Coffin Sally

Was recommended this place by the hotel and it did NOT disappoint! Great flavours of pizza! Wide variety of drinks. Service and conversation was great, including spot-on suggestions for food and drink! One point- do ask the origin of the name Coffin Sally... so awesomely Australian!

Pizzas and beers were heaven in a great friendly relaxing atmosphere. Cheers guys. Great place we accidentally found when looking for dinner.

Great pizzas, friendly and super helpful staff and a nice atmosphere.
We were squeezed in on a chilly night despite the restaurant being fully booked. The staff were all so pleasant - we’ll definitely be going back. Thanks

Atmosphere, service and pizza was top notch! Definitely recommend if you're looking for a place with a good vibe in a small town.

I have been here a few times now and every time has been great. The pizzas are delicious - they are the perfect size to either have to yourself as a meal or to share as a snack. The toppings are generous. There’s a great drinks menu with cocktail and beer specials, including non-alcoholic options. Looking forward to going again.

Port Fairy's gourmet pizza restaurant and takeaway, they serve takeaway straight to Sackville St passers by and also have a dining room behind the shop look for the door marked BAR and follow the passage.
Recommend the pear prosciutto and Gorgonzola pizza, heavenly combination.

Absolutely beautiful dining experience! We stopped in for dinner at Coffin Sally and loved it. The pizza and cocktails are amazing, the staff are all so kind, and the atmosphere is great :) Highly recommend!

Went 2 nights in a row. Staff were an excellent well oiled machine that made it look easy. Place was booked out and they could not do enough to help. Atmosphere food drinks and staff all excellent.

Literally 10/10! Food and cocktails were delicious and came out quickly. All the staff were so lovely and the whole place is just a vibe! Great little find!

Very impressed, this cosy little place packs a giant flavour punch! Pizzas were delicious and there was a great vibe, open fire, beautifully decorated and overall warm and inviting interior. Despite being booked out, the wait staff were very lovely and accommodating. I was seated at the bar and was still very pleased with the food, drinks and attentive service. Highly recommend this place!

It's often very hard for me to find a pizza place which has a gluten free alternative. They have it, and it's really yummy. The standard dough is also very good, and the topping is soo damn delicious. We love this place and can recommend it. We were lucky to get a table as normally you have to book in advance. So please book in advance not to get disappointed. The cocktails are also delicious. The ambiente is cool and everything comes together. Make a stop here when travelling the Great Ocean Road.

Husband and I have been coming here every weekend for almost 12 months now!
Definitely our permanent date night spot 👌
Week after week these guys consistently put out the best quality pizzas (and I mean BEST). We've been to Melbourne and Sydney to search for what we consider the "best pizza we've ever had" and nothing has been able to top this! Such a good vibe, super friendly staff, top quality ingredients, large variety of drinks, I mean what more could you want?
Huge love to the Coffin fam ❤✌

If you’ve got a hankering for a fantastic pizza made, and served, by people who have a great life attitude then head to Coffin Sally. Takeaway is via the front door during covid times. get yourself a Margherita, thin crust, perfectly cooked with a crisp base but with that cheesy chewiness full of tomato flavour, fantastic value for $14 washed down with a wicked selection of canned cocktails and beers. You won’t be disappointed. A must try in Port Fairy

A real gem. Wonderful pizzas and a great selection of great beers. Staff were great. Highly recommended.

Cosy and laid back dining area.
Good pizza. Great margs. Good vibes.
Kid friendly. What more could you want.
Thanks guys ✌🏼

Pro tip: ask for the secret menu item 😉

Wow! This place is fabulous. Pizza was beautiful, crust, fresh and light. Great beer and wine list and funky decor! Highly recommended!

Fantastic service, food and drinks ! I had a leg injury and they delivered an ice pack without me even asking ! So kind and considerate.

Impressive pizzas with an atmosphere to match. Cosy setting, fireplace, friendly and welcoming. Great for a relaxing night out.

Always a treat to visit Coffin Sally. Plenty of staff to help. Ample seating and tables available for big groups. Also drink specials are unique and unusual, always something new to try. Lastly the pizza menu... Just go try yourself.

Pizza is fantastic, rocket salad was also amazing. Freindly service. If you planning on going during busy periods, make sure you book. They also do takeaway.