Andy’s Restaurant Greenport New York

The food was delicious. The staff was very attentive and friendly. I had the Ruben, and there was so much corned beef it was crazy. But so good! My friends had the tomato soup (she loved it!) And the gyro (and he love that also). Fries were perfectly crispy. There were kids around, so it was a very family friendly place (at lunchtime at least).

Quant bar and restaurant. Lots to look at and do. Games, TV’s, etc. Had the fish tacos which were perfect. The hamburger with fired was great too. Andy is very friendly and responsive.

A diverse American cuisine reimagined! Local-ingredient-inspired dishes plated beautifully, with a hometown, no-frills feel and plenty of tvs at the bar to watch the game(s). Wish we could come here more often! Decor (5/5) Food (5/5) Service (4.5/5)

Visited on consecutive nights and the bartender, Chris, is fantastic. He offered up (and swore by) a recommendation to a local restaurant. My wife and I obliged and we weren't disappointed. We showed up after dinner to show him our appreciation for the recommendation. We had great convo, and he surprised us with some treats for our anniversary.

Typical bar food, burger, fish, salad. All good. Fair prices, clean bathrooms . The nice thing is they give you FREE popcorn while waiting for your food 😜

Yummy food and good service, fun relaxed atmosphere. Also, really appreciate their solid kids menu. If you want take out, call them rather than ordering online. ChowNow's Uber delivery not so reliable out east on the north fork in general.

First time here and it was great! Andy was a gracious host. The drinks were cold and the food was delicious. Highly recommend and we will be back!

Came to watch a game, drink a beer and eat some food. ✔+✔+✔+. They put my game on and even though my team lost the atmosphere was nice, the beer was cold, and my food was good. Service was outstanding. Our server may have been the owner who was super attentive and accommodating and if he wasn’t the owner, then I’d want to hire that guy!

Great local pub with delicious pub foods. Especially the potato skin shooters! Fresh fish tacos, boom! Great lunch once again!

This place checks all my boxes. Great service, outstanding wings, juicy burgers properly cooked to temperature, cold beer, and an awesome location. Come in and check it out!

Hidden gem!!! We started our night out at an overpriced local restaurant and ended at Andy’s. The bartender was attentive and the food was outstanding! Turns out our bartender was Andy himself! Great guy and so humble! We’ll be back again!!

Very nice and clean place. Owner made his way to our table to chat for a few minutes and make sure everything was good.

Stopped into Andy's for a bite to eat on our first night in town. We were welcomed with popcorn and an extensive drink selection. Both the food and local beer were great. Props to Andy's for being an Untappd Verified Venue. This allowed me to look up what beers were on tap before/during our visit.

Best hometown feel from extraordinary people. Good eats and drink! Don’t miss this gem!

Tomato soup without equal. Delightful live music

We had the pleasure of having our son's wedding welcome party at Andy's. Everything was fantastic! Andy is wonderful to work with and is very accommodating to your needs. Both the food and atmosphere were perfect for a large gathering. All the guests enjoyed themselves and it was a perfect way to kickoff a weekend for a wedding celebration.

Love this place. The owner is really nice and the staff is great. Love the food. the Chimichangas are great and my absolute favorite: sweet potato fried with a side of maple mayo crack! yes! its so good its like crack for your soul! I always get more sweet potato dip!! I think I could have a meal of just sweet potato fries and that crack dip!!!

Excellent atmosphere with plenty of outside and inside dining. Casual dining at a very reasonable price. Their potato skin shooters and fried chicken sandwich are fantastic. Large bar area and great music (not live) I highly recommend this place if you are looking for delicious, casual, American food.

Came over via shelter Island ferries, I am a South fork farmer. Of course with a toddler in toe we are running later than expected, and Tuesdays apparently most pizza places are closed, desperate for dinner I googled chicken tenders in greenport... I am sitting on the ferry headed back home with all my plants for my farm in tow. Snacking on this absolutely amazing pretzel. I've already nibbled on a pickle, and of course had to check the chicken tenders to make sure they weren't too hot, and everything is absolutely amazing. The best food I've had in a very long time. Nothing dumped from a bag into the deep fryer, all delicious and homemade made with the heart. The bartender who took my order on the phone was super helpful with parking, being an out of Towner this was key. And the waitress was super sweet and let me stand out the back door so I could keep an eye on my daughter in the truck. Hands down the best fried pickles and pretzel I've had in all my life.
Thank you so much for making dinner easy AND delicious, it doesn't often happen this time of year!
We cannot wait to go back!

. My wife and I chose Andy’s due to outdoor seating options but honestly chose inside instead due to the weather. I will say I was blown away by the service we received by our. Waitress Gabby. She was extremely attentive to our 11 month old and interacted with her on a level I didn’t expect. It was honestly my first time going to a restaurant with my daughter due to Covid and I was a bit nervous on how she would act- Gabby really made those feelings dissipate quickly and allowed me to enjoy my time out. We only visit Greenport 2-3 times a year, but Andy’s will be my go to every time now!