Betsy's Consignments

After traveling 2 hours, I arrived at Holiday Valley for a wedding only to discover that I mistakenly brought a suit that fit me about 20 lbs ago. While the selection among men's clothes is spare, I was able to find two virtually new dress slacks that fit without alteration. The owner was helpful in determining which pair would go best with my jacket, shirt, and tie. She kindly steamed out the few wrinkles, and at a very reasonable price, I was soon on my way. In fact, I was ready before my wife and daughters. Many Thanks!

This is my favorite consignment shop! Betsy is discerning and tasteful in her merchandise. I always love visiting, both for shopping and consignment!

Betsy's is high class, top shelf. I wear designer clothes because Betsy has the discerning eye one expects an owner of a top notch trendy boutique resale shop to have. I often shop these tyoe of shops in Nashville and Betsy's quality can rival any of these shops visited by famous country stars. Parking right out front makes visiting this shop a cinch. Must go.

My favourite consignment store. Amazing merchandise and reasonable price. Very clean and organized. Found a wonderful authentic Chanel after 5pm bag for $200 which is AMAZING. Great place to stop as you never know what you will find. Thank you Betsy. FIVE stars all the way. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

Number one go to consignment shop in Ellicottville, you never know what you're going to find from Bits & Bobs to odds and sods and a vast collection of contemporary designer clothing. I also picked up a really sweet Burton Snowboard jacket there brand new with tags.

She was so nice and had really nice clothes and jewelry!! Great prices. She also told us where to go for lunch and shopping. Please visit. Very cute shop

Absolutely love this place! Very clean with adorable clothes at affordable prices. Highly recommend stopping in!

Nice clothes and fair prices. Betsy is very helpful

Wide variety of quality goods. Selection changes regularly.

Best stuff ever

Overly priced for used clothing! A bra was $20.00! The owner was rude. She said hi as I was walking in and so did I. She thought I didn’t say hi and she mumbled the entire time ‘ don’t say hi’! It was very uncomfortable & just simply weird and rude!

Not much just like a garage sale that is way over priced

Would have purchased a few things, had the clerk not been so rude and pushy. I was commenting on how cute this one light fixture was to the person I was shopping with...no intent of buying it, just said "oh hey, that's super cute!" The woman at the counter inserted herself into our conversation and commented about how she did a price check and on the original value and pointed out the great shape it was in. I really had no interest in buying it at a glance of the price (also the fact that I have no need for a light fixture)...but was planning on purchasing two sets of shoes I had already found and was still looking around. I politely said I just don't have that kind of money, but the lamp is very nice. The woman scoffed at me for saying that I didn't have the money for the light and it was out of my price range..and she would not stop going on and on about how I'd never be able to find one like it cheaper. I had already politely said that it was too much for me. She scoffed again and then mumbled under her breath swearing as well. I decided to just leave and did not support her business. It's a shame I could not even just say "hey that's cute" and just move on with my shopping...I had to be interrupted and belittled by this woman.

Like many others here, my encounter with the owner was NOT pleasant. Rude, arrogant, as soon as I stepped in I felt like she thought I wasn't worth her time. As I browsed, some regulars (Canadian) came in and she became a different person. Gregarious, smiling, animated, helpful...hmmm. When I had a question about a pair of shoes she was dismissive. Prices were very high for used clothing, and at the time I was there the merchandise all seemed dated, nothing in current fashion. Very disappointed.

Irresponsible and rude. I believe in doing business in the local area, so when I had a few items of a really nice quality, I decided to go to the local consignment shop. I had never been in the shop before and was met as I stepped through the door, by the owner. I immediately felt a slight flippant attitude, as I spoke to her about taking my items on consignment, but I shrugged it off. She gave me her consignment contract and I left a pair of $200 men’s shoes that had only been worn once. My son had decided they didn’t fit. The contract stated that I was to stop in to the shop by a certain date to either remove my items or collect the money. After that date, they would be donated. I stopped in one week before the date and they hadn’t sold, but the owner asked me to leave the pair of shoes with her until September, because she was certain she would sell them because of the quality. One week before the date in September, I stopped by the shop and she looked through her records and told me they hadn’t sold, so I went over to pick up the shoes and found that they were gone. When I asked the owner where the shoes were, she shrugged and said “we must’ve donated them”. I reminded her that we had had an agreement that I would pick up the shoes and they weren’t to be donated. She looked at me, shrugged and said “sorry, not my fault, the help must have done it” with that same flippant attitude. I own a business and I know that sometimes things happen that are out of your control. The money wasn’t the issue, it was the attitude of the owner. I will never go back in the shop either to sell or buy.

The items are outrageously overpriced, but I was considering getting a skirt that was on sale. Then, I overheard the owner trash talking the salt room business, that is next door to the consignment shop, and its clients with a customer. Very unprofessional. I decided to leave and the owner seemed irritated that I didn't purchase anything. Incredibly rude owner!

I was not impressed by the arrogance of the owner who mentioned that the clothes came from skiers who were there as second home owners, etc, etc . Nothing was upscale other than her intentional snootiness.