Buffalo Jump Steakhouse

Omg. The food was so good. We sat at the bar and the bartender was really nice and chatted with us the whole time and even put up with my drunk shenanigans(i was excited I thought my burger came with a dinner roll but it was actually just the top bun) we ordered the BBQ potatoes with brisket and it was phenomenal. My husband got the Buffalo steak and I got the jump burger and we shared and omg everything was so good. Then we got dessert and you can definitely tell they don't get the desserts out of a pre-made freezer box. If we ever make it this far again we will definitely stop in again. So good.

Our waiter, Austin was great! The food was delicious. We arrived at 4:00 when they opened, no wait to be seated. Prior to leaving business was picking up and it started to get busy.

On recommendation, we popped in on our way to Devils Tower for an early dinner. Jen’s birthday dinner! I had the bison ribeye, which was done medium rare just rightJen had the dry aged ribeye med rare. We both had the garlic mashed potatoes served loaded. Oh yes.
The salad was super and well dressed.
Everything was delicious. Service was great.
Bison was leaner and more complex than the dry aged ribeye, which was one of the best steaks I’ve ever tasted.

Amazing experience! We ordered the BBQ potato’s to start and the flavor was amazing with the brisket and cheese sauce! The wife ordered the peppercorn sirloin which was delicious! I ordered the Ruby steak and the brown sugar glaze was a unique flavor I have never experienced in a steak before! Perfect side to go with was the garlic mashed potatoes. Best steakhouse I’ve ever been to!

Small town steakhouse makes some great steak. Had the prime rib with New England clam chowder and a loaded baked potato. Good food

This place never disappoints us! The service is the best around (Whitney was our AMAZING waitress tonight) and the food is top shelf. Their steak tips are the best I've ever had and my husband loves their fillet with shrimp. The lemon drop martini is SO good!

This place is Wyoming. From the people to the vibe this place is a must go. Of course the food is great. The atmosphere, decor, even the smells....makes it a great Wyoming experience. There is a bar in the restaurant but there is also a great bar at the other end of the building where you can drink with the locals. Service is over the top and ultra clean.

McKenzie took great care of me at the bar. Awesome - Owner - staff - food - wine
So worth the drive from Spearfish
I will be back next time I’m in town

If you want an amazing meal that will not disappoint this is the place to be at! Wow I am literally blown away by how every single thing I had was perfect! We had the Buffalo smoked chicken Bleu cheese dip with chips and toasted bread. Holy cow or should I say holy chicken lol , best dip I have ever had in my life! Then we had ordered clam chowder soup with one of the meal it came out early. Best clam chowder soup I have ever had, seriously the amount of clams it in omg... then it was so creamy the potatoes and bacon in the soup on point! We ordered the NY strip with the pepper jack Mac and cheese. Omg yet again did not disappoint at all , bursting with flavor! I had the jump burger, the whole thing was just flavor full I really like the hamburger patties they use. I also had the steak fries with my meal , legit home made steak fries so so so good. Our server which i now know is the owner lol was so amazing and did such a great job! She also offered us dessert which I chose the turtle cheesecake and soooooooo good. Everything came out with great presentation, so flavorful , the atmosphere was so good , had a thirty minute wait to be seated but I would of waited 2 hours just to eat there. I've eaten alot of places and this was the best restaurant hands down! This place is a hidden gem on the edge of Wyoming. I would recommend every one to go. Thank you for the amazing experience! Also the prices are actually amazing for the food quality!

Didn’t have reservations but did not have to wait long at all. Food was great from appetizers to main course. Service was great also. Will definitely be going back!

If you are visiting anywhere near Deadwood, Sturgis, Lead, or Spearfish, South Dakota and don’t make the very short trip over to Beulah, Wyoming your entire trip was wasted.
The food was outstanding and the owner was so welcoming and kind. The Aged Ribeye was worth the $ and so we’re the tips. Don’t miss this place!

Absolutely FANTASTIC! The atmosphere is spot on for a steakhouse and the service is definitely top notch. The food... as a self proclaimed foodie, I have to say the food at the Buffalo Jump is nothing short of 5 star. World class dining right in Beulah, Wyoming.

Holy cow! Best steak I have ever had. $34 for the Ruby Ribeye steak and potato was well worth it. Tons of people always eating here at night!
Chicken Picatta was very good too.

Food was top notch, the inside was nice and the servers were very friendly despite the fact the place was packed mainly because of the Sturgis motorcycle festival. Would love to come back here.

Amazing food, and a great atmosphere. Best steakhouse I’ve ever been to

Buffalo Jump is a small town gem. The food and service is always good. They seem to always have a good crowd, so reservations are probably a good idea.. just in case.
Great steaks and surprisingly excellent Ahi tuna, salmon and walleye.

Food was great. Prime rib and ribeyes.
Outstanding service great waitress.

Absolutely amazing food and our server was so nice and attentive! For a town with 33 people what an awesome steak house!!

A fantastic find in a town of 33 people. The food was tasty and well prepared, the prices were decent ($23 for a 10 0z sirloin) and the service was great. I appreciate how attentive MacKenzie was to our needs and how friendly she was throughout our meal. If you are travelling on I-90, the Buffalo Jump is worth stopping for!

We stumbled upon this restaurant and were simply blown away! The service was top-notch and the food exquisite.