Witchy Pies & Cakery /Cookies Galore

Great place for a pie stop, I had the mince pie. The pastry was crispy and the meat was flavoursome 10/10.

Also, we have some of the best coffees so far on our trip around southern WA (that comings from a resident melburnian)

A real pleasant surprise in a tiny little town just south of Margaret River! I had a "Mexican pie" filled w beans, jalapenos, and some magic ingredients -- really super. My wife had an equally delicious toast pesto chicken sandwich. And then we opted for a couple desserts -- the key lime pie is to die for; we haven't started on the other All super scrumptuous and very reasonable price. Nice, funky little place w friendly staff too.

We went out for bike ride on the Wadandi Track and took a quick stop at Witchy Pies. They have various kinds of pies, sandwiches and desserts. We had Mexican Pie & Pesto Chicken Croissant and Lime Pie ... Very tasty!!!

Back from a hike and looking for a great coffee and snack this place will satisfy your tastebuds .

Coffee was great and Miss L said it was the BEST hot chocolate she’s ever had .
Bought an assortment of cakes to share . All tasted great . 👌

Really great GF pies as well as regular ones. For a family with over half coeliacs this kept everyone happy. For me it was the best gluten free pie I’ve ever had and the regular stuff rated highly from others in the family.

Super yummy pies & sausage rolls. The team did a great job at facilitating us in a rather large group for both food and drink orders. Special shout out to the new girl training on the till when we came in. Very impressive in how well she managed the sudden rush of customers and stayed on top of orders. We will be back next time we are in town.

Smiles my sausage roll was the best sausage roll in the world.
R.I.P Smiles

Passed by Witchcliffe and couldn't resist stopping for a photo. Witchy pies was an unexpected delight! Best sausage roll I've had in ages and all of the baked goods were on point (especially the apple turnover! That was divine). Will go out of my way to stop here again if travelling through Maragret River and you should too! I don't know what sort of witchcraft they use to make the pies, but I'm ok with it!

Perfect place to stop for lunch or a snack when touring around Margaret River. The pies were delicious and very fairly priced. There's a great selection of pies, sausage rolls, and sweet baked goods. There are tables to the side if you'd like to eat in.

Phenomenal gluten free pie - I had the beef, mushroom and wine one and bought two more for home. Delicious gf peach and almond tart for dessert. People were great too. Thanks for making my day!

Loves their pies. Found them by accident but so far the best pies we have ever tasted ❤ had the pull pork one and was so juicy. This one pictured is beef steak and cheese.

Fantastic pies. Choose my other chunky or minced. Also great selection of cakes all made on the premises. excellent bakery

The zucchini tart was delicious!! I also enjoyed the pulled pork pie. Joanne was friendly as well!

They have moved from their old premises to a bigger place and they added more items to their menu! My favourite are the macadamia nut cookies! You can also make an order through the phone and they will deliver anywhere in Australia.

Excellent pies and coffees. Their fillings and crust are perfect matches. We bought 3 pies and coffees along our way back to Margaret River town and were amazed by the taste!

Their beef and kidney pie is extremely flavourful. Will definitely be back if we have the chance to visit Margaret River again. Definitely a must-go if you’re travelling along Bussell Highway!

Visited a couple of times on a recent visit to the area. My partner enjoyed the beef options. I had the spinach, ricotta and mushroom roll, which was delightful! A great idea for a combo. The vege pastie wasn't my style though, I prefer chunky veg and this was quite smooth. Coffee was good! Definitely recommend a stop here. Witchcliffe really punches above its weight in terms of awesome shops in a tiny town.

Don't drive past when driving between Margaret River and Augusta
Stop here
The best yummiest pie shop ever
Good luck trying to choose something
Everything is fresh and delicious
And did I mention the coffee
Perfect
And the young girl working there
4 th generation and super friendly!

Friendly service, great pies. 5 star bakery.

There coffees where tasty and I am very picky. The coffee pistachio mirangue was the best mirangue i have ever had. I wasn't a fan of the pies but each to there own :) . Decorations and service was lovely

Their selection of pies and pastries are amazing . We were astonished to find proper Gluten Free separation and then found out a staff member is Gluten Intolerant and they have tested to Coeliac safety.
The flavours in the carrot cake and key lime slice would be amazing for a normal pastry, so just delicious.
The standard beef and mushroom pie was delicious and yes we will drive the 50kms to get more Gluten Free pastries including an Apple Pie.