Tybee Island Pizza

The service is quick, fresh and got plenty of flavor. Not just dough, sauce and meat. The staff were cool, quick and def good at what they do. I didn’t expect to like a small pizzeria on a island as much as like there’s. I’m so glad I tried them.

Nice outside eating area for you and your family especially if you have kids it’s for the most part not on the main road and blocked off so you can eat and enjoy your pizza why do kids run around highly recommend it

Really good pizza place on Tybee Island. You call them and make a to go order. They call you when it is about 5 minutes from being ready and you can come pick it up.

The buffalo chicken pizza was AMAZING! Staff was really nice too and the pizza only took about 20 minutes to be ready. Definitely recommend!

Best pizza I've had on Tybee so far. The pizza was quite juicy and the crust was crispy even on the bottom. You'll be needing a plate for these slices.

Awesome take away/eat outside pizza place. It’s a 4 minute walk from the Dunes hotel. We walked up placed our order went to the store next door and got a beer. Sat down on the picnic tables and by the time the beer was gone the pizza was ready. The Deluxe was delicious and my kids got a pineapple bacon that was excellent as well. Great crust on the pizza. Kinda like mellow mushroom but I think it was better. It was still streaming by the time we walked back to the hotel. Definitely order again.

We ordered 2 deluxe pizzas, and they were amazing, some of the best pizza I've had by far and my entire family agreed. The crust was handmade and perfect. Not to thin and not to thick. Vegetables were fresh and was amazing as well. If I could give 10 stars I would or if I lived here I would order everyday.

GREAT FLAVOR, AMAZING FRESHNESS WORTH THE WAIT!!! We took family down to Tybee for their first time, our third time and while the beach wasn't really crowded at all compared to what it usually is.... Finding a restaurant was so impossible. On a Monday, not a holiday weekend. After 7pm. Most places had either a 2 hr wait or was completely booked. We happened to Tybee Island Pizza and placed a rather big order.. We were told hour/hour and half wait... Exactly at an hour we got the call it was ready and WOW the wings are huge! With fantastic flavor! Pizza everyone was raving about! AND the stromboli! my husband said was incredible. And big! So glad we got to experience this place! Will definitely be back and encourage you to try it!

Best pizza on the island period. Fast, hot and the customer service is beyond excellent even in the midst of the pandemic and only having 1 cook and himself. The owner is a great guy. Extremely humble. I told him I'd leave an honest review. Here it is. Great job!!!!

We LOVE this place!! As locals, this is our Friday night go-to. We’d love the meatball/feta pizza and their teriyaki wings. But seriously, everything we’ve ever had is fabulous! Jeremy is very friendly & you can get it to go or eat outside. By far the best pizza on the south end!

Had both buffalo chicken, and a single pepperoni pizza. I have to admit the Buffalo chicken was the best I've had 10/10 would eat again. The pepperoni was satisfying as well, definitely safe pick for picky eaters.

This place is not just the best pizza joint on Tybee Island, they make one of the best pizzas I’ve ever eaten- and don’t get me started on the Stromboli and Calzones! They are absolutely delicious. We come to Tybee Island every winter for 6-9 weeks, and we order from Tybee Island Pizza at least once a week. It’s outstanding!

Ordered on a Saturday night and wait time was less than 15 minutes. Excellent pizza 5 stars. Hot, fresh & delish!!

This is the best pizza around. We had a 16" pepperoni that was delicious! Great easy-going atmosphere. The people were very nice and cool 🤓 Recommend for sure!

Had the meatball sandwich my wife got the white out pizza. Chicken, feta,spinach with white sauce. Owner was there very friendly and gave us other suggestions where to eat since it was our 1st time here. When we come back we will be back.

After walking around the beach, we needed a beer and pizza. Grabbed a beer from the convenience store (which they didn't have a problem with) and got 2 HUGE slices. Happy that lighthouse pizza was closed. Also, the staff are very friendly and fun to talk to.

Bring your appetite!!! We got a Stromboli, calzone and cheese sticks. Used to normal sizes from pizza places back home we could of been satisfied with just 1 of the items. Though we are happy we got all of it because it was all delicious!

First timer eating some italian pie at Tybee Island Pizza, it was Awesome.
Loved the sauce and crust - not something I can get in southwest Ohio. I would recommend to friends, family and anyone who loves pizza, try this place, you wont be disappointed.

Very tasty pizza, got my large order done really quick. They don’t have delivery, but the island is small so who cares! Will be back!

Trust me when I say, you will be glad you made this your pizza choice.. Came thru in a clutch at closing time.. they still made our pizza to perfection and let us explore other businesses and gave us a call when it was ready..You will be glad you stopped here!