Indianhead Supper Club

The staff was exceptional. Great food (warm Brie, prime rib, sirlion, crème brûlée and lava cake)! Very accommodating when we called last minute and they were full but squeezed us in! Heather was a great server and the staff was all so friendly! Sorry no more food photos as we ate everything too quick!

Indianhead never disappoints! I had the most delicious steak dinner over the weekend and the drinks were fabulous. I can't wait to be back!

We were a party of four. The waitress Jenna was outstanding, prompt and very friendly. The drinks were well balanced and very good, the citrus martini was absolutely delicious. We ordered fillet with mushroom sauce, so tender and cooked to perfection. The walleye and Salmon entres were fabulous and the chicken Marsala was so tasty. Highly recommend this for any occasion!

This place embodies everything a supper club should be. From the gracious and wonderful hostess, Jan, to our friendly and efficient waitress, Jenna, and the most succulent and tender prime rib I've ever tasted, you can't get any better than this place. I hope to be back many times.

Great old fashioned super club.
The food and the service here is excellent. Started with an old fashioned cocktail than a dinner salad and roll.
The main course was delicious. There are many choices. I had the fillet with Cheesy potatos and
Creme brulee for dessert.
You will not be disappointed.

Wonderful place, a step back in time to the old time supper clubs. We went to the supper club because of "Old Fashioned" the supper club book.
Our meals were great and we will be back a again. You will not be disappointed. Thanks for everything

We didn't have a reservation, but the hostess seated us at a high table near the bar and close to the piano player. The atmosphere was great. People were out and having fun. Our waitress was over booked, but did a fantastic job of making sure we were taken care of. The food was really good, didn't take to long inspite of a full house. We have been avoiding going to restaurants as of late, bit we will be going back to Indian Head Supper Club.

Pan fried walleye is the best menu option. Delicious garlic mashed potatoes. Wings were good. Both Heather's are fantastic waitresses!! The porch is great for a private party up to 12 people. A great place to celebrate a birthday, anniversary or retirement.

Great place! Go. Eat. Enjoy. Be Happy Happy Happy that you listened to me!

A real supper club!! This is not a new restaurant made to look older, it’s the real deal. Food and cocktails are always excellent!! Please remember this is a true supper club so service is not high speed. This is intentional and true to the supper club experience as it gives patrons more time to engage in conversation. Highly recommend!

A classic supper club, fantastic food and cocktails. A must see and enjoy.

The service from the bartender to the waitress was outstanding. Then from the appetizer to the meal to the desert was unbelievable it made your taste buds dance.
If you're asking will I go back there again yes most definitely.

An exceptional dinner was had, we were very lucky to get the last table available at 5pm, will make reservations in the future, but very gracious hostess and no table is in a poor spot! Our Old Fashions started the meal off to a great start. Jana was a very attentive server and dishes were described on point. Chef Roark's Pork Shank Special was fantastic and the broiled Jumbo Shrimp scrumptious! Regrettably didn't have our phones for pics, but take our word, all was wonderful from start to finish. The relaxing atmosphere was so enjoyable and can't wait to return! This Gem was so worth the drive 👍🤩👍

It was fun. We sat in the screened porch and it was delightful. The service was really good and the food was delicious. Fun atmosphere.

Lovely supper club atmosphere. Very good service and food.

I've been coming here for decades. My grandparents had their honeymoon dinner here. We have a family lake home nearby. Indianhead is the best! 5 stars all the way.

First recommendation is that you need to call in for reservations they could squeeze you in if someone cancels but it is mainly a place where you need to make reservations it's very busy.

Also like to say that it's loud inside. Ppl like to talk with their mouthful evidently and loudly unfortunately. the restaurant can't control that and at least they don't have loud music to cover it up like others do like a bar.

I ordered onion rings as appetizer which were lightly breaded and lightly fried but still oily / greasy. At the start of your meal you also get plain water which is not tap and very refreshing must be filtered. I ordered the lemonade which was I believe to be real lemons squeezed.

Like all fine classy restaurants you get bread except the bread where simple rolls one per person which were a bit hard and butter was from a fridge meaning hard they should let it sit out. The bread should also be Unlimited.

Also ordered the soup of the day which was cheesy potato- very delicious and very hot.

The online menu does not mention that they serve prime rib so you need to get that which I did their king size and that was very tender the knife sliced easily right through it with little fat. The meat was made to order. Also ordered the smashed potatoes which does not come with extra toppings which is great.

The meal was rounded out with lava cake with ice cream also very hot and very delicious not overcooked and the ice cream was delicious.

The whole meal lasted about 90 minutes. The waitress did not push us but she did come by every once in awhile to check on us which is great. We were able to place your order within 20 minutes and the meal came within 20 minutes after ordering.

As mentioned it was loud but they do have an outside patio so be sure to reserve that if you know the weather will be pleasant.

One thing I did not like was the paper tablecloth which is like for kids the cloth should be cloth.

Classic Wisconsin Supper Club serving all the classics in a beautiful north woods setting.

On a random whim, I did not order one of my traditional favorites- salmon, shrimp or walleye. I ordered the fillet with the crab topping. With the rice and the brown mushroom sauce, it was beyond amazing! The salmon is always amazing !

I did not catch the server’s name, but she was very nice! She made the evening fun for us!

We are so glad we have a gem here !

Plan to relax and enjoy the atmosphere of the evening.

This was a unforgettable evening. Well exceeded our expectations with a 65 minute drive from the cities. It's a must! Nothing less then perfect!
Thank you!