Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

Cute and delicious! Definitely worth the stop. We tried the Brownie Bay Volcano and Nutella Sundae. Great serving size, priced well. The Nutella sundae was very rich and the Brownie Bay Volcano was a balance of yumminess.

They have Wheel chair accessibility with the ramp and convenient parking in the back. Plenty of shaded tables on the patio to enjoy your treat. Service was pleasant and quick - we’ll definitely be back!🍨

Had soft serve ice cream.... they only had vanilla n chocolate (or a mix) but it was delish. Very good prices. I got my granddaughter a small cone. It was a very nice size (larger than I expected) for only $3.75. Also ordered a kids cone and it came w a cup so they don't drip all over AND there was almost the same amount of ice cream as a small cone. They had a nice selection of hard ice cream for .25 more. They had sundaes available as well as milkshakes, banana splits, etc...see photo...

5 stars because it’s looked so inviting and clean. Support local business! Prices look good too. Good flavour ice cream and water ice. Plenty of parking and nice sitting area.

I OFTEN FREQUENT Barnegat Bay Ice Cream! In my opinion they have the best ice cream & so many options to choose from! There a small FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS & are some of the KINDEST PEOPLE YOU WILL EVER MEET! Their ice cream is not only DELICIOUS BUT RIDICULOUSLY FAIRLY PRICED❤‍🔥 I ALWAYS GET the banana split🥰 They also do door dash! If your a local or even just visiting our beautiful ocean side town you have to stop by their shop! Way better then Mrs Walkers 😬 Barnegat Bay Ice Cream Is the best best place to go from Eagleswood to Toms River!

Love this place!! They have a ton of options, and will let you design your own Sundae! Family business that cares, right down to the pup cups for your furry baby. Sitting in front and back. Favorites are the cheesecake ice cream and the brownie Sundae. Fall definitely pumpkin pie Sundae

Delicious soft icecream served by a friendly server. There are clean tables and chairs to accommodate customers and plenty of parking in the rear. A local gem in the neighborhood. We will return with our grandchildren when they visit, and most certainly when we desire an icecream treat.

Awesome ice cream, soft serve, water ice, etc. Good prices. Huge portions. Ample parking and really nice people working there. Nice tables outside. Definitely going back!

Always enjoy the icecream here. Great prices and very friendly staff.

Best ice-cream. So much variety and great toppings. Also impressed that they had lactose free ice cream and ices. Great staff and very clean establishment.

Good ice cream and excellent service the staff waa friendly. Will probably visit again.

Excellent ice cream with an unbelievable value. We will be back. The portions are particularly large. The parking lot entrance is tricky if you're coming southbound RT. 9

The best ice cream around. And we have gone everywhere in the area. Including LBI. The soft serve is very fresh. Reminds me of the creamy freshness of Carvel's soft serve.

Love love love this place,so nice.Very reasonable price,great ice cream,shakes.We go almost every day.I highly recommend the shop along with my friends and family....😊😊😊

Just enjoyed delicious ice cream outside on pristine clean and comfortable tables and comfortable. seating area. Great menu of choices. Will be the place to bring grandkids and will be back for sure!

Loved this place! Even have pup cups for your 4 legged friends. 😊 Staff was great and the ice cream was delicious.

This is just what we need in barnegat! The service and staff were delightful! The ice cream was delicious with reasonable prices! My family really enjoyed it we will be returning!

Very nice first experience. Good icecream, not cheap with toppings.
Waited for the new to wear off first. Parking is a little weird. I will go back.

Very nice place for ice cream. Quick service, nice people.

New to the area and found this gem! Great ice cream and even had lemon ice for my picky eater! Staff was very friendly. Will definitely be back soon!

Great ice cream place. Big cones and good prices. Don't mind paying a little more if you get what you pay for and you get more than you pay for here