Tony Boloney’s Pier Village

I was a little overwhelmed by all the creative and yummy sounding pizza creations here.....the taco pizza looks amazing. But I wound up getting a plain slice just to see....and it was so good! Their sauce is a little sweet which I love and very rich tasting and the cheese good too. Overall a 9/10

This pizza is phenomenal! I make sure to go at least once a week. Ahmad does an excellent job with cooking & customer service!!! You guys rock

Best pizza in Long Branch! We've been coming here for years, food is always hot and ready before we pickup. Danny always has a great attitude and makes sure our food is top quality!

Went to AC a few months ago and ate at that Tony Boloney's and was immediately hooked, came to long branch and was so excited to see one here. GREAT food, GREAT service. Worth every penny. So excited for the new location!

There is always a line out the door on the weekend but it really moves quickly. It’s a great spot for pizza!
We got the plain, pinky and my favorite, the burratta!

Some of the best pizza you'll find in New Jersey

Yes, it’s on the Pier Village boardwalk, yes it’s right by the beach, yes it’s super local. All good reasons to try Tony Boloney’s. Their pizza is a great example of Jersey style pizza is a reason to keep on coming back. I ordered a slice and they heated up a slice for me. It came to me, on two plates; it’s that big! It still had a crispness to it despite being a reheated slice, it tasted fresh, very good sauce to cheese ratio and all had a great flavor. I can’t wait to order a fresh pie!
I’m told their sandwiches are on point as well.

So, now you know. Now, go out and give them a try!

Consistent and easygoing place for a slice (or check out their other menu options too!). We love going on the week days when it’s much less crowded. Everyone who works there is great and they remember our faces and always say hello.

Incredible pizza and subs made with fresh quality ingredients. Staff is always helpful and accommodating.
Creative and unique specials not available anywhere else on this planet!
Been going to the Hoboken location for years, same quality and service at the LB location with lots more seating!

This is the place you go to if you want a good solid inspired non-traditional slice.

If you go here and order a plain slice, you are a literal piece of trash that does not deserve to share this world with the rest of us. Seriously, go to hell you basic asshat.

If you like specialty type pizza, you'll dig this place. My favorite things here however are the belly-busting sandwiches! Soooooo good 😋

Awesome grub and the beach?! What else ya need! Smack on the water with quick slices and sub. Y’all make everything from scratch so I appreciate the extra 5 minute wait. Well Well worth it. Panco Franco slice is unreal. Highly recommend. I try and new menu item every time I’m over in Pier Village. Keep it up!! Next up is the taco pizza 🍕 🌮

Amazing pizza! Another great place by my school! The Burrata pizza is extremely addicting cause it’s sooooooo good!! Many of the pizzas looked extremely delicious!!! I need to try all the flavors cause every single one of them looked mouthwatering!! The soda machine is also very interesting! Birch beer was fire!! I’m coming back!

This is the best pizza place ever! Don’t listen to the bad reviews. The FOOD the service everything incredible! Ive ordered almost everything on the menu!

Excellent pizza! We arrived at closing with 15 in our group and they stayed open to serve us! Great service beyond the call of duty!

Boloneys rib sub is a must get if it's your first visit. Fall off the bone meat. Service was ok but the food made up for it

Tony Baloney's is always incredible. Whether it's for sandwiches, pizza or fries it's a great lunch spot. Highly recommend. Fresh food always.

Fantastic as always and super happy to not have to make the trek to Hoboken or Atlantic City!! Best cheesesteaks on the planet, with the nicest owner and staff.

If you're looking for pizza in Long Branch this is the place! Just plain delicious! And friendly helpful service as well.

Best cheesesteak on earth. Pizza is incredible and inventive. So excited for this new location closer to home!!! ❤❤❤❤❤