Red's Falbo Brothers

Bravo , the Calzone should be award winning ! The thin crust pizza wasn't sensational but good for the price , it was that Calzone ( sausage & peperoni) that was and would bet is the Hook ! 👏 🇮🇹🇮🇹

I LOVE THIS PLACE! Best in Madison Area in my honest opinion.

They were even an hour and a half behind tonight and I was still wowed by the flavor and quality. The employees here really care about their reputation and customers and that means a lot to me.

I give a high rating for their customer service AND timeliness also their communication and judgement. If you’re in the Middleton area and haven’t tried Red’s pizza PLEASE do. Their quality and standards are impeccable and they pride themselves on doing the right thing. That is so important and appreciated by this —-> pizza fan aka ME! :)

Thank you for the excellent customer service and an always awesome calzone, Red’s! Keep up the great work all of you behind the phone and counter and deserve a big congratulations!

I pride myself I'm giving the best experience possible! You serve pizza with fresh ingredients and try to provide an amazing customer service experience.

Just had Red's last night! The Supreme was excellent! Also did a "Build your own" with Banana Peppers, Sausage, and Onion. Both were very good! Hand Tossed is a little thicker than most places, but the seasoning on the pizza and crust were amazing!

As a first time customer I called in my order for a 14" Supreme Pizza last.night.
Just for me
Figuring on left overs for today.
The menu has a large selection of choices of all kinds. I was loving the variety of salads, including vegetarian pizza and MUCH more.
I chose to call in instead of doing an online order. I was treated pleasantly. Told my order would be delivered in about an hour. It came much faster then expected. When I opened the good and hot pizza my mouth fell open. Each slice was LOADED with ingredients. And tasted as good as it looked. The price was only $17.00 plus $2.00 for the hand tossed crust. Plus tip.
I was in pizza heaven.
RED PIZZA will have all my business from now on. I'm so glad I decided to try somewhere else as my disappointment with Pizza Hut had been increasing.
Last time from.Pizza Pit pit was dry, tasted old, was cold and I discovered a couple pieces of Canadian bacon were actually raw on the piece I was brave enough to try. I called for a full refund and received it. In cash. At my door.
That was an unusual action on my part. To bad they are slipping so badly.

After trying Red's pizza, I know that this will be my go to pizza place. The crust is perfect and they do not skimp on the toppings, including the cheese. I love the variety of pizzas they have and I'm excited to have a good mac and cheese pizza on the west side. The prices are so reasonable and no one can compete with a fantastic locally owned pizza place.

Red's Pizza always hits the spot when I've got the carb cravings. They also have great grinders along with the pizza. The staff is always super friendly and you really can't beat their slice lunch special.

I was just pretty much on the verge of a Mom-meltdown, the house is filled with smoke from burning dinner, the house is destroyed, my kids are hungry and grumpy, my night was not going well lol. After just giving up and ordering pizza, I literally feel like a weight was lifted off of my shoulders! Not only can I trust that my family will be THRILLED that I ordered Reds and not some crappy fastfood pizza but I was treated like a friend on the phone. You don't find customer service like that any more! I'm proud to be a neighbor of this establishment and highly recommend it. Oh and for the food, pizza is the bomb and please for the love of pete, try the sandwiches!! So SO good.

When thinking about a good pie, its crucial to have a good crust and a good sauce. Red's has both! Pair that with always fresh ingredients, I think this place sets the bar in Middleton and the rest of the surrounding area. I wish they were in my delivery zone which would save me the weekly drive to them for a pick up! Service always welcoming so going in is not so bad either :) .

Order took a little over an hour, but it was worth the wait. The roads were bad and pizza isn't worth someone's safety. Delicious stuffed pie, really good crust. Will absolutely be ordering again!

If you eat pizza, you eat Reds. Big Red and the crew make some creative kick ass pies. Not only is it the best in town, its a local business run by a local guy. I highly recommend a lunch slice and an ice cold sprite. 5+ stars

Awesome experience with their delivery. Even brought our dog a treat! Much appreciated!! Will definitely keep ordering from them, since nobody else wants to deliver out by us and the food is always fantastic!! :-)

I believe this was the original spin off from the college staple Falbos pizza. I think the original owners sold and other the other Falbos in the area are franchisees. This owner was smart enough to not go down that path. The food is largely the same, great as always, so you might miss the new sign if you're not paying attention. Slices for lunch are a staple, just ask the Middleton high schoolers, and the calzones are great too. I'd stick with there deep dish as I don't find the thin nearly as satisfying. Eat local, eat good pizza, eat Reds.

The thin crust pizza is delicious! Don't hesitate to try Red's Pizza, always made to perfection. I highly recommend the thin crust pizza with pepperoni and jalapeños.

Their Pizza is so damn good,. I can't wait to order another one. I love the supreme pizza.. the owner really takes pride in his staff that makes the staff great

One of the single worst days of my adult life and it was made better by you. Thank you so much, I was at the Hampton Inn my feet throbbing cause I couldn't walk another step and you brought me the most delicious food. Honestly the side salad and wigns did us in and then we got to our Sammy. Fabulous! Thank you so much. I will sleep well, with my stomach full.

The stuffed pizza is incredible. Put giardiniera on everything -. It's worth it

Really delicious pizza and friendly staff, didn't catch his name but dude with curly long hair was super helpful and friendly. We'll be back specifically for his awesome service.

Reds is amazing pizza and has a great team behind them. New name and even better place. You'll be a happy person after you have some Red's!

We ordered 2 large pizzas for the Weed Man Lawn Care operations department, you guys have amazing pizza, and we will definitely be coming back. Thank you.