not expect it to be on the menu but I was pleasantly surprised after eating it. The wings also are very good.

Had a great experience. Our waitress was great, service was prompt, food was delicious, and the portions were large. Had enough to bring home and eat for lunch the next day.

Food was great, staff friendly and provided good service!

Always the best wings. Teriyaki and Gold Fever. Worth the trip just for them. Garlic parm fries.

My favorite place in New Paltz to get wings or a drink. Not to mention the amazing staff!

Really enjoyed it here. Food was excellent. Staff was on top of everything and kind. They also have awesome kid stuff. Treasure box at the end of a meal for kids is awesome.

🍀Proper Pipers! Home cured 🍖corned beef, 🧆potatoes, 🍞 soda bread, & add your favorite pint...🍻 A worthy St.Patricks celebration 🍀

Food was so good. The soup alone filled us up. The wait staff was fast and friendly. Covid safe too! I felt safe and comfortable.