Craftsman Table & Tap

Tried this place on a whim today. So happy we did. Our server Stephanie was great. She definitely went out of her way to make our visit top notch. The food was really good but the topper was the horseradish sauce. I've never had a better sauce. Check this place out. You'll be glad you did.

Beautiful little restaurant with a nice atmosphere and delicious food. My boyfriend got their fried Walleye and I got the butternut squash ravioli and both dishes were cooked to perfection and packed full of flavor!

We stopped in for restaurant week and were impressed with the food here. We tried the Deviled Eggs, brussel sprout toast, aloha burger, chocolate mousse and roasted walnut torte. Wow, what a great lunch. Great, friendly service to top it off. The brussel sprout toast and walnut torte were especially delicious.

Delicious cheese curds, sandwiches were good, dessert was a tad rich but good! Only suggestion would be a better vessel for the au jus! Nice waiter too!

Nice place for a good brunch - and the food is fresh and on the healthier side which is always nice after a few drinks the night before. Sierra was fantastic even after we ordered about a dozen drinks to start. Wings and pretzel were fantastic! Definitely recommend if in the area!

Amazing brunch, delicious cocktails. I can't wait to go back.

Stopped in for brunch. Several items on the menu sounded scrumptious so it was hard to choose, but landed on the Bourbon apple French toast which was absolutely delicious! The toast itself was perfectly done. The apples were nicely cooked, retaining a little bit of crunch which was marvelous. The syrup was delightfully bourbon-y. Overall a delightful meal and I'm looking forward to going back to try other items.

Valentines update… love their tiramisu.
My daughter and I visited again. It was a good day for burgers. Was told about their tiramisu, and we were not disappointed. So rich and delectable. Not too sweet, just the right amount of richness… mouth watering.
Each time I come here I have enjoyed absolutely devine food, their comfortable atmosphere and have loved the wonderful, friendly and accommodating staff.
Couldn’t ask for more!

Fantastic all around. In town on business and just tried something. This place has prompt, friendly, and helpful staff, a really classy atmosphere, and great food. Their bar has a great selection as well as friendly bartenders. This place would be the perfect location for your next date or business meeting

Came here on a Sunday for lunch. Had the burger and it was so good and unique. I wished I lived closer. Probably in my top 5 best burgers I ever had and I have had more than my share. The homemade chips were tasty as well and hit the spot. Great atmosphere and service. Would recommend to anyone in a heartbeat.

This place is great. I've never had a bad meal and I've come 4 times. They have an interesting twist on many classics, some great stuff I've never seen anywhere else, and the only brunch menu I've had to struggle to decide on. (Breakfast. All day. Life rule.)

Last time I went I got an order of their cheese curds, because I live in Wisconsin. ... 🤷🏻‍♀. They were the best curds I've ever had hands down. I get cheese curds from every restaurant I go to that had them at least once. Hands down best. And the breakfast burger. I asked for my egg runny, so I did tweak to my own preferences, but it was amazing. Would definitely eat again. But next time I have to try the breakfast BLT, so.. I have to go back twice now. Darn.

I will say while the food and atmosphere are stellar, they can have some slow and imagine service. Not every time, but I've definitely had good service and not so good. However, this is a small thing, because most of the time things get taken care of, and the food never takes very long to be made, so you don't end up drinkless for too long.

All in all, I'm definitely going back and while there's a tiny bit of room for improvement, I'll definitely say it's a 5-star place.

We ate at Craftsman Table & Tap on New Year's Eve and enjoyed a delicious dinner. Our main entrees consisted of the potato -crusted walleye and prime rib. The walleye knocked my socks off and I would highly recommend giving it a go. For an appetizer we had the French onion spring roll which presented a savory flavor with the brandied onions and gruyere. And to top it off we had the chocolate mousse that was perfectly rich and creamy!

Came with a party of 6, food was excellent, service was great. Menu has some good choices and the bar had lots of choices. Great place to come and enjoy a meal, I had the BBQ burger which was great, the nachos were great, as well as the cheese curds. I will be back!!

A group of 3 of us went to dinner on a busy weekend and didn't have to wait long. They didn't take reservations by phone. We ordered some drinks and cheese curds to start. The moscow mule was really good!
We ordered the smash burger with fresh greens and it was a really great burger! Our cheese curds got lost in the ether but they were very generous and removed it from the bill.
Very nice staff and atmosphere. Will be returning again and again!

Great service! Great food! Hats off to the Chef!

Interesting menu with fan favorites and items you can't find elsewhere. This is an awesome location and a great atmosphere. Staff here is always helpful and friendly, and oh man...the curds! They are great. Also a great spot for brunch! This is a nice staple for Middleton, Food Fight Restaurants are always amazing! Try it, enjoy it, love it. (Don't forget about the amazing beer selection on tap)

We visited here on a Friday night and we're really impressed with the food and the service. The cheese curds were awesome! I had the fish and chips and the cod was also very good. The restaurant is very warm and inviting and feels cozy like a neighborhood pub. Everything we had there was delicious and the service was excellent.

The cheese curds were amazing. I had the shaved sirloin sandwich and it was delicious. I tried my wife's Italian sandwich and it was even better than the shaved sirloin. The criss cross cut fries are perfect. The Wisconsin Old Fashioned was also very good. The kids also ate their entire meals. 100% will go back.

Outstanding food, great space for lunch with a friend. Easy to hear/converse, comfortable seating. Steak sandwich, Brussel sprout salad with salmon, sweet potato fries, chocolate mousse were all exceptional! Can't wait to visit for brunch. 😋

Really great mixed drinks and food! Came for lunch one day and just had to return for dinner later that week. Think high-end restaurant quality food versus typical bar & grill food. Love, love love the Osi 2.0 wheat draft. Tasted like Blue Moon only lighter. You gotta visit this place!