The Main Street Creamery

The ice cream was AMAZING! They had this lemon honeycomb ice cream which was the best ice cream I have ever had IN MY LIFE. The only thing I was not too fond of was the marshmallow topping. I thought it came toasted, but I wasn’t and there was way too much. Next time I would just go without it because the ice cream was so amazing on its own!

Ice cream is so good every time! Friendly service and everything from cones, sundaes, to milkshakes. Flavors are delicious and beautiful place to sit down outside or inside. Has a lot of charm in the building it is located in.

The ice cream was absolutely delicious. The portions were HUGE!

Arrived here after dinner at the bistro across the street and down a block. Was planning to get a waffle cone and just eat that because I can't eat regular ice cream. Hubs had gotten a luscious dairy -laden treat after dinner. Well, I discovered the vegan option here. It was coconut milk-based and DELICIOUS. The young women in this shop were all super-nice and very helpful. I got two scoops in a waffle bowl and could only eat about half of it. I'd order this all the time if I lived closer. Price was reasonable.. around $8.

What a great addition to wellsboro, we will definitely make this a new tradition as part of our cabin vacation. The ice cream was some of the best I've ever had. The building is super cool , and staff is friendly and able to accommodate alot of people at one time

This is the best ice cream I have had in my long life of eating ice cream. They make it in house and the flavors can vary wildly based on who is making it. I was there 2 days ago and one of the servers (who were both friendly and knowledgeable) said that the cinnamon bun was their favorite. I tried it, as I've never had it from there before, and it taste like biting into a cinnamon roll. Absolutely spot on. I got 2 pints to go.

One of the things I like so much about their ice cream is that it is creamy. Now, I know you'll say "Ice cream is supposed to be creamy!" and you would be right! but I've never had ice cream as creamy as this. It leaves behind an amazing mouth feel that has you licking your lips even as you go to take another bite. I dont know what it is that they put in that makes it so creamy, and at this point I dont care. I'm looking forward to my next visit, and the next after that.

TLDR: This is an adorable and charming place with the best ice cream I've ever had.

Amazing ice cream. All made right there. I got 2 scoops and could barely finish it. Nice portion size. I would have posted a picture, but once I tried the ice cream, it didn't have a chance

Super cute little shop in Wellsboro. Ice cream was delicious and you get your money’s worth. Enjoy!

Delicious homemade ice cream and both classic and unique flavors. I god zucchini chocolate chip and black raspberry and enjoyed them.

Was traveling through from pine creek rail trail. Stopped for some ice cream in a refurbed old house. The ice cream was delicious , nice and creamy. The building with the wood mantle fire place and fountain bar in another room was very nice.

Such a charming little ice cream shop! Freshly made waffle cones. The lemon honeycomb was the best (though I opted for a root beer float)

When you walk into this place, the wonderful smell is the first thing you notice! I had the banana's foster and the lemon bash! The lemon bash was over the top AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!! I wish I had a freezer in my truck to take home some! Do they ship??? Lol

This is a great little place for ice cream in Wellsboro in a beautiful old building. The homemade ice cream is excellent. Prices are very reasonable. We’ll definitely be back when I’m the area.

Truly one of the best milkshakes I have *ever* had: chocolate with a dash of peanut butter!

My favorite is the pistachio ice cream 🍨

During our four day stay near Wellsboro we have visited this ice cream parlor twice and we plan to make another visit before we leave tomorrow. Their ice cream is so delicious. We have tried nine flavors between my family of four so far and we loved every one of those flavors. They are flavorful and rich. Reminds me of J.P. Licks in Boston. Already looking forward to our next visit. Yum!!!

The Ice Cream was delicious I had 4 different flavors and all of them were great. Kit Kat was my favorite :P

Decided to stop for ice cream after biking the PA Grand Canyon. Between 6 of us, we tried 5 different flavors. All were exceptional. My family enjoys locating and trying different local ice cream shops and this one was great.

Great homemade homestyle ice cream. Tonight's treat was a black raspberry milkshake!

Great service. Great ice cream. Great owners. 10/10