Mike & Cathy's Good Old Days

Have not ever been here, but based on the reviews, I will absolutely be checking it out when we go to Arrowhead next time. Had no idea that there was something so close. Arrowheads' food is awesome, but throwing in a good friday dinner with the family is always a good time. Look forward to camping season '24. We will see you then

Our family loves the fish and chicken on Fridays. You can also get baked cod if you are gluten free. Comes with baked beans, Cole slaw, German potato salad, and or broasted potatoes. Delish!

Nice people. Very good and reasonably priced food. Great view of Lake Puckaway especially from the dining room porch.

My steak was perfectly cooked.

Love the food and place never miss it when I go to Lake Puckaway..good service...great brunch on Sunday too...

We visited 2 weeks ago. Very busy, Sunday brunch. Good selection of breakfast/lunch entres. We enjoyed our visit and will return soon.

One of our go to spots when visiting the area! Good food, good drinks and great customer service!

The first time here, visiting from Waukesha and I loved the food. My friend had the Mushroom and Swiss burger. I had the Cheesesteak. Both are very good. Chips are excellent. Nice little place on the lake.

This place just flat out rocks. If you're in the neighborhood you have to stop!! Oh my goodness. Friday fish and chicken toooo die for. It is so good I would wait 2 hours to get a table. They are fast, food is hot, and did I mention the Friday fish and chicken wow!!!!!

The Friday night all you can eat Fish and Chicken is delicious! With rye bread, homemade German potato salad +/or boasted potatoes, fresh cole slaw, baked beans and even homemade tartar sauce! Excellent!!

Great Prime Rib, which they do not hold back on portion size or flavor. Beautiful view and our server Bobby Joe was excellent and made a great dining experience even better. Highly recommend..

This place is awesome. Roomy winter dinning, in the nice weather its very nice to enjoy a meal on the outdoors deck on the lake! Wednesdays all you can eat wings are a favorite, but all you can eat chicken and fish on Fridays is my all time favorite! Large Full bar to for before and after dinner drinks!

Stopped in last Friday on a whim and was out for a fish fry and it was a pleasant surprise to find that the place was beautifully remodeled but the service was great and the fish Fry and chicken was outstanding I was really impressed with the remodel. The food as well, Kathy was quite gracious.

I have been meaning to write a review for here! We absolutely LOVE this restaurant! Honestly it is the best in town! Your wings, your breakfast, prime rib, and ribs my gosh!!! Very Very good! Service is always great and more than fair pricing! We won’t go anywhere else. Beautiful scenery too on the lake! Couldn’t be better!

We ordered the fried chicken and fried fish and some chicken tender kids meals. All 3 dinners included a salad bar and soup! The food was delicious and there was so much food. Our waitress was so sweet and personable. If you are look for delicious food at a reasonable price with leftovers then this is the place for you! My husband visited 2 years ago and he's been talking about it ever since lol I enjoyed it just as much as he did.

I grew up in this area and it has been years since I've dined at Good Ole Days!! I just attended a luncheon for my Aunt's funeral here. I have to tell you....it was absolutely delicious just like I remember years ago. They were very courteous and accommodating. I highly recommend!!

Great food and fast service.

Nothing swanky, but great view of the lake, plenty of friendly locals and welcoming staff. Standard bar food lunch menu... but the burgers were way above standard.... hand formed juicy patties, pretzel bun, fresh lettuce leaf, juicy tomato and the crinkle cut fries were crispy on the outside, tender inside. We will make a return trip, for sure, to try the Friday and Saturday night specials.

Just stopped quickly to check it out. The old fashions were fantastic and the food looked great! We look forward to stopping again soon for a few meals! Hidden gem as far as we can tell!

The food was delicious and the drinks are good. Nice little place with great scenery.