Cottage Inn Pizza Pigeon

The pizza is delicious every time! And they make a great gluten-free BLT pizza!

Great food! Absolutely the best salads!

Pretty good pizza. Got the chicken bacon ranch. For me it was to much ranch.

Good food. For sandwiches pretty good portion size

Great place in town to get some good comfort food!! Service is great and quick. The staff are really friendly! Shout out to Matilda being one of the best who treats customers with value. Great job to management for having her on board with her positive attitude and care for people!

Went here last week and it was wonderful. The food was delicious, the staff was super nice, and the sitting area was quite peaceful. I would recommend finding some coupons though, It was a little on the expensive… but worth it.

I give them a high rating because the food is excellent especially the lasagna and they're in sticks.
I stopped in last Saturday to order in sticks and their homemade garlic cheese like I do two or three times a week. The two ladies working there firmly let me know I was 4 minutes early. So I walked to the gas station part and got some ice cream, I told the gas lady attendant I didn't think the two women like working today because I got reprimanded for being a couple minutes early. She just kind of looked at me funny so I went out in my car and waited 10 minutes, when I walked back in I noticed the pizza lady and the gas attendant was talking and immediately quit when I walked in. Yeah I learned a lesson that day. I picked up my Instax and the garlic cheese was on top of the box jumped in my car and went home. All my years getting in sticks I've never once seen the garlic cheese other than inside the box. Later that day I opened the box and to my surprise the breadsticks were Brown and burnt, all my years getting breadsticks they've been nothing but perfect. I opened the garlic cheese and it seemed crusty around the sides and pasty with a yellow tint. again I've never one time seen that it's always creamy and delicious. I've wanted to get bread sticks and garlic cheese all week but just can't seem to go over there. I guess I'm embarrassed. All the mail workers are excellent polite and very kind and considerate. Jessica is awesome always a big smile and a kind word. I really miss my Instax I wish that didn't happen,.

We had a delicious meal on a night with no time to cook dinner. The online ordering system was easy to navigate and the delivery was 10 minutes ahead of the listed time. Dana, our delivery driver, was excellent. She hustled from her vehicle to our front door. As usual, she shared her great personality and thanked us for our order and was quickly on her way. The varied menu options keep the entire family happy. Our nine year old daughter loves the boneless chicken wings while the two year old devours the bread sticks. My wife and I both enjoy several of the gourmet pizza selections, the oven toasted subs, and the calzones. Occasionally we enjoy the dessert options.

the few times last year pizza's were great! this year after my 1st visit ordered 2 large two toppings and was greatly disappointed both pizza's were not properly cut not one piece pulled out of two pies came out of the pie right toppings were scarce one slice not even having both toppings on it. everything else about this visit was fine the place is clean very nice friendly staff

We drive by other pizza places to get here. Much better than some of the competitors. We'll be back!

This was the first time ordering from CI, we had it delivered to Caseville Marina.
They arrived in half the time they estimated.
The food was Hot fresh and delicious.
From the person that answered the phone to the delivery person, extremely friendly.
I would definitely recommend Cottage Inn Pizza in Pigeon Michigan.

Service: 5/5, Quality: 5/5, Value: 5/5
Vegetarian/Vegan Options: 4/5

In short - This place provided some exceptional customer service and delicious pizza that saved us from a reception where we had no food options that met our diet!

Further:
Service was exceptional. We attended a reception that had zero vegetarian options available. We planned ahead and brought some food because we know better (and sure enough, there was meat and bacon in the vege's!). Well, we still ended up being hungry so we searched for local restaurants and tried the pizza. We were greeted by Darrion L at the counter and asked if the crust and sauce were vegan. He was very friendly and willing to help us and was able to confirm that both the crust and the sauce are vegan. Pizza was ordered and came out in around 10-15 minutes, about what you'd expect.

Quality was great! We ordered a the flavorful vegetarian pizza with broccoli, pineapple, green pepper, banana pepper, mushroom, and NO cheese. The crust, sauce, and toppings were all very flavorful.

Value was on point too. For 5 toppings on the pizza we were really pleased with the price and flavor of the pizza.

Vegetarian/Vegan options. The place seems to offer quite a bit of vegetarian options. The crust and sauce being vegan is Great! I marked down a point in this category because there was no vegan cheese substitute or no protein alternative. From what I've read online it does sound like the franchise is starting to experiment with more vegan options in the Ann Arbor area. While I would've loved to have seen that at the Pigeon location, ultimately we were just happy to have something we could eat when we weren't sure we'd be able to find anything.

Major thanks to Darrion L for helping us out. In the unlikely event we're ever in the area again we definitely would be stopping by again.

So far so good. Haven't had anything that didn't taste delicious. The staff members are very polite and helpful, one employee even took my order out to the truck for me because I couldn't carry it all due to the fact I use a cane to get around town. Thanks again!!!

Finally got to try this place out. Was not disappointed! Delicious!

Very good food. Great new facility. Clean and new. Delicious menu.

Always a treat to have Cottage Inn when we’re in town! Really enjoy their specialties.

Double cheese really means it to them. The oven toasted subs are excellent. You should definitely call ahead. Totally worth the drive from Bad Axe.... just for this. Two thumbs up

Ordered the all meat pizza and literally the meat was falling off there was so much. Great place definitely going back

Good place to get delivery

My family just had this pizza for the first time and it is now the only place I will go for pizza. I think my tongue gave me a black eye trying to get to another bite. Lol