Amy's Pizza

The food and the atmosphere are great, and the people who work there are have always been very nice and welcoming. It's one of my favorite places to eat when I'm in town. Imagine a diner in the middle of the country with great music and service and even better food, and you've got Amy's.

Wonderful place to eat! Love the decor! Fast, friendly and great prices! I think it's funny how people get so bent out of shape over a picture though. If it was someone they liked, they wouldn't have an issue with it. Just saying! Coming back soon! Enjoy yourselves, life's too short not to!

The great reviews here did not disappoint! We were staying in a cabin with no kitchen, so we had to get all of our meals in town. I called for carry out pizza. It was ready when I arrived, and we couldn't believe how much food we got versus the super reasonable price that we paid. This is a must visit for anyone who visits Shipshewana!

What a quaint, wonderful little place. The decor is an amazing chunk of Americana. The food was very inexpensive and yet extremely tasty. I had the chicken club 8in sub sandwich. It was not only delicious, it was interesting. Instead of mayo, I believe the used a creamy Italian dressing. I would say it's an absolute must stop if you're in the mood for pizza or sandwiches and you're in the area.

This is the second time being here and I have got to say they have the best food. They have a great service and a great atmosphere. I get the pizza house sub every time and I and never disappointed. So for that I give 5 stars

Very cozy place with friendly staff and GOOD PIZZA 😋😋👍👍

We were excited to try Amy's restaurant and we were very pleased! The food was great! We stopped for lunch and were suprised our drink was included with our order. We met Amy, and was grateful to see her Trump sign ! We'll be back ! Thanks Amy!

Great place to eat. It's a family owned business and doesn't have a lot of help but they manage just fine. The food is great for the price.

I was wandering around for a long while with my gps taking me all over until I was hungry! I pulled into Amy's simply because the car behind me was tailgating and I was just *so* frustrated. Inside, it was quiet and calm, with the other customers looking relaxed. I was offerred assistance shortly, and I ordered their bbq pizza with extra cheese. It was delicious! As I've often noted, bbq pizza can be hit or miss when traveling, but this was made very fresh and was exactly what I needed to end my frustration. I am leaving happy, full and satisfied!

Great food, great service. Doesn't take long at all to get your food, and will make it how you like it. Very pleased 😁

We was very happy with our pizza and my wife said it was the best pizza she has had in a while. We would definitely recommend Amy’s!

Amy and staff are the best!!!! I eat here every day the best pizza and subs around plus you buy ten you get one free check it out gonna miss you

Awesome pizza! And they have a gluten free crust that is good. Quaint atmosphere and friendly service. We highly recommend it!

Best pizza in town, very courteous & respectful owners and all around great atmosphere

Excellent service, excellent food, quaint atmosphere. You can't go wrong with eating here.

Very good pizza. The atmosphere is unique and pleasing. I'm very impressed.

Amazing place. We stayed across the street. Food was great and the staff was friendly and welcoming.

Food was delivered fast, amazing flavors! Definitely will eat there again!

It wasn't very busy. The food was reasonably priced. And the pizza was delicious

Awesome food! Fabulous service!!! Small home town atmosphere.