Mount Forest pizza

We have found a gem! We come from another town to get pizza here . It's worth the drive! Flavour is great , it's consistently good, and price is a great deal ! The owner is very kind and so are the employees . Once you try it you'll be hooked !

We had such a lovely man serving us our order he was incredible at customer service, so much that my daughter wanted to return to tip him. We ordered wings and strips today the wings here are always amazing, the best and amazing sauces. As usual great food, best value and quick and courteous service. We picked up tonight but the delivery drivers are always awesome, we love their shwarma poutine and pizza and the greek salad is theee best. When Feeding a crowd we grab a party deal and sides and it feeds our small army for an affordable price.

The pizza is a bit on the heavy side and the sauce can certainly be better. With that being said the quality and quantity you get for the price can't be beat ! Also id recommend the chicken wings juicy and well cooked will certainly order again.

Update: chicken shawarma poutine was delicious!

Great pizza, we have ordered from here several times and everytime both employees and food have bin great.

Great pizza, consistent quality way above what you would expect in a small town, and in my opinion far better than Pizza Hut or Dominos. Good pick-up service and the pizza value on the specials is outstanding. (100% recommend for the pizza, I haven't tried the other food or delivery service.)

August 17, 2021
After experiencing the best pizza ever, I went back and ordered 2 panzerotti’s. Well, all I can say is WOW!!!! If only Google offered a 10 star selection!! They take the time to bake your panzerotti (not like the fast pizza places that deep fry them). Baking is much healthier as well.
The EATALIAN PIZZA place does not skimp on their ingredients. Our panzerotti’s were FULLY STUFFED with the 3 ingredients that we choose. Most pizza places leave a bunch of crust around the edges. The EATALIAN PIZZA place stuffs their ingredients right to the edges of the dough. You will not be disappointed if you order a Panzerotti. We bought their PANZO SPECIAL for $16.99 (plus tax) which included two (2) 3 toppings panzerotti’s, two (2) cans of pop and the choice of two (2) dipping sauces. You can’t beat that price for such an AWESOME TASTING Panzerotti !!!
This is definitely the best pizza and panzerotti place in town! Make sure to check them out in Mount Forest! Sorry no picture this time. After taking one bite, I could not stop and then realized after my panzerotti was all gone that I forgot to take a picture to show this incredible panzerotti!!!

August 7, 2021
Everything was AMAZING! They don’t skimp on the toppings. I ordered a Party Combo with 3 pizzas, 2 lbs of wings, garlic bread w/cheese, dips and pop. The pizza was awesome, the wings were big and meaty, the garlic bread was very cheesy.
No more “brand name” pizza places for us anymore. EATALIAN PIZZA is our #1 choice for pizza now!
Can’t wait for next time to try their Panzerotti’s!
Give this place a try. You will NOT be disappointed.

Finally someone who understands 'thin crust'!!!! And, not doughy like Titos. Our opinion, Mount Forest pizza is best in town!!! Thank you.

Ordered pizza on Friday night for the first time and it was ready really quick (under 20 mins) and at a great price. The crust was awesome, crispy on the bottom and fluffy on the top. The sauce was also delicious. One note: if you get sundried tomatoes it will be huge pieces! They taste great but the restaurant should likely cut them a little smaller, I had whole or half large tomatoes on the pizza!

Great service and excellent delivery range. One of the better pizza stores in the area. Highly recommend mount forest pizza for quality and service.

Latest update: Chicken Shawarma Poutine, mmmmmm heaven atop my fries. I'm in love!
Im pretty hard to impress when it comes to pizza, but this one will have me coming back for more! happy to hear the wraps are on the way too!

Good fluffy crust. First time getting pizza here and it is delicious. Easy to order online, and pickup was a breeze.

Very tasty pizza and Pickles. Went twice within days of first visit because I was craving more lol

Always great pizza made fast and at a reasonable price

Amazing place! By far the best pizza place to come to Mount Forest yet. Price is amazing, especially for what you get! 9/10 pizzas I've got from them were loaded well and were fulfilling. If you guys can post your toppings online so that we can organize prior to calling then I'd give a 5/5.

Great pizza! New to the area, read the reviews and was not disappointed.
Will definitely be on speed dial.

Pizza was delicious and fresh. Toppings were plentiful and crust was fluffy and perfectly crispy. It could have used more sauce. But that didn't take away from the flavor too much. Friendly and efficient service.

Like Dave and Frankie from one bite From YouTube. I gave the pizza slice a 7.7 and the price a 10 out of 10. The staff is very friendly and the pizza is good not as good as Tito’s in Arthur.

I really like Eatalian Pizza. There are a lot of options for pizza in Mount Forest, and all of them have their charms, but this is the only pizzeria where I can get anchovies. Not a sell for a lot of people, but it has made my day on a number of occasions.

Food is always prepared well and in good time. Comfort food that is comforting. I look forward to occasions where I can order from this place.

Some of the best local pizza I've ever had, especially the crust, and a great walk-in price of $15 for a large with 5 toppings!

Update: Had a small delivery issue and they came good and resolved the problem. Thanks guys for fixing that and sorry I got grumpy.

These guys are FANTASTIC!!
Best pizza in town for sure. So glad you came to Mount Forest!! We had a large five topping pizza and it was one heavy pizza when it arrived. Our delivery driver was new in town and a total sweetheart. Thanks to the whole team for making our Friday night awesome!! We'll be back!!